The Journey Down to 3 - 2 - 1

Well in the past two weeks I've changed up my "collection" considerably so it's time to update this thread. My original post was on November 3, 2018, and I maintained that exact set of three knives until February 2020. So it was a solid run of 15 months with just those three. Long story short: I only own two knives now and they're both Benchmade Bugouts.

In February I caved and bought a second Benchmade Bugout--this time in the ranger green/grey color configuration--after about six months of thinking about it. I bought it simply because I liked the color combination, but it was also nice to know I'd have an immediate backup if something happened to my original blue Bugout. I bought it with the idea that it would be a test run though. I had been wanting that additional color combo for a long time even though I knew it made no logical sense to own two of the same knife. So I finally just bought it to see how it would play out and if I'd like having to make a choice every morning. I had both Bugouts on my EDC tray, and just grabbed whichever color I felt like carrying that day.

Fast forward to the last month or two, I'd been considering selling my Benchmade Mini Crooked River and Benchmade Puukko, and now I have finally sold both in the last two weeks. I think the Mini Crooked River is an absolutely beautiful knife. I love the look, the lines; I've just drawn to the beauty in it. And I enjoyed the feel in the hand and it's cutting ability. However, I had to come to terms with the fact I enjoy carrying the Bugout more. So there was no reason for me to own it; I can enjoy it's beauty while looking at others' pictures.

The Puukko was an awesome knife, and I have no doubt it could handle anything I'd ever throw at it. But a trip to the Smokey Mountains made me take a hard look at what I truly need. One of the results was I purchased a much smaller hiking pack and drastically cut down on the amount of stuff I carry. The Puukko was one of those things that got the boot. Honestly, I just have no real need for a fixed blade knife outside of the kitchen. I've pretty much owned fixed blades over the years because that's what you're supposed to do. But I've never had to baton wood with a knife, only done it once or twice just to mess around. I carry a gun for self defense. So up to this point in my life it has not been a need for me. So the Puukko was moved on to someone else that I hope can get much more use of it. Having said all that, I actually do have my eye on the new version of the Benchmade Steep Country set to come out in a couple months. I've been wanting to learn how to hunt for years, and I've finally got someone who is willing to take me on a deer hunt this fall. So maybe I'll have a need for a fixed blade after all. We'll see.

Currently I'm down to only two knives. Both of which happen to be Benchmade Bugouts, so it's kind of like I only own one knife. But there's been one other change in my knife carry. As I mentioned before, I've been carrying both the Bugouts; just choosing whichever color I felt like carrying that day. That is until about two weeks ago when I read an article in the Modern Huntsman titled Young Guns by Jillian Lukiwski. A few passages stood out to me, and I'll share one here. "Tools seem to be the face of tradition, the memories we can reach out and touch, the objects we press our faith into, the source of some superstition and luck. It's by using a tool of the hunting trade that we imbue it with story, purpose, history, and worth." This article resonated with me. To me it highlights one of the reasons I most enjoyed about EDCing the same knife every single day which is you gain a sense of familiarity with the knife and just feeling it in your palm brings back memories that it has been along the ride with you. So after a few minutes reflecting on that article, I placed the green/grey Bugout back into its box and in my safe. I wanted to get back to my one true EDC--the original blue Bugout. It might not last; I might decide I want the daily color choice again. Or maybe it will remain in my safe until such time that the blue one is worn out beyond usefulness. Only time will tell. But I will say I've enjoyed the past two weeks of getting back to the just one.

Props to anyone who actually read all of my long-winded update :)
 
I’m now half a year into “knife aficionado-ism” and in the course of acquiring 18 knives, I don’t yet have a black knife. Is this a “problem” that I need to rectify?
Get the hell out of the kitchen and get a LIFE...
 
Well in the past two weeks I've changed up my "collection" considerably so it's time to update this thread. My original post was on November 3, 2018, and I maintained that exact set of three knives until February 2020. So it was a solid run of 15 months with just those three. Long story short: I only own two knives now and they're both Benchmade Bugouts.

