Something that would keep me away from a first Strider Knife.
I can't speak for Strider Knives any more than as an owner. Their policy is their choice, their business. I have read plenty of threads complaining about cosmetic problems sent back as warranty repair, or issues with certain characteristics of the various knives owners were disappointed in, or disapproved of, and they returned them as warranty defects.
In my opinion, these specific issues - cosmetics, or different opinions about the functioning of the knife - do not constitute a valid warranty repair. They do represent a misunderstanding of the nature of the knife's design, it's use, and the knife buyer's expectations. Again, in my opinion, some knife buyers thought they were getting an expensive, hand crafted, custom, perfectly fitted and finished art blade to show off their discriminating taste.
A Strider? It's an expensive, best materials and top of the line design hard use beater, folks, sold to users who need a no-fail edged tool. My SnG shows it, rust on the blade, clip worn rubbing on angle iron CNC carts, G10 edges getting that Case "pocketworn" look, the Ti flame finish wearing off the exposed handle above the seam. I've had it a year, and the previous owner probably wouldnt' even recognize it now.
Real users with broken knives get a lifetime repair and refurb courtesy the makers - which doesn't happen all that often. Those who collect, never use them, and haven't been raising a howl of protest about the fee when they send in their safe queens "to the spa" for a complete cosmetic makeover. They understand the real users may even get free shipping back - often to their duty station. It's a hard use knife company serving hard users; the monied collectors are just glad to get in on it.
If you really need a Strider, $15 to get it back is no big deal - and certainly not a show stopper. It's the cash for the third or fourth that slows you down. . .