The Knives You Just Can't Part With

I generally hang on to all of my knives. All have been carried and most of them still see pocket time.
I can't imagine buying a knife that I don't use. I'm not a good collector in that regard. That said, I don't get rid of knives that were given to me, unless the giver likes the idea of me giving a knife on to someone else. Gift knives carry memories of the giver, and that's something I want to hang on to.
@knarfeng and JTB_5 JTB_5 may not know it, but they speak for me. :)

Like Frank, I tend to hang onto my knives, except for occasional GAWs. I have a schedule in a spreadsheet to make sure I carry all of my knives periodically.

Like JTB_5, although I've received many knives as gifts, there have only been two cases where I got rid of gift knives (once raising funds for BigBiscuit's family and once because it was totally obvious that another BF member would get far more use and enjoyment out of a particular knife than I did). The memories/sentiments attached to gift knives are important, and would fade if I didn't have the actual knife to spark the memories.

I'd also be very reluctant to part with any of my stag or horn knives, just because I happen to enjoy those handle materials and they're relatively rare among the knives I have.

So except for the gifts and the stag/horn knives, I'd consider parting with my other knives if the opportunity arose. But I don't think most of my "eligible" knives are in very high demand! :D

- GT
 
@knarfeng and JTB_5 JTB_5 may not know it, but they speak for me. :)

Like Frank, I tend to hang onto my knives, except for occasional GAWs. I have a schedule in a spreadsheet to make sure I carry all of my knives periodically.

Like JTB_5, although I've received many knives as gifts, there have only been two cases where I got rid of gift knives (once raising funds for BigBiscuit's family and once because it was totally obvious that another BF member would get far more use and enjoyment out of a particular knife than I did). The memories/sentiments attached to gift knives are important, and would fade if I didn't have the actual knife to spark the memories.

I'd also be very reluctant to part with any of my stag or horn knives, just because I happen to enjoy those handle materials and they're relatively rare among the knives I have.

So except for the gifts and the stag/horn knives, I'd consider parting with my other knives if the opportunity arose. But I don't think most of my "eligible" knives are in very high demand! :D

- GT
Glad to be in your company on this one 5K Qs 5K Qs
 
Often, I go through my knives and wonder just how I could break my collection to a certain number- and I just dont think I could do this, I am in the minor league and know other and have seen collections that are mind staggering- and I suspect heavily they too feel the exact same way- it's a hard road building a collection, I think even harder breaking down one.
Knives gifted to me are extremely precious for many reasons...
1, The meaning behind the Knife
2, the thanks and thought i send out when pulling out that gifted knife to my friend whom gifted me the knife- I often say " Thank you my friend- I love this Knife"..and get to work with it.
3, also usually the Knife gifted to me is a darned nice knife anyway- that is actually the smallest part of a gift knife- but also counts because we are the Knife nuts that we are and appreciate that particular Knife for- the Bone, or Blade selections etc, for example Charlie gifted me a Case 40 to 64 Red Bone Barlow that I carried on my Wedding day- although I have bought other Red Bone Barlows fro the same era and the knives are near a perfect match- Charlie's one is the one I have kept and will forever- this goes with every gifted knife that I have.
 
Of the 100 or so late model Case knives I have, I could probably live with whittling it down to a half dozen or so if my life depended upon it. The keepers would be 1 representative of each pattern I really like & the common thread would be each would have really hard snap & no wobble. Probably my all time fave EDC would be a toss up between a splotchy purple appaloosa 63032 or my blue ratcliffe muskrat.
 
Simple the 3 that belonged to my Grandfather's! And my SR Graduation 8OT and and my 2 Fixed Bladed Old Timer Hunting Knifes I got in the 1980's.

My Grandfather's knifes skinned small game and clean fish, they killed cut worms on tomatoes plants, they harvested fruit and cut it to bite size pieces.

My Graduation 8OT Stockman was given to me by my Cousin who owed the Lumber yard I worked in and bought stuff there for Ag! He took me fishing when my Dad was building his lake house! I was supposed to be working on the house but he told Dad I writting the checks and he going fishing with me! When I get them out and handle them precious memories flood my mind!
 
