Thanks Atavist. New and strange alloys can have great properties, but it takes a bunch of research and experimentation to figure out how to bring out those properties. Grade 5 titanium alloy is about 4% vanadium and 6% aluminum, which makes it way different than pure titanium, just like alloying elements dramatically change the properties of pure iron. The beta stuff I'm using right now is alloyed with 10% niobium, which is very heavy and makes the alloy beta metastable and highly heat-treatable, not to mention it's small amount of iron alloyed within, that has as strong of an effect on titanium as small amounts of carbon has on iron!
The one thing that seems to have the most dramatic and positive effect on titanium alloys, though, is simply the long process of hammering out the titanium billet. Without being hammered out, the metal really does seem to be a bit soft to hold up to hard, abusive strikes when it's ground thin!