Stuart Mitchell "Survival Knife" Prototype (Pic Heavy)

Joined
Feb 6, 2010
Messages
64
I found myself in the lucky position to try out this new Stuart Mitchell Survival Knife prototype during a recent trip.
Number 476 is made from 5mm RWL34, has a full flat grind and retains its thickness throughout the tang. The blade itself is approximately 10 centimeters long.
Needless to say, it is a beefy and very strong knife. Seen here next to an old style Paramillie for size comparison, the knife has a spearpoint configuration and two large lashing tubes in the handle.
The balance point is right at the forward lashing hole.

DSC_0019-1.jpg


The handle itself has a high visibility layer of orange G10 sandwiched between the tang and a rough black canvas micarta scale. The big flared "pommel" lets you grip the knife with your thumb and forefinger, so that the entire knife can be used with extended leverage. The pommel also makes for a very comfortable thumb rest in reverse grip.
The micarta has lots of texture and is grippy even when wet. The interior diameter of the lashing tubes is 7,5mm.

DSC_0014-9.jpg


This is helpful when lashing the knife to a pole. Standard sized paracord can be doubled up and slipped comfortably through the tubes to create loops.
Slide your pole through the loops, tighten them and you have a very solid spear point. The choil and the flared pommel prevent your paracord from moving.
The knife point is in line with the lashing holes, making it all quite stable and well balanced.

DSC_0001-33.jpg

DSC_0003-21.jpg


This knife has a bolster that was constructed to take a beating. Stu used no less than 5 pins to secure it to the tang. He wanted me to see if it would stand up to some abuse, so I used the top part of the bolster to hammer a variety of metal and stone objects... Hammering (or pounding, whichever word you prefer) with the bolster feels much more natural than hammering with a pommel plate. You get the added benefit of a handle, which aids in aim and downward force. The bolster held up very well, even though it suffered from a bit of pitting and scratching.

DSC_0017-4.jpg

DSC_0009-15.jpg

DSC_0008-17.jpg

DSC_0006-21.jpg


The bead blasted finish on the knife suffered a bit from use. In any future versions, I think I would prefer a satin finish.
I found the point of the blade to be the strongest I have seen on a fixed blade knife of these dimensions. The spine retains its thickness for a good 7 centimeters and then tapers slightly to the tip.
I still measured 2mm of steel right behind the spear point. Nonetheless, the point is sharp enough to make small and precise puncture holes in leather and fabrics.
It was also strong enough to drill holes in hardwood without having the slightest worry about damaging the tip.

DSC_0010-13.jpg

DSC_0011-12.jpg


The prototype was used daily in this heavenly topography. Some of these lakes are accessible only by (float)plane.
Some of our gear and means of transportation needed to ride outside the airplane. I made sure to double check the knots!

DSC_0047.jpg


This knife is thick and strong. The full flat grind helped its slicing ability but shaving feathersticks will never be its forte.
Nonetheless, these came out reasonably thin and without too much effort.

DSC_0046.jpg


Put your knife down somewhere on these rocks or near the trees and you will have a difficult time relocating your property in the low sunlight.
The orange G10 really made a big difference and I never once misplaced it. I dropped it in a river once and although the water was a scant 4 inches deep where I lost it, the orange streak made it so much easier to spot between the rocks and the sand.

DSC_0021-2.jpg

DSC_0049-1.jpg

DSC_0016-5.jpg


We argued with our pilot about aerodynamics and float planes. In the end he agreed to transport the boat with the bow facing the slipstream.
In his defence, judging by the speed with which we were ambling over the countryside, it would not have made the slightest difference anyway...

DSC_0045.jpg


Seafood a plenty. You catch it or you buy it from the local fishermen. The salmon comes in all varieties, and its all good!

DSC_00012.jpg


I had given some thought to the kydex sheath. A nicely rounded kydex sheath is useful as a digging implement. Another good use is to tape a sewing needle and maybe some fishing hooks or safety pins to the sheath before wrapping a length of paracord around it all. With my failing eyesight I also needed one of those loopy things that help old men thread the line through the needle's eye :|.
A 6 foot length of paracord gives you 7 X 6 foot strands of thread that you can use to repair just about anything. Even if you use up the entire 7 strand core of your paracord, the outer sleeve is still plenty strong for most tasks. You can pick up one of these curved sewing needles at your local supermarket.

DSC_0005-23.jpg


Salt water mussels nearer St. Lawrence. The spine of the knife is very angular, making it perfect for scraping firesteels and bark tinder.

DSC_0023.jpg


This female moose couldn't be bothered by our presence. Magnificent sight to see them up close and personal.
Even though it was trampling through a fishermans trapping area.

I thoroughly enjoyed my time with this excellent knife and hope you enjoyed reading about it.
Thanks to Stu Mitchell for letting me have a go.

DSC_0048.jpg


Link to his website here: www.stuartmitchellknives.com
 
Hi folks, thanks for the kind remarks, speaking as a maker it is great to see the knives you make put through their paces, even better in a review as well put together and photographed as this one is, thanks for it Nightfly...

The knife is set to visit at least another two 'users', one of them will again put to various Bushcraft/Survival tasks, the other predominantly carcass work, particularly Deer...