In February I caved and bought a second Benchmade Bugout--this time in the ranger green/grey color configuration--after about six months of thinking about it. I bought it simply because I liked the color combination, but it was also nice to know I'd have an immediate backup if something happened to my original blue Bugout. I bought it with the idea that it would be a test run though. I had been wanting that additional color combo for a long time even though I knew it made no logical sense to own two of the same knife. So I finally just bought it to see how it would play out and if I'd like having to make a choice every morning. I had both Bugouts on my EDC tray, and just grabbed whichever color I felt like carrying that day.

Fast forward to the last month or two, I'd been considering selling my Benchmade Mini Crooked River and Benchmade Puukko, and now I have finally sold both in the last two weeks. I think the Mini Crooked River is an absolutely beautiful knife. I love the look, the lines; I've just drawn to the beauty in it. And I enjoyed the feel in the hand and it's cutting ability. However, I had to come to terms with the fact I enjoy carrying the Bugout more. So there was no reason for me to own it; I can enjoy it's beauty while looking at others' pictures.

The Puukko was an awesome knife, and I have no doubt it could handle anything I'd ever throw at it. But a trip to the Smokey Mountains made me take a hard look at what I truly need. One of the results was I purchased a much smaller hiking pack and drastically cut down on the amount of stuff I carry. The Puukko was one of those things that got the boot. Honestly, I just have no real need for a fixed blade knife outside of the kitchen. I've pretty much owned fixed blades over the years because that's what you're supposed to do. But I've never had to baton wood with a knife, only done it once or twice just to mess around. I carry a gun for self defense. So up to this point in my life it has not been a need for me. So the Puukko was moved on to someone else that I hope can get much more use of it. Having said all that, I actually do have my eye on the new version of the Benchmade Steep Country set to come out in a couple months. I've been wanting to learn how to hunt for years, and I've finally got someone who is willing to take me on a deer hunt this fall. So maybe I'll have a need for a fixed blade after all. We'll see.

Currently I'm down to only two knives. Both of which happen to be Benchmade Bugouts, so it's kind of like I only own one knife. But there's been one other change in my knife carry. As I mentioned before, I've been carrying both the Bugouts; just choosing whichever color I felt like carrying that day. That is until about two weeks ago when I read an article in the Modern Huntsman titled Young Guns by Jillian Lukiwski. A few passages stood out to me, and I'll share one here. "Tools seem to be the face of tradition, the memories we can reach out and touch, the objects we press our faith into, the source of some superstition and luck. It's by using a tool of the hunting trade that we imbue it with story, purpose, history, and worth." This article resonated with me. To me it highlights one of the reasons I most enjoyed about EDCing the same knife every single day which is you gain a sense of familiarity with the knife and just feeling it in your palm brings back memories that it has been along the ride with you. So after a few minutes reflecting on that article, I placed the green/grey Bugout back into its box and in my safe. I wanted to get back to my one true EDC--the original blue Bugout. It might not last; I might decide I want the daily color choice again. Or maybe it will remain in my safe until such time that the blue one is worn out beyond usefulness. Only time will tell. But I will say I've enjoyed the past two weeks of getting back to the just one.

Props to anyone who actually read all of my long-winded update :)

I really woudl like to thank you for the update. Your thread is inspirational to me, now even more with this additional update.
 
I think you need a nice little traditional GEC just to round out your collection. Plus a man should have a little pocket jewelry. ;)
 
I think you need a nice little traditional GEC just to round out your collection. Plus a man should have a little pocket jewelry. ;)

Well the first problem with that is I'm not a man lol. I'm intrigued by the nostalgia of traditional knives, but for pure usefulness, a pocket clip and one hand opening is a need for me. I do wander into the forum's traditional section from time to time to admire the pictures though. The Earl knife thread was one of my favorites on this forum.
 
Believe it or not I had a time when that was the case for me as well. I like my current way of doing things better though, YMMV.

I have at least sold off most of the knives I don't carry.

Now, if Spyderco would just stop putting new steels in my favorite models I could find some peace! ....but why would they?
 
I have at least sold off most of the knives I don't carry.

Now, if Spyderco would just stop putting new steels in my favorite models I could find some peace! ....but why would they?

