drjones,
LOL....to each his own -- or, as Mick said on "The Other Forum":
There's a seat to fit every ass.
For me, although I have an inherent love of BIG folders (my dream is to steal a Blackwood Skirmish off the secondary market some day), I find that for my EDC as a limp-wristed, pencil-necked, white-collar paper-pusher whose job/school atmosphere favors particularly more flimsy "dress" wear -- to be more suited to "lighter" weight folders, regardless of size.
My current EDC is a RJ Martin Avenger. No small knife, by any means -- 4 and 1/4 inch blade, 9 and 7/16 OAL as compared to the AR/GBs 9 inch OAL and 4 inch blade -- but it's very, very light by comparison.
So I guess I should modify my statement:
For me -- it's about size
and weight.
With the AR/GB, they're not all that big nor excessively bulky -- but they combine that with being heavy. The tanks that they are, you can't blame them for it, but it's just a bit too heavy for my dress needs and that exacerbates their overall bulkiness.
For me, the SnGs ride along the perfect size/mass edge.
I'm gonna have to try out a SMF.
Allen
aka DumboRAT