I have a few that I would never sell under any circumstances -

My first fixed blade - a Western L46-5 my grandfather gave me when I was 10 y.o.
The first knife I ever bough with my own money - a Buck 110 back in 1973.
My Texas A&M University Corps of Cadets saber.
My USN Dress Sword.
My Texian War Sword from the 1830s.
The Kabar Cutlass Machete my family bought me for my 60th birthday.
A Case stockman my nephew bought me for my 61st birthday.

Then there is a very large pile that would be disposed of only in extreme necessity. That list is too long to list.
 
My Queen 49h(or f. You know the one-Krein regrind) 2016 BF Forum Knife 35 Drover. And probably none of my Kreins. I Too never get rid of my knives-unless I’m gifting one. And I generally keep all the ones gifted or won by myself, unless it’s obvious someone else needs/deserves it.
Thanks, Neal
 
I have gifted several of my knives as thank you’s In the last 4 months. I will probably give away a few more this year. I honestly have far fewer knives than most people around here (I think under 10 at this point), but I’ve developed an apathy about my personal belongings, especially ones I don’t use regularly.

I enjoy giving them to those who will use and appreciate them.

I do have a Schrade USA 834 medium stockman new in tube that I’ll probably hold onto....for a while anyway.

Edit - I just remembered the old 2-blade congress in my pocket. It’s one of my first knives and the only one I still have from my childhood. I’ll keep it for sure...nobody would want it anyway! Here’s a bad pic in the dark.

wirjazE.jpg
 
Last edited:
I don't sell my knives. I just seem to keep accumulating them, especially old Barlows whenever I can find them. I do occasionally give one of my knives to my son or grandkids, but that's not because I don't want or use them anymore. It's because I want them to have it. That's different.
 
It would seem that I can't part with any of them, but I'm working up to selling some off just to get them out of my unused and generally not wanted or needed knife tub. Tastes change. However, none of my GEC's or slip joints in general are in that tub. I really don't have a problem with knives accumulating.
 
I've sold off most of my knives over the past year or so, and every time I'm getting ready to sell some of them I get them all out and sort them into groups: sell, maybe sell, don't sell. Then I think about the maybes, assign them to one of the other two groups, and move on. And every time, these three have wound up in the "don't sell" group.

RYNvVdi.jpg


The 2015 BF knife reminds me of the Porch, and how welcome I felt here when I was just getting into traditional knives (and still feel today!). It also pairs two of my favorite blades in a handle that's actually long enough for me to use, and is incredibly slim in-pocket.

The 47 is my favorite traditional knife of all the ones I've owned; I love everything about it. Even though I'm carrying a modern knife these days, if I circle back to traditionals this would be the one I'd drop in my pocket.

The Peanut showed me how much I could do with a small knife, but more importantly it accompanied me on one of my favorite trips with my daughter. I see this knife, and I remember that trip; the two are indelibly linked, and I love that link.
 
I generally hang on to all of my knives. All have been carried and most of them still see pocket time. They all have something that speaks to me. Something unique about the design and I carry them to remind myself of that feature.

Occasionally an exception comes up. My brother-in-law fell in love with a large Camillus-Remington and I gave it to him. But on the whole, the mound continues to grow, albeit more slowly than it has in the past.

Kids will just have to deal with it when I depart. It will likely not be one of their major concerns.

@knarfeng and JTB_5 JTB_5 may not know it, but they speak for me. :)

Often, I go through my knives and wonder just how I could break my collection to a certain number- and I just dont think I could do this, I am in the minor league and know other and have seen collections that are mind staggering- and I suspect heavily they too feel the exact same way- it's a hard road building a collection, I think even harder breaking down one.
Knives gifted to me are extremely precious for many reasons...
1, The meaning behind the Knife
2, the thanks and thought i send out when pulling out that gifted knife to my friend whom gifted me the knife- I often say " Thank you my friend- I love this Knife"..and get to work with it.
3, also usually the Knife gifted to me is a darned nice knife anyway- that is actually the smallest part of a gift knife- but also counts because we are the Knife nuts that we are and appreciate that particular Knife for- the Bone, or Blade selections etc, for example Charlie gifted me a Case 40 to 64 Red Bone Barlow that I carried on my Wedding day- although I have bought other Red Bone Barlows fro the same era and the knives are near a perfect match- Charlie's one is the one I have kept and will forever- this goes with every gifted knife that I have.