They're not going to stop doing that lol. Which is both a good thing and a bad thing sometimes. But hey selling the knives you don't carry is a big step.
 
It's good to hear someone got enjoyment/inspiration out of the thread :)
Getting enjoyment/inspiration from your writings is nothing new. I'm sure many of us look forward to what you have to say. I know that I do.

Personal motivation to scale back my collection started back when you had 5-6 knives. Back then I found your knife choices practical and very well thought out. I was so impressed with what you had (and why) that I decided to change the way I was collecting. You were not the only reason but, your ideas and thoughts came at the right time. Who knows how much money I have saved because of you and a few others here.

Well, you get the idea. If I keep writing like this someone will claim I am sucking up.
 
I have almost 60 (might be 60...I'll have to count again!) and I just don't think I can be without them. I have my most carried knives, then others I carry a little less, etc etc. Some I don't carry at all right now. Some backups (an extra 20cv Blackout Bareknuckle I may let go because I have 3...the CF sprint, standard grey, and 20cv) and my ZT 801ti backup (discontinued, so I have it in case something happens to my user). I did sell my ZT 0470 backup because if i need another I can always grab another, and I wanted a fixed blade so something had to go.

Some will never go anywhere, like my first Kershaw (cheap Tone from Academy) or my Tenacious. I have a weak spot for Benchmades (11 at the moment, and I still want a CF Elite Presidio II). I've got all the ZT's I like (aside from a 777, but that ain't gonna happen, so I have a Natrix XL and the CF Bareknuckle). My Spydie collection is at 12, and I still want a Drunken but that won't happen until I find one for super cheap, which will probably never happen.

And of course my Cold Steels, the AD10 and 4max Scout. Have to have the super overbuilt, ridiculous knives.

Yea I've got a problem! Maybe one day I will be able to trim it down.
 
Well in the past two weeks I've changed up my "collection" considerably so it's time to update this thread. My original post was on November 3, 2018, and I maintained that exact set of three knives until February 2020. So it was a solid run of 15 months with just those three. Long story short: I only own two knives now and they're both Benchmade Bugouts.
<snip>
The Puukko was an awesome knife, and I have no doubt it could handle anything I'd ever throw at it. But a trip to the Smokey Mountains made me take a hard look at what I truly need. One of the results was I purchased a much smaller hiking pack and drastically cut down on the amount of stuff I carry. The Puukko was one of those things that got the boot. Honestly, I just have no real need for a fixed blade knife outside of the kitchen. I've pretty much owned fixed blades over the years because that's what you're supposed to do. But I've never had to baton wood with a knife, only done it once or twice just to mess around. I carry a gun for self defense.
I have only handled Puukko's and never owned one. I woods wander in the Smoky's quite a bit. It is probably my most favorite place to be in the woods. My carry load in the woods varies quite a bit depending mostly on photography. Most everything revolves around what photo equipment I choose to carry with me. There is a limit to how much junk I'm willing to carry for more than a half mile. I have multiple day packs and the choice depends on my anticipated load for the day.

When this thread started I said I carried three knives.... Now, I pretty much mostly carry one knife except when I'm in the woods. That knife is the Vic Small Tinker. On occasion, I will add the Benchmade Mini Presideo II clipped to a back pocket. It is a simple knife. And I do really like it. I have never owned a Bugout and I don't think I'm going to try one. I carry the little Tinker so much that I would rather spend the money elsewhere and I'm pretty sure I wouldn't use the Bugout much regardless. The one hand opening thing is not generally an important knife attribute for me.

I do carry a Leatherman Ps4 Squirt on my keys. It has a little blade but I have never used it.

I want to carry a nice GEC slip joint too. But I don't need to do that and as a result, it almost never happens. So, why do I buy them? Sometimes I wonder. ;)

Your fixed blade observation is something that I always knew.... I seldom need one, ever. I still carry a fixed blade in the woods, but never or very seldomly use it for anything other than it provides a security blanket for me. Security is important to me. The fixed blade has simply gotten a lot smaller. I do edc a fixed blade often. I found that I tend to use it more that way.

