Esav Benyamin
MidniteSuperMod
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2000
- Messages
- 90,915
vactor, I think they treat knives over there the way we treat firearms in many places: you can bring them, but locked, separate from ammunition, etc. You can't just walk around wearing them.
The obvious logical problem is what the others have said: the law only hampers honest citizens from using knives responsibly. It does nothing to stop criminals.
The solution is to criminalize socially unwelcome behavior, like murder
and not worry about what people own and carry around. But laws on the books are hard to repeal, even when the pendulum of social understanding swings back to a different mindset.
Abadir, my apologies. I didn't mean to challenge your opinion, only get a more specific reference. The laws already on the books can be intrusive enough. I doubt any Patriot Act is going to change policing noticeably. The problem is more one of Federalization of crimes anyway.
The obvious logical problem is what the others have said: the law only hampers honest citizens from using knives responsibly. It does nothing to stop criminals.
The solution is to criminalize socially unwelcome behavior, like murder

Abadir, my apologies. I didn't mean to challenge your opinion, only get a more specific reference. The laws already on the books can be intrusive enough. I doubt any Patriot Act is going to change policing noticeably. The problem is more one of Federalization of crimes anyway.