the quest continues

Joined
Mar 22, 2006
Messages
5,944
I'm still restlessly searching for the perfect knife...something like an f1 perhaps but with carbon steel and a flat or scandi grind...maybe also a little smaller.....and under a $100 bucks and fairly easy to find would be a bonus... any ideas?
 
You bastard! how dare you blaspheme against the almighty F1!!! :) The F1 is my idea of a "perfect" knife, but can't really help, nothing comes to mind (lol). Maybe a mora? Ontario RAT-3? Cold Steel Master Hunter CV (admittedly larger)? You could try the custom route, like a Koster Bushcraft or a Skookum Bush Tool.. etc.
 
Rat-3 +1

We have a winner.
 
Thanks for the help so far guys... waba I love my f1....but carbons winning me over it's got charectar..
 
Under a 100 bucks? How about ten Mora's? That way you will have ten 100 knives.:D
 
In the same boat myself, granted I'm probably going to pull the trigger on the F1, but seeing as today is officially my birthday I'd planned on splurging on a knife I've been eyeing. Just waiting to have spare funds, so it'll probably be after the holidays.
Not sure how you feel about traditional Scandinavian handle materials, but this one fits the requirements you specified. The Granskniv 77mm at www.gransslojd.com. At 495 SEK(77 USD) it's in the price range, slightly shorter blade than the F1(3inches rather than 3.8), and Scandinavian ground carbon steel.


Gautier
 
Quit searching through production knives and get a custom. Lots of makers out there that can make you exactly what you want. No more compromising.

D Farmer, Fiddleback and Scott Gossman come to mind. Koster bushcraft would be good also.

Maybe something like a Kephart is what your looking for.
 
I would agree with ilbruche. I would go custom on this one to find the perfect all around knife. Mora knife or BRKT Northstar would come to mind for straight bushcraft and camping duties. Maybe even survival too.
 
I looked at and drooled over the F1 for a long time, before deciding to go for the WM1.
And although everyone might look at me weird, cause i`m a guy, and the WM1 is a "woman" knife. Well.. It`s the knife i have on me at all times. It`s lightweight, so i don`t even notice it`s hanging from my pants, until i`m halfway into town. And let`s just say that carrying a knife in Norway is the biggest no-no you can ever commit.
So i just slip it quietly and discreetly into a pocket on my jacket. It`s small, but it`s well up to most tasks you can throw at it.
True, it`s VG10, so no carbon, but i`ve handled plenty of carbon steel knives that don`t hold their edge half as long as this one. And i`ve thinned down the angles on mine so that it`s a slicer. Which one would think, would make the edge less stable, but not in my experience. (Your experience may vary, but it was incredibly slicy out of the box aswell, so there was no real need to thin the bevels.)

In closing, i was also, like you, out on a quest to find the "perfect" knife. And i can say, without a doubt, that the WM1 isn`t far from being that knife. The only thing i`ve noticed is that the handle is a bit too thin for my liking, which i`m planning to rectify by putting my own scales on a bare blade i got a while back.
So, if you don`t have to have carbon steel, then try a WM1.
If you need carbon steel, then... Uhmmm... I really don`t know what to say. :D
 
The WM1 is a great knife. I plan on getting a blank blade and making my own. I personally don't care for the rubbery handles. It is a great blade that lives in the shadow of the F1.
 
I'm still restlessly searching for the perfect knife

I hate to tell you this Hombre, but it does not exist. It's just a figment of your carbon steel infected, nicely figured desert iron wood saturated mind. As soon as you overcome the search for the perfect knife, your alter ego AKA (see bold print above) kicks in, and the quest is continued.

Don't fight the "alter ego" it will consume your SOUL!;)

Good luck with that buy the way.:thumbup: I'm off to hit the "Customs for Sale" section. :)
 
I'd say something for Charles May or a Fiddleback Bushcrafter would be the ticket. The Koster bushcraft would work well, too.

I also find that if I go and use one of my blades to try out something new (like use it to harvest cordage to try and learn that) makes me feel less eager to purchase a new blade.
 
You're dying to make your own knife Riley. Draw something up, order a little carbon and do yourself a cutter. Its not hard. Ask any questions you like.
 
there's several makers on here who could probably fill the bill for a Bill- if you weren't picky on exotic handle materials. And you can tweak- you can go a bit thicker, a bit thinner, scandi, convex, even a combination (shallow flat leading into a scandi?

1084 or 5160, or?

and you get a good fit to your hand size, too.
 
Back
Top