The most important lesson you've learned about knives.

jideta

Gold Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2020
Messages
1,417
Custom is the way to go.
Knives are kinda personal to me.
Nothing like holding that knife made especially for you and knowing that there is only one like it on the planet.
 

Currawong

Platinum Member
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
1,814
I find it very hard to know if I'll like a knife until I have it in my hand and use it. So the process of building my collection of keepers has involved buying 5x that many, just to go through the process of experimentation and sorting. My taste in knives has changed because of that process and has evolved towards thin sharp knives, and hence towards steel types and heat treats that support a stable thin edge. My current favourites are AEB-L and vanax.
 
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
206
Most important would be:
1. Overall design and geometry are more important than some give them credit.
2. Best buy is best buy for a reason.

Less important:
Plain carbon steel suits me the best as it's very tough and also takes the edge very easily. It also requires no special sharpening equipment and finally - it's inexpensive.

Cheap stainless steels like 440, chinese steels and 4116 will roll, chip or break with harder use.
High end stainless steels are out of my budget.

3V is the best steel I currently have and I love it, but is not easy to sharpen.

D2 suits me well, but it is a chore to sharpen it.

3V and D2 both require special sharpeners (diamond) which itself is costly, and I am a student.

Bottom line - plain carbon for me over anything else any day!
 

not2sharp

Gold Member
Joined
Jun 29, 1999
Messages
18,254
I think most of us tend to start looking at knives from the wrong end. The most important part of the knife is the part that mates with your hand. If it is wrong, uncomfortable or feels unsafe, then you should choose something else. You are unlikely to modify your hand, so if you start with a handle that fits right, the knife will be much more pleasant to use.

n2s
 

Gilbert G

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2019
Messages
305
Many great posts so far. I see this becoming a great thread.

I would add after years of collecting and going through many knives that you'll find you let knives go you wish you still had in possession and in the collection. :rolleyes:
You'll learn what features in a knife are most important to you........ergonomics, edge geometry, action, steel, comfort, edginess, materials, etc. For me I found the best knives are not cheap and are a great blend of ergonomics and looks. I'm less picky on steel and also interested in the knife in hand and what kind of vibe it produces and the various meanings that come forth. For example if you are into Chris Reeve knives you may enjoy the construction and appreciate the extreme detail and discipline that goes into such a near perfectly manufactured knife. This in turn could inspire you more throughout your daily life to be in-spired and discipline to achieve greatness in your own ways.
You can really enjoy carrying $30 knives as nearly as much as $700 ones and in some cases more so because you have less fear of mucking things up and really going all out using the knife.
The biggest thing I learned is there is no perfect knife out there, no 1 perfect knife. There are many knives with great aspects and features but if we are really honest, no perfect knife. Also learned that despite the great knife companies in the world, USA still makes the best knives on planet earth whether production or custom.
 
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
1,950
Smatchet is always the answer.

Kidding aside, I learned that there’s plenty of excellent user folders in the $100 - $200 range that will give you many years of service. That being said, it’s perfectly fine to spend north of $500 on a single blade as long as you don’t go into debt.

Use your knives often and responsibly. Cut stuff with them, sharpen them, change the scales, swap out the pocket clips, explore different edge angles, etc. You will find surprising depth and variety for a hobby that merely separates and pierces matter.
 

Ironbut

Gold Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2016
Messages
2,805
The most important thing I've learned in over sixty years of carrying a knife is always have one on you. I can leave the house without my wallet, I might turn my cell phone on once in two weeks; but there is always at least one knife in my pocket, whether I'm sitting on my recliner, out shopping, or walking the dog.
 
Joined
Jul 28, 2016
Messages
971
In the end (for me at least) a knife is still just a tool, and needs to function as such. I can appreciate artistic expression, interesting design features, and such, but it still has to work.
 

Kabancheck

Platinum Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
182
Well
Weak detent is even more dangerous then weak lockup.
Good warranty is not always mean good Quality
Beefy knives is nice toys but poor workers
Using of high quality knives is more fun than looking on high quality knives
You can have whatever you like, but anyway you need a SAK (everyone need) :)
Learn a sharpening, if you understand principles it is no matter how hard the steel is
And last thing - don’t cut on the glass surface! :D
 

Blue Sky

Gold Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Messages
2,918
There is a big difference between want and need.
Well made yet inexpensive knives have a beauty all their own.
Tastes change, and sometimes change back. And then change again.
Opinions can differ and still be right.
Everything can fail.
There is no best.
 
Joined
Jul 14, 2020
Messages
7
Wow, many great replies here! It's very interesting to read all of your comments and I can see that a few people have reached the same conclusions as me over the years. Some have surprising answers too, I'm learning a few things.

I would love to comment about specific posts, but that would take a little while. Let's wait a little more and see what others have to say, then I'll add my 2 cents at the end of the day.
 
Top