Thanks again, I'll keep you posted...

Stuart.
 
Hi folks, thanks for the kind remarks, speaking as a maker it is great to see the knives you make put through their paces, even better in a review as well put together and photographed as this one is, thanks for it Nightfly...

The knife is set to visit at least another two 'users', one of them will again put to various Bushcraft/Survival tasks, the other predominantly carcass work, particularly Deer...

Thanks again, I'll keep you posted...

Stuart.

Beautiful-looking knife Stuart, and a very practical-looking field utility knife I'm sure. I like the flat grind, the length, the in-line spear-point, the pommel, the finger cut-out, the lashing holes, handle material, the orange liner, what's not to like?! I thought it was an 'integral' at first, which I've always been a fan of, and was wondering how you'd done it. I see it's actually a separate bolster, but the finish looks flawless. I like the square corners too, and the slight thumb-ramp. All very practical features, nicely executed. Good luck with it. Nice review and beautiful pictures Nightfly.

On the subject of "survival knives", I came across this recently and thought you might like it for your scrap-book Stuart.



All the best

Jack
 
Last edited:
Hi all, quick thread resurrection here...

As the title suggest the knife in here was indeed a prototype, through various field test, by various folk, a few useful modifications were identified, we now have MkII, hopefully addressing these...

The changes....

1: The edge was to be brought back, slightly intersecting the finger notch, bringing that valuable business end, right by the grip, right where you need it...
2: The bolster was to get a through hole, 1/4" is as much as I can safely get in there, bearing in mind there are 4 x 1/8" pins in there too, 1/4" is ample, but I'd rather not see smaller, there though...
3: A satin finish, not the blasted one, for the blade...
4: The most important for me and one I was keen to see work, I wanted to introduce a more Busse like tube/fixing, the Proto relied solely on epoxy, I was looking for belt and braces here... I didn't want a full flared Busse style, they do that well and it makes for a great fixing, I hoped to keep it a little more akin to my prototytpe, more a cross between where we were and the Busse, the tubes in 'Secare' are 10mm stainless, 0.8mm walled, slightly flared into those recesses in the Micarta, the recess cause no discomfort, if anything they add grip...

This particular mod was the cause of some thought by me, it wasn't exactly straight forward to do in a handle with so much shaping, all done by hand and so with differences from knife to knife, the way I saw it the grip really needs shaping and finishing pre adding the tubes, to enable this I was reliant on epoxy only, no mechanical fastenings in the scales at all, for much of the build...

Here's it pre tubes...

4851.jpg


I was quite impressed by that, just the epoxy, it even survived a drop...

From there though, countersink the Micarta, squeeze the tubes into place with a wipe of more epoxy then flare the ends, that 0.8mm walled tube takes some flaring, it is not minded to go back without a fight, the whole thing is very, very strong...

So, here's it, 'Secare'...

4851-1.jpg


4852-1.jpg


4853.jpg


And here's why I was keen for the bolster hole to be 1/4", two thickness's of Paracord...

download.jpg
 
Very pretty, especially the satin-treatment and cleaning up the heel of the blade (now choilless dropped heel) :thumbup::thumbup:


But personally, I prefer it without the bolster-hole :thumbdn:. The two in the handle are enough to string it securely to some fingers or a stick. But putting cord through the bolster just impedes finger placement where you might want it most... and the weakness issue, though I assume that isn't a cause for worry. Anyway, just my opinion.

Thanx for bringing this thread back up, keeps this knife on my radar....
 
Nightly thanks for a very well done review!

Stuart that is an exceptional design, very well done!
 
Thanks for the comments guys.
Yesterday Stuart finished my MkII version of Secare and sent me these pictures to hold me over until I get a chance to look over and try out the changes from the prototype used in this review.
It is now on its way to be sheathed by Martin Swinkels in the Netherlands.
More after I have had some time to use it!

securedownload-5.jpg

securedownload-2.jpg

securedownload.jpg

securedownload-4.jpg

securedownload-1.jpg

securedownload-3.jpg
 
He's updating it I think, but here is the link:

<link removed>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Martin Swinkels did the sheath for this one. The partial orange liners are mostly hidden by kydex but still perform the task of relocating the knife in snow etc very well.
The smaller hole through the bolster houses an 18mm Scout firesteel. It is small, but still long enough to get a decent grip. Clear lacquer seals it in, you need to use a stick or a stone to dislodge it. The idea is to only use it in a pinch (after use it won't fit as snugly anymore either).
Size comparison against a Bayley S4 from the Man vs. Wild shows. Thanks for looking!

DSC_00222_zpsf5df6ae2.jpg

DSC_00214_zpsa7b8ccdb.jpg

DSC_00204_zps7c98fda1.jpg

DSC_00233_zps76be6eb7.jpg

DSC_00215_zps39f7b06c.jpg

DSC03071_zps4f31c862.jpg
 
Thanks for the look. That is a great looking package. What a wonderful place to test it.
 
Thanks for the kind words fellas, I have a small batch of these on the go in the 'shop at present, I'll post up some photos as they become finished...

Cheers, Stu.
 
Back
Top