Great thread, especially since this topic comes up often enough. I think it is unfortunate that some people get dissuaded from the going gear types based on rumours of their difficulty at striking. Yet in other ways they are much more versatile for the globben metal blobs they produce. When the chips are down, I think I might want a going gear rod and decent striker. Then again, if I don't have a striker, I feel like I could get an LMF to work with natural materials better, like a rock or glass or mussel shell (See Rotte's contest thread on this).
Also lets not forget that a bunch of makers here will produce little scrapers for the $25-$50 range.
I received two of these from Bryan Breeden. His warncliff shape works perfect for this application because there is no belly to cause slippage when scraping down the firesteel. He also puts a one sided chisel grind that, while not as great for cutting, does what it is supposed to do perfectly - strike sparks very well with a minimum of edge wear. The blaze orange G10 makes it easy to spot. In a striker this is critical, because once you get your flame to take the first thing you do is toss your fire steel and striker on the ground and try to nurse your fire. Eventually you gotta look around for your gear.