Testing my knife.

J

Johnbeck180

Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
199
Well, I'm probably going to take my knife through the durability test then 90 degree bend this weekend. Anyone have any tips? I do not expect to pass because this is my first time trying, but I'm still pretty excited.
 
Wrong attitude Sir,Expect every knife to pass,do the best you can to make it pass,Then if it fails figure out why and do your best to correct it.
Good luck with your testing.And let us know how it went.
Stan
 
Good advice from Stan. Always think a little past "Positive"

If you set your mind to it, then it will happen.

Robert
 
You guys are right, what I should have said was: my knife has Been made to the best of my knowledge and ability, if it fails then I will try to understand why an fix it. :0) thank you. I will reset my frame of mind.
 
You can do both, post links and insert the videos. of course I don't know how, but I've seen it.

Red
 
Keep as accurate notes as possible! use a torque wrench to see how much force is required to flex it. not just how well it cut, but how many cuts it took to quit shaving, then how many cuts to quit agressively cutting, on a bathroom scale to measure force for each cut. how many edge flexes and if the edge bent over or chipped out and on what number of fledge flexes it happened. test the tip by concrete floor test, hammering it into mild steel. anything and every test you can think of, but keep those notes in a place where you wont lose them.

As the others said, believe that it will pass! Not just one 90 degree bend, but several! dont forget to use wood blocks between the blade and the jaws of the vise, and your safety glasses!
 
Are you attempting the ABS Journeyman Smith Performance Test?
If so, did you make a knife to pass the test or are you puting a knife through the test? IMO, there is a big difference.
See edit in post#11
 
Last edited:
Rick Marchand said:
Are you attempting the ABS Journeyman Smith Performance Test?
If so, did you make a knife to pass the test or are you puting a knife through the test? IMO, there is a big difference.
Click to expand...

I made the knife that I will use in the test. Im just doing it on my own to see if I can produce a good usable/durable/flexible knife. I'll have a friend of mine who has made knives for several years there to watch. It won't count towards anything except me saying: yup I did it or, me saying that one didn't work. I should have clarified this in the first post. Sorry about that.
 
Johnbeck180 said:
I made the knife that I will use in the test. Im just doing it on my own to see if I can produce a good usable/durable/flexible knife. I'll have a friend of mine who has made knives for several years there to watch. It won't count towards anything except me saying: yup I did it or, me saying that one didn't work. I should have clarified this in the first post. Sorry about that.
Click to expand...

Actally I should clarify my statement....
Did you make a knife to pass the test or are you puting a knife you made through the test?

The difference being that the JS Test was not made to test the quality of a knife but rather the skill of the maker. The fact that a knife can pass the test does not necessarily make it a good knife. The goal is to see if the maker has control over heat and geometry. To cut and stay sharp, the steel must be hard but tempered... For the knife to be flexed 90deg, it must be soft and ductile... Two extremes in one blade... THAT is the test. I know of only a few makers who see the JS Test as anything more than jumping through hoops to display specific skills to a board of bladesmiths.

All I am saying is please don't feel the need to judge the quality of your knives by this test. It is set up like this for a reason and that reason has little to do with what is expected from knives in the real world. Have fun but don't take it too seriously.
 
Rick Marchand said:
Actally I should clarify my statement....
Did you make a knife to pass the test or are you puting a knife you made through the test?

The difference being that the JS Test was not made to test the quality of a knife but rather the skill of the maker. The fact that a knife can pass the test does not necessarily make it a good knife. The goal is to see if the maker has control over heat and geometry. To cut and stay sharp, the steel must be hard but tempered... For the knife to be flexed 90deg, it must be soft and ductile... Two extremes in one blade... THAT is the test. I know of only a few makers who see the JS Test as anything more than jumping through hoops to display specific skills to a board of bladesmiths.

All I am saying is please don't feel the need to judge the quality of your knives by this test. It is set up like this for a reason and that reason has little to do with what is expected from knives in the real world. Have fun but don't take it too seriously.
Click to expand...

Rick: I completely understand what your saying. I just want to do this for my own understanding of what I need to do to produce a better knife. I'm just trying to hone my skills a bit better. BTW sorry for the delayed reply, I've been dealing with some. job related issues, unfortunately I lost my job today. I have a wife a two kids to watch over. Sorry all unfortunately I won't test my knife this weekend, I'll be looking for a job.(worried!!!!) :0(

BTW, had the privilege or eyeing you knives on your site. The Lore-snub it cool!
 
Last edited:
John,
Just to be sure you understand, making a knife that will pass the ABS test is not intended to make a better knife. It is to make a better smith who does his own forging and HT. The knife is made not to test the knife but to test the smith. The knives used to judge the quality of the maker's knives ( after passing the bend test) would not pass this test. Some disagree, but a well made knife should not pass this test.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top