Strider sng vs large sebenza

[Bronco]

FWIW, I have both Strider and Sebenza folders. Two Sebenzas, in fact, a large and a small. The Sebbies pretty much stick to the same old boring script. Fit and finish was perfect as purchased and has remained so throughout the ensuing decade. Cutting efficiency is very high and there's something refreshing about a manufacturer who not only encourages you to take apart their folder if you so desire, but even gives you the tool to do so.

The Strider, of course, sports a much blockier handle design than the Sebbie. That's not to say it's uncomfortable, however. In fact, I find the ergos to be more than acceptable for the majority of my purposes. The thicker blade cross section renders it less of a slicer in comparison to the Sebbie. The flip side to that is that the blade can theoretically handle tougher tasks. Unfortunately, in my experience, the handle construction and fit don't really inspire great confidence in pushing the knife to its limits. Things were fine initially. But over time, the blade no longer centers between the scales when closed. More distressing is the blade play that has developed. At this point there is no adjustment to the pivot screw possible that will both eliminate blade play and allow for smooth opening. I leave just a bit of wobble so that I can open the blade and have found that the blade is fairly stable once locked - at least good enough for routine tasks.

 

[Lycosa]

If I may, you might want to try an Emerson, R.I.L., aka, framelock. These folder are SO nice.
I don't think my HD7 is going to leave my pocket any time soon.

 

[JNewell]

Polar opposites, in terms of what users generally look for.

Strider if you plan to pry open car doors, prefer tacticool designs, and don't mind less-than-perfect fit and finish, sticky locks and lock wear.

Striders often develop play with time, but Sebenzas effectively never do.

A Sebenza is more practical for EDC use. Go for it if you can appreciate incredible fit and finish, tight tolerances, and a lock that will last a lifetime.

Strider's QC may be hit or miss, I don't know. I've only ever owned a SNG and a SJ75. However, both are flawless. Any lockrock was pretty much alleviated once broken in. Neither has blade play, they both center perfectly, overall they are nothing short of fantastic in every way. Maybe I got lucky, but from my experience, Striders are top shelf.

The Sebenza needs no review. They're perfection, period.

You can't go wrong with either. Try them both in your hands before you make a decision.

I have both, like both. I would only buy Strider from an AD. Yes, they can have vertical blade play fresh out of the box, ooops, baggie.

 

[Hairlesstwinkie]

I owned both. I've had 6 different Sebenzas coming and going. I can't keep any to save my life. They are just not that special to me. I don't like the ergos on them either. They are good knives with top notch fit and finish, but they're boring.

I still have my SnG. It offers something different in my collection because I don't really own anything else like it. The profile is distinct and it's build tough. Z-wear is a fantastic steel. Fit and finish is a hit or miss thing, but for a knife like the SnG, it really doesn't need refinement.

Go to the show and handle it in person to see if the ergos is right for you. Do your homework on prices and spotting fakes so you won't get ripped off. good luck and have fun!

 

[red mag]

I wouldn't buy a knife that has bladeplay. Take your time. A SnG is readily avaliable online these days.
Decisions under pressure of time ring an alarm-bell.
hope this helps
red mag

 

[efreedma]

I had this same dilemma about 6 months ago. Strider SMF or a Sebenza 25. I ended up going with the Sebenza 25 and to be honest it sat in my safe for 6 months. I was afraid to carry it. After a little pep talk from some forum members I put it in my pocket and have not looked back since. Granted it has only been 5 days, but it will be in my pocket for the foreseeable future. Fit and finish on my 25 is perfect, lockup is at about 75% and solid as a rock. The Sebenza is just a great pocket knife that won't let you down. Plus it looks beautiful and I get comments on it everytime I pull it out.

 

[murfdog67]

Polar opposites, in terms of what users generally look for.

Strider if you plan to pry open car doors, prefer tacticool designs, and don't mind less-than-perfect fit and finish, sticky locks and lock wear.

Striders often develop play with time, but Sebenzas effectively never do.

A Sebenza is more practical for EDC use. Go for it if you can appreciate incredible fit and finish, tight tolerances, and a lock that will last a lifetime.

I strongly agree. I carried a Strider on duty for years, actually met Mick Strider. It is a hands down no Bullshit workhorse. If you can break it, Mick will replace it the end. Now, having said that I would much prefer to carry a CRK Sabenza now. It is simplicity perfectly executed. It will be your best friend and never let you down. It will also not scare the crap out of people when you need to deploy it in a non combat situation. Lol. Basically IMHO they are both at the top of their games, Strider is a tactical tool, Sabenza an edc genius.

