Hello all,
With a nice change in the weather, I was able to enjoy a long hike in this weekend. I took the opportunity to test my first Scandi grind from Andy (a Recluse, of course), and a new sheath that Rick made for this knife. I am posting a mini review of both below.
First the Recluse.
This particular knife has a tapered tang, and given that the Recluse has a narrower blade than the Bushfiger, it makes for a very light knife. If you are looking for a packable knife, with a longer 4" blade, this one should do nicely. As for the grind, I has able to thinly slice beef jerky with close to no resistance, so I agree that this type of grind is incredibly sharp and slices very well.
One observation I have for all my tapered handles, is that they tend to run a bit thinner. Andy has stated that he varies handle thickness on purpose, but I have found that most of my full thickness fiddlebacks tend to be thicker. The original specs for the knife are stabilized dyed curly Maple, Scandi on 1/8” thick steel.
Now the sheath.
This is my first sheath by Rick. I am lucky to have a number of sheaths made my Heber, so I decided to also try Rick's design. Rick's sheaths use a different retention mechanism. In the case of the Recluse, most of the friction happens at the "neck" of the knife, just before the blade starts, so I believe this is mostly what retains the knife. The blade also rides tight in the sheath, so there is a good chance that the blade contributes to holding the knife in place. The sheath is thin and compact, so you almost do not know it is there.
I asked Rick to provide a fire-steel and dangler with the sheath. The fire-steel loop is over 2 inches long, so it works better for longer rods. The dangler design is very well executed, since it has two buttons that allow you to slide it over your belt without unbuckling. I hiked for 5 hours with a pack and the sheath, I did not even know it was there.
First a picture of the front. The Recluse sits in the sheath with just the last pin exposed. This makes for fast and secure retrieval of the knife, but at the same time there is plenty of friction to hold it in place as discussed above. I asked Rick to move the fire-loop a bit higher, so 1/3 sits above the end of the stitches on the opposite side.
Now the back. Here you can see a square ring that is added before the belt loop is sewn. The ring attaches the dangler to the sheath using the two snap buttons to hold it in place. The top of the dangler is also wider than the base. Note I had the lanyard over the fire-steel loop, to keep it from snagging branches along the way. This is not needed to retain the knife.
This is how it carries with the dangler.
And now without the dangler. The belt loop allows for changing the angle from vertical as shown.
Thank you Andy and Rick for making the knife and the sheath, they will be used quite a bit going forward. I also plan to review Heber's design in detail in the future, since it also works very well. That is all for now,
GM