Suggestions for 8" fixed blade, large hilt

Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Messages
322
I welcome any recommendations for a fixed blade knife with the following 4 features:

Blade length approx. 8 inches.
Blade shaped for stabbing, such as spear point.
Large hilt and rubberized handle, for sure grip in rainy weather and/or covered with blood.
At least reasonably rust-resistant steel.

Purpose: animal defence while hiking and fishing in a rainforest wilderness area that has a very high population of mountain lions and bears.

Thanks in advance, bladesters!
 
Let me be the first to suggest a Winchester Mod. 70 in .30-06. You are not looking for a knife with the criteria you listed.


Steve
 
I would suggest a Smith & Wesson Model 25 Mountain Gun in .45 long Colt and a Bark River Classic Green River Sheep Skinner. Personally, I would never go into a remote wilderness with just a knife as protection. Mountain Lions and Bears are a 1000 times more proficient with "their knives" than humans will ever be.
pix3108917218.jpg

Sheep.Ant.Ivory.MP.jpg
 
I won't suggest a .50AE Desert Eagle :D ...(I have one, and it's too big & heavy of a pistol to pack around all day on a hike)...But then, if you ARE going to be around large hungry bears... :thumbup:

A Cold Steel Trailmaster bowie would be a good choice for a knife.
 
Wow! My post is hijacked already! Please, dear bladesters, I did not post that I want to discuss guns, spears, or the dangers of animals! I have "some" experience and knowledge of those subjects, firsthand, and for longer than I want to admit. :(

I'm simply looking to upgrade my "last ditch" survival tool here, for times when my gun is out of reach, or has been knocked aside by the attacking animal, or I've been jumped in dense bush without time to shoot my gun or spray with bear spray, etc.

Thank you!
 
glockman99 said:
A Cold Steel Trailmaster bowie would be a good choice for a knife.

I had a look at that one, Glockman, and it's just the kind of tool I'm looking for. Thanks for that.
BTW, I see you live just few hundred miles south of me, so you know what I'm talking about!
 
How about a BK9, Rtak 10" or one of the Ranger Detatchement Knives. All are reasonably priced and should suit your needs. On the low price end how about a Cold Steel Bushman. Wipe down the blades with Sentry Solutions Tuf cloth, for protection.
Art
 
I suggest a box of Snarol.

All trolls are speared ruthlessly by the Troll Predator armed with the Terrible Speargun of Knife Collector Wit.
 
I second the Trailmaster, also the Becker BK 9, or CS Recon Tanto. Any of these should fill the bill for what you are looking for. Also, there are several sub hilt fighters out there that might be worth a look at also.
 
Eight inch blade is simply too small.

At least go for the Cold Steel XII Tanto......that's a 12 inch blade.

When you have a large bear chewing on your head you will wish you had more.

:D
 
Based on Pogo (I think it's Pogo, maybe Pongo, don't recall for sure) 's posts about killing racoons, he has found that you need a very sharp tip to actually push through tough hide. So I think that the BK9, Recon Tanto (7" blade anyway), and Trailmaster might not be your best bet. Certainly I wouldn't want to try to stab a wildcat with any of those! Maybe that S&W after filing the point to make it super-pointy. Cold Steel also makes a kraton-handled version of the black bear that is cheaper, the OSS with carbon V steel but it has a rust-resistant blade coating: http://www.knifeworks.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=4773. There's also the Blackjack Anaconda: http://www.knifeworks.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=5302. However I think you're looking for something lighter & with a slimmer profile like the OSS, with an emphasis on stabbability rather than chopping.

edited to add - (Pogo the) Possum.
 
Cold Steel Bushman, nice deep belly with piercing tip. Have you thought about a tomahawk? Much more devastating blows as opposed to close up thrusts.
 
I'm getting some great ideas here....thanks everyone!

fishface5 said:
...need a very sharp tip to actually push through tough hide....I think you're looking for something lighter & with a slimmer profile like the OSS, with an emphasis on stabbability rather than chopping.

Right on, Fishface5. What I need is slim & sharp, very fast, and 100% positive grip (even with cold, wet, gloved hands; I fish fall salmon & winter steelhead), so it HAS to have a big hilt. Oh, and not too heavy, because it's going on my belt that already has 2 large bear sprays on it.

I've got a bit of a list now!

I'm really interested in the Meula MI-90057, but the only supplier I've found on the net won't ship to me here in Canada: http://www.ndsproducts.com/muela.html
(12th knive up from the bottom) It has a MOST excellent hilt. I do wonder about the steel, though, at that low price.

Others on my list:
S&W Search & Rescue: http://www.shoplite.com/smithwesson178.htm#10536
Cold Steel OSS: http://www.knifeworks.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=4773
SOG Tigershark: http://www.sogknives.com/tigersh.htm
Camillus Bayonet #CAM1A1: http://www.camillusknives.com/1mainframe.htm
Meula Tactical Fixed Blade Black Cast Guard: http://www.swordsofhonor.com/tacfixbladbl1.html

Decisions, decisions!
 
Pocketknife said:
Purpose: animal defence while hiking and fishing in a rainforest wilderness area that has a very high population of mountain lions and bears.

Where exactly is this you're going, if you don't mind my asking?
 
Not where I'm going; where I live! Vancouver Island. For those not familiar with geography, that is off the southwest coast of British Columbia, which is Canada's westernmost province. Vancouver Island has the highest density of cougars of any area in N.America.

We've already had 2 cougar attacks this year, not far from where I live. We have several attacks every year. I have personally seen cougars in the wild, which did not attack me, but I know a fellow who was. He now wears a cap that says "Cougar Bait" on it!!!! Oh yeah, last year a logger saved himself from an attacking cougar with only his Buck folder....very lucky.

Cougars are much more predictable than bears, when it comes to attacks on humans. Look at a house cat; at it's automatic, instinctual "stalk-pounce-eat" behaviour. That is what cats do. They cannot help it, because they are carnivores. Because they only eat meat, they are programmed to kill other animals, given any opportunity. Smaller animals, like deer fawns and human children, are especially attractive to cougars, since they prefer victims, not challenges. But, when they must eat, they will take down whatever is available. Because their only goal is to kill you, rather than merely chase you away from their young (like some bears), you will die if you do not fight back.

Our cougar population is increasing here, just as it is all over western N.America, contrary to popular belief. Extremist "preservationist" environmental groups would have us believe they are endangered, but that is a lie. And, cougar attacks have been increasing over the past 10 or 15 years.

These environmentalist groups would also have us believe that most bear attacks on people are caused by people doing something "wrong". They ignore the fact that bears are PREDATORS...hello!!!

B.C.'s bear population is also increasing, due to government policies influenced by environmentalist groups' pressure, which have resulted in things like hunting bans, and restrictions on the authority of wildlife officers in dealing with problem animals.

Oh, and we also have many wolves here. Wolves have attacked loggers and hunters in the recent past.

So there you go....this is where I live and play! And I wouldn't live anywhere else!
 
Back
Top