This knife thing changes slowly over time for me. I have been downsizing mostly if there is a trend. Smaller knives and usually fewer knives.

I still won't reduce the number of knives I own regardless of use. I don't get up in the morning ever wondering what knife I am going to carry. I am a creature of habit and have developed habits or preferences for things that work for me. The only time I wonder about "what knife" is when I head to the woods and I try to slip a One-Handed Trekker into my carry bag. I don't get excited if I leave the fixed blade at home.
 
Last edited:
Getting enjoyment/inspiration from your writings is nothing new. I'm sure many of us look forward to what you have to say. I know that I do.

Personal motivation to scale back my collection started back when you had 5-6 knives. Back then I found your knife choices practical and very well thought out. I was so impressed with what you had (and why) that I decided to change the way I was collecting. You were not the only reason but, your ideas and thoughts came at the right time. Who knows how much money I have saved because of you and a few others here.

Well, you get the idea. If I keep writing like this someone will claim I am sucking up.

You were one of the main reasons I posted an update :)
 
I have only handled Puukko's and never owned one. I woods wander in the Smoky's quite a bit. It is probably my most favorite place to be in the woods. My carry load in the woods varies quite a bit depending mostly on photography. Most everything revolves around what photo equipment I choose to carry with me. There is a limit to how much junk I'm willing to carry for more than a half mile. I have multiple day packs and the choice depends on my anticipated load for the day.

When this thread started I said I carried three knives.... Now, I pretty much mostly carry one knife except when I'm in the woods. That knife is the Vic Small Tinker. On occasion, I will add the Benchmade Mini Presideo II clipped to a back pocket. It is a simple knife. And I do really like it. I have never owned a Bugout and I don't think I'm going to try one. I carry the little Tinker so much that I would rather spend the money elsewhere and I'm pretty sure I wouldn't use the Bugout much regardless. The one hand opening thing is not generally an important knife attribute for me.

I do carry a Leatherman Ps4 Squirt on my keys. It has a little blade but I have never used it.

I want to carry a nice GEC slip joint too. But I don't need to do that and as a result, it almost never happens. So, why do I buy them? Sometimes I wonder. ;)

Your fixed blade observation is something that I always knew.... I seldom need one, ever. I still carry a fixed blade in the woods, but never or very seldomly use it for anything other than it provides a security blanket for me. Security is important to me. The fixed blade has simply gotten a lot smaller. I do edc a fixed blade often. I found that I tend to use it more that way.

This knife thing changes slowly over time for me. I have been downsizing mostly if there is a trend. Smaller knives and usually fewer knives.

I still won't reduce the number of knives I own regardless of use. I don't get up in the morning ever wondering what knife I am going to carry. I am a creature of habit and have developed habits or preferences for things that work for me. The only time I wonder about "what knife" is when I head to the woods and I try to slip a One-Handed Trekker into my carry bag. I don't get excited if I leave the fixed blade at home.

I'm glad you found the knife that works well for you in the Tinker. Your Mini Presidio II should serve you well. I had an original automatic one that I carried for years when working EMS, and it never let me down.
 
This thread was an interesting read and it's very cool that you've found one knife to meet all your needs. Maybe one day I'll join you but for now I'm enjoying the variety.
 
This thread was an interesting read and it's very cool that you've found one knife to meet all your needs...

Agreed. I am not anywhere near the proper mindset to only own and use one knife. Although, two or three knives are a possibility.

The interesting thing is that I can go for ages with the same blade in my pocket and not give much thought about any other knife. This tells me that I am on the right track with my collection.

Right now I am doing most things with a Gerber LST that a BF member gave me. The Gerber and a full-size Griptilian are doing all of my normal cutting needs outside the kitchen. If I did not own the Gerber, my Vic Cadet or Kershaw Zing could easily take its place.

Overall, I am pretty happy with the knives I own and most of my knife needs could easily be met by three knives: Benchmade's 531, large Griptilian, and their 162 Bushcraft fixed blade. However, the Cadet and Kershaw are probably better suited for my needs than the 531.
 
Back
Top