You can't beat the Military for its size to weight ratio. That, and it being a great slicer is why I love it so much.
To be fair, there are some knives out there that match its blade length while at least matching it's weight/thickness, if not beating it outright. HOWEVER I have not seen one that comes anywhere near to its ergonomics. It found that perfect divide between very simple and universale, and more "locked in".
For instance, something like a BM 710, pretty straightforward grip, just enough swell at the front to keep your hand from sliding forward without locking you into one grip, however you can't choke up, and it's just generic enough to where you can choke down for more length/whip/whatever, but doesn't feel great to me. Overall I give it a 7/10.
Other end of the spectrum is your typical Emerson grip with that massive built in guard. VERY secure for thrusting type things, however you are pretty much stuck in that hammer grip. Even worse choking up ability than the typical BM handles, and a lot less variation in grips available. Overall I give it about a 4/10 rating.
Military. You can be in the "normal" grip, index finger at the lock cut out "choil" area, puts you about in the ballpark of the standard BM grip (but the curved back makes it better in my hand), or you can choke up on the blade choil for detail work. One of my favorite for hard power cuts is choking back so the pinky side of your hand is firmly against the "rear guard", thumb putting pressure on the thumbramp, etc... Now that I think about it, the thumbramp just about doubles the usable grips that the stellar handle/choil combo has in the first place. You don't have to use it, but I often find myself using it without realizing it. Saw a picture of myself chopping veggies while camping last weekend and had no idea my veggie chopping grip had my index finger on the ramp.
spot the Millie
I simplified the other two knives a bit, but I still don't think they give you half the grip choices the military does. Maybe you are fine with simple hammer and reverse grips far away from the blade, but I have found when I am doing a lot of manual labor all day with lots of different cutting, having all those different options of great grips comes in handy. Of course I used to do them with real crappy knives also, so it can be done, it's just preference.
The G10 and Carbon Fiber Military is one of my favorite knives. I don't care for the heavy Ti version.
How about I meet you in the middle?