 

[pnsxyr]

Strider is the knife you can do anything with and have it survive. For its intended usage, it is a great knife. I think their fit and finish is good, although not comparable to CRK. Their steels favor toughness over the highest possible edge retention, which is great relative to the purpose of the knife. The grind favors strength as well, but at the expense of fine cutting/slicing tasks. It has a large carry profile which has always made it not a very practical EDC for me, as I prefer small form factors.

CRK makes a knife capable of tough work, but not on the scale of a Strider. They favor fit, finish, and compact form factor. They also tend to harden their steel a little softer than many. The hollow grinds on the Sebs (excluding the 25 which is technically a high flat grind) do not have a lot of edge strength, but they slice super well when sharp. The insignio blade is plain awesome. The form factor of the Seb is about as compact as folding knives of their respective sizes can be.



I like both knives but if it were me personally it would be something other than either of them given that they are in a price range that opens up the door to many different options including custom/semi-custom knives that I feel are better values, sometimes meet usage needs better, and are from companies which I think are more enjoyable to deal with/interact with. That last part is not to say Chris Reeve or Strider have poor customer service...but it is to say that my own interaction with custom makes has left me feeling that they go to further lengths for their customers, they go out of the way to be 100% they get the job right on the first go, and they are extremely appreciative of business (it's unlikely one will have interaction with Chris Reeve or Mick Strider at this level).

I think the SNG, Sebenza, and XM-18 are all awesome knives (and they get a ton of press/discussion/praise). However, as I noted in another thread not long ago, I think the Project VECP and El Patron are nicer knives and priced in the same range than the above (and sometimes lower than the above).

 

[red mag]

How did you deceide?

 

[Zerolessmusic]

Update:

I have decided to wait a little longer and get a brand new Sebenza (large 21 w/ micarta inlays) instead of the used strider... The strider was used and $300, Not much of a price difference plus I think I would of had to send it to strider right away ($25-$30) plus getting back into the gun show it was at (another $10) and at that point, I decided I would rather buy new anyways..... But, like I said, just waiting it out and gonna get the sebenza. Looks to fit my needs alot more, although after the sebenza I might need to get a strider as well . Thanks for all the responses and the time spent!

(Note: sorry I was not responding, but I was reading!)

 

[yakstone]

You will end up with both

 

[630skirmish]

Fit and finish on striders are actually really good ever since they started using the new lock face. Both knives are totally polar opposite so it depends on what u like. Personally I am not a Sebenza fan because it lacks ergos, as oppose to strider which has great ergos.uf your concerned with comfort in the pocket go with concealed carry SnG.

 

[dcmartin]

Strider sng vs large sebenza... and why..... facts and opinions are both appreciated. Really need to know by tomorrow(for reasons of the strider is at a gun show).... Also.... do strider sngs tend to have up and down blade play? Or would I have to send it to strider?

I have both and I wouldn't get rid of either one. If you can, take your time and get an SnG CC. The profile is thinner and it sits well in the pocket... If it develops lock rock send it in, it's not the end of the world. I don't think I'll ever buy another Lego strider... I much prefer the CC or the DGG because of the contoured scales. The Sebbie is just perfection and seeing as you can pick up a used 25 in the $320 to $340 range on the exchange, not a bad deal. Or to remove any doubt, just get a new one.
Post some pix of the Sebbie when you get it! Happy Hunting!

 

[Zerolessmusic]

Here is the sebbie I bought, I love it!

Oh... and I also have Already looked at my second... Although I can't afford it, At some point it will be a small carbon fiber insingo as an EDC.

 

[dasknife]

I've had both, the only one that remains is my sng dgg (current gen). No lock rock. Reprofiled to 20 to 22 per side and it's perfect. My opinion is the ergos are better than the crk, however the crk would probably be better for office or lighter duties. Been eyeing the 25 lately but wouldn't mind a smf either.

 

[control circult]

I own a SnG cc 3/4 and a standard large sebenza 21. Both are trustworthy and durable,never worried the locks to fail. The sebenza is more fine and suits city EDC better(goes well with a suit and tie); the SnG is more tactical and offers a sense of manhood...however I prefer CTS-XHP to S35VN so if there's really a guy holding me at gunpoint and force me to make a choice, then it is this Sng cc.