Gee, I don't have to post anymore, I'll just quote you folks from here on out. ;) With 40 years of accumulating I have gifted maybe 30-40 knives to family, friends and strangers who either admired one of my blades or never carried an edc knife before I've amassed a substantial accumulation and they all have a story to tell, subsequently they all have meaning behind them.

Any knife I've been gifted regardless of what kind I keep, I kinda look at my knives like baseball card collecting. I don't sell many but I've traded a bunch to get something else I wanted and had no money for. Funny thing was 90% of my accumulation were bought for $10 and under at auctions, flea markets and yard sales.

Considerin' how I don't really get rid of knives like the fine folks I quoted above, here are a few of my favorites.

South African maker, JD Ellis' 2016 Lanny's Clip done with a blue G-10 frame, red linen micarta liners, natural canvas micarta scales capped off with maroon linen micarta bolsters. All this surrounding a Sandvik 12C27 blade.

o1qYYNO.jpg


R. Cover Drop Point in Snake wood scales ATS 34 blade and hardware

8sDUuin.jpg


Lone Wolf/Loveless collaboration called the City Knife with what's supposed to be green canvas micarta IIRC. I love this little knife and wish someone would do a remake. It makes the perfect little pocket knife, a little bigger handle to blade ratio, a thin, high, full hollow grind makes this a fantastic slicer. (Can ya tell I like this knife a lot? ;) )

2DZXoU9.jpg


OK more than a few :) I got lots of knives I carry and won't get rid of, I have a feeling I'm gonna be a major contributor to this thread. ;)

1911-12 Union Knifeworks from NYC Moose pattern with jigged brown bone scales and iron bolsters. This was a rescue knife with a broken blade. A lot of elbow grease and TLC and this was the result.

APxdISU.jpg


Most of my SAK collection, there are about a half a dozen not shown.

kA5tJxx.jpg
None of these will go, 1 of 2 or 3 complete BFC's Traditional Forum's knives. This is the only one I won't write out the names, it's just easier to add a pic that's labeled already.
vL2r2mV.jpg


I9t6FIH.jpg


Mid 80s early 90s Case Mini Coke Bottle with 512 layer Parker/Edwards Damascus

2ajUg9W.jpg


1920s-40s Grief Schmidt Jack Knife in smooth bone covers I found coated in a half an inch of white latex paint, broken and abused I rescued it and this was the end result.

8ASkVzt.jpg


Case Swayback Jack and Sodbuster Jr. In jigged Brown Chestnut bone scales. Funny thing, the SBJ is a Tony Bose collaboration and the SB Jr. isn't but they compliment each other so nicely.

Pu9rKHz.jpg


1960s Kutmaster Coca Cola Jack Knife wrapped in brown jigged bone. My father in law worked for Coca Cola for 30+ years so I always loved all types of Coke paraphernalia .

ujPn1pj.jpg

ETA ... A pet peve of mine and often a gripe I have is when people don't put the knife info in if they know what it is. It only takes a moment or 2, just a line or a few words at least. Well I didn't do that here and in order to be able to continue to have something to gripe about I have to right my wrong. I woulda tried the 2 wrongs don't make a right but 3 lefts do subterfuge but I'd still know so I just wanted to correct my wrong and put up the info for the knives in the pics.

(Now I feel better)
 
Last edited:
Ted-that Loveless City Knife! Love those, just a beautiful execution of the Man’s knife.:):cool:
Thanks, Neal
PS-Complete Forum collections are awesome as well!:thumbsup:
 
Back
Top