TF's Leather

Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
3,346
This is just a post i made in the Fiddleback passaround thread, but i copied it here for everone to see.

Normally, i dont pay to much attention to the sheaths on passaround knives, but the extreme quality of this sheath warrants a review all its own. That, and the fact that no one has really reviewed TF's leather yet are the primary reasons for this seperate reveiw.

The sheath:

3453939728_21ab42e3ed.jpg


3453274651_9d955f44b8.jpg


TF's leatherwork is quite a surprise to most people. He started working leather maybe a month ago, and it is already better than my sorry attempts at leathercraft, which i have been doing for a while. So, TF has obviously got a nack for this leather working stuff.

The sheath has a very solid tight fit. once the knife is in there, i dont think the knife will slip out. The Way he treated the leather makes the knife click in, very much like kydex.
3453950578_7887864cf3.jpg


He had also encorperates a couple of different carry options: a drop loop, and the more traditional belt carry. I used the drop loop the whole time because that is just my preference, but i am sure that the other method is equally comforable. To swich between carry options, all you have to do is undo the chicago screw on the back; a simple and functional design.
One of my peices of advice would be to make the belt loop on the back a little wider. I tested my 2 belts and neither would fit. But i wear wide western type belts, so that isnt really a huge surprise.
The carry options:
3453138273_a2a29621bd.jpg


The sheath has an intigrated fire-steel loop, like alot of the modern bushcraft sheaths tend to. It sturdily holds the standard LMF army firesteel, and would probably hold other styles of similar thickness.

The sheath is very well finished and the sides are very smoothed out. Great attention to detail.
smooth edges:
3453128371_2c89d82897.jpg


two other bits of advise; one would be to add a drainage hole. nothing major, but i would like the sheath to have one. the other thing is visible in the pic below. see how the two end stitches go on the outside of the beltloop? this is somthing that i would try to avoid. This would probably never cause any issues, but the exposed thread seems much more likely to get cut or snag on somthing. i dont know if this explaination makes any sense, but tell me if it dosent and ill try to explain better.
3454076386_ff8963d72a.jpg

Not much else to say really. The sheath is beyond fantastic, and its quality is quite comparable to the knife it houses.

Hope you enjoyed,
~Brendan
 
Nice pics and an honest review. I see what you mean about your areas of concern. I 'd bet that Tal would be happy to accommodate any requests if he were making a sheath for you. That's the nice thing about custom makers.

Regarding the stitches in your last pic, I'd bet that it could be re-sewn leaving the two outer holes empty.

By the looks, it appears really well done. The forming around the handle scales looks
fantastic. Tal must've been working his bone tool quite a bit. I like how he's using darker dyes than many sheaths out there. It looks rich like fine Corinthian leather. I've yet to make my own sheath, but have the materials and the information. Too bad he's raised the bar for folks just getting into sheathmaking. I hope my first attempts look half as good as his.
 
Here is what I said on the other thread:

Great review on my sheath. Thanks SO MUCH.

The stitching going beyond the belt loop is what Al Stohlman recommends. It adds horizontal strength... but you are right it may be able to be snagged.

It is SO funny that you mention belt width. I have made almost all of my sheaths to accept 2 inch belts - but I made this one at 1 3/4 because so FEW people wear the big un's! Of course, you HAVE to be a hoss and wear the western stuff! Point taken and I will change that in the future.

The drain hole is always controversial in my research. But for a bushcrafter I would agree - it is probably a must have.

I am listening with wide ears - it is great to have a review of the leather work.

TF
 
Great review - I love to see honest reviews on here. I prefer my sheaths without a drainage hole. I'm not one to put my knife back in the sheath when it is sopping wet so it would be of little to no use with me. If I'm going to be in some sloppy weather/conditions I'll make sure to take a knife/sheath combo that is suitable to that environment.

You are right - the sides of that sheath look great. It's those little details that draw your eye.

In regards to the stitching on the loop, I would have probably never noticed had you not pointed it out so thank you. I really don't have an opinion one way or the other in regards to what that stitching does for the structural integrity of the sheath, but it looks darn cool like that ;)

Thanks for the pics and the review.
 
Great review! And, great sheath! I would completely agree as I have had the pleasure of giving one of these sheaths the once over, and they are very nice.

I would absolutely agree with the critiques though. Especially the stitching, should not come over the edge of the belt loop, or over the edge of any part of any leatherwork. The strength that is added is not enough to warrant exposure of the stitching to cuts and abrasion.

Otherwise great sheaths though, and great craftsmanship.
 
Back
Top