The good and the bad...

Benchmade 710: plain-edge, black blade, 154CM:
The Good:
Very comfortable in the hand.
The Axis-lock is awesome.
There's plenty of cutting edge.
The handle design is exceptionally nice.
The blade has a very nice slight recurve and slices very well.
Dual skeletonized steel liners and G-10 scales makes it plenty strong for anything required of a folder.
Excellent craftsmanship and very good fit-and-finish.

The Bad:
Tip-up carry only.
The handle could be just a tiny bit beefier or more hand-filling.
It needs a real choil instead of the odd space between blade and grip.
The backspacer should be G-10 as well instead of FRN (just for continuity if nothing else).
The thumbstuds are too close to the handle when closed and it makes it a little harder to open.

The Balance:
Truely a modern CLASSIC!
Simple a wonderful knife in both design and execution.


Spyderco Endura 4: plain-edge, no wave:
The Good:
VG-10 blade-steel!
Nice trimmed down pocket-clip.
Dual steel liners!!!
Tip-up/tip-down/left/right carry makes everyone happy. :thumbup:
Exceptional handle texturing.
Very affordable.

The Bad:
The new handle design does not feel as comfortable as the old Endura design in my opinion.
The thumbhole should be slightly larger, like the hole on the Pacific Salt.
And the larger thumb-ramp tractions grooves are better on the Pacific Salt too.

The Balance:
Without a doubt, the new Endura 4 is one of the best folders that Spyderco has ever produced.
It is destined to become another CLASSIC!
At this point in time, it's the only knife that can compete with my Pacific Salt for EDC status.
 
M16

The Good:
Decent steel
Decent price
Feels GREAT in the hand
Carson Design
THE FLIPPER

The BAD
COMBO EDGE ONLY on the AUS8 ones
How about that clip point blade?
The liner lock could be done better
I don't think the LAWKS is necessary on a good liner
 
cool. here is my take just for the heck of it.

M16-14D

the good:
AUS8 steel
good price
great feel
Lawks
great look
solid construction
great finish
considerably light
solid lockup

the bad:
to big for edc (almost 9in open)
the notches on the flipper can hurt the tip of ur finger when using it


as you can all see i am fairly easy to please
 
Great thread, I just dug this up while looking for info on the Benchmade 551 grip. It would be nice to see some more knives with the updated steels too. This thread was made when the Griptilians had 440C still, wow :eek:.

Hope you guys keep this thread going, really helpful.
 
Just goes to show everyone is different!

Me, I cannot stand the LAWKS, and the few liner locks I have, I have removed the LAWKS...

I own no knife that allows only tip-down carry...On those that do, I drill and tap for tip-up..

Very good reviews!
 
Great reviews!

CRKT Rollock II
Very heavy for such a small knife (mine in Stainless steel bolsters)
Pocket clip is weak

S-2 (small)
A fine knife in a small package.
When a small size, pointy is very useable.
 
Thread resurrected in the hope that others might add some quick down and dirty "good and bad" mini-reviews.
:)
 
Quote:
They look and feel cheap--they even sound cheap.
Somehow, they feel and look even cheaper than the FRN that Spyderco uses on the Endura.
And despite the texturing, they're still somewhat slippery.

That was exactly my first impression too. Here's what I wrote this April in a brief review:
Quote:
The lock design makes the knife worth $60, but I wish the handles were a different material. "Clicking" the handle with a fingernail makes a very chinzy and hollow sound, like cheap plastic. I'm sure it's plenty durable for my needs, but I'd rather it was the same material as the Spyderco Endura/Delica, or a 'grippy' rubber like a Gator.

Funny thing is, I've read other peoples' similar comments many times after buying my Griptillian. Oh well, I bought the knife for the mechanism, not the handles.

-Bob

I learned this the hard way with a Ritter Grip. For some reason (less hollow space?) it's not an issue on the Mini-Grip which has become my favorite EDC folder. Check it out!
 
Back
Top