There are no left unfriendly knife locks

you are taking your personal experience and generalizing to all or the majority of left handed people handling knives. Am I reading you correctly? Or are you just saying that this is true for you personally?

In my experience, buttonlocks with the button on left side of the handle (so it's depressed by the thumb of the right hand) are more difficult for me to depress with my finger. Axis and ball bearing locks, and lockbacks are obviously ambidextrous. And for me, liner and frame locks intended for right handers are unworkable in my lefthand. Obviously, different lefthanders have different experiences.
 
I have not encountered a knife lock yet that cannot be manipulated just as easily with the left hand as with the right. Using the left does not require much if any more dexterity than using the right, in my experience.

Some are even safer to manipulate with the left hand in their righty configuration, like liner & frame locks.

Axis locks
Ball bearing locks
Lockbacks
Liner locks
Frame locks
Compression locks
Rolling locks

I have never used the Phantom lock, but it also looks to be ambidextrous friendly as well.
Being left handed, which I am, is not a detriment to easily releasing knife locks. Getting hung up on "right" & "left" handed locks is pointless, in my opinion.


Did you intend that as a trick statement? Or did it just work out that way? Naturally a Left Hand liner, frame or compression lock will work as easily for me as the right hand version would work for someone right handed. But there's an aweful lot more to a knife than just the lock.

Nail nick slip-joints and thumb stud folders both locking and non locking can,
and often do favor the right handed. Even a design element as seemingly ambi as the thumb hole can be incorporated into designs that, for one or any number of reasons, favor one hand over the other. When this is the case, we left handed folks are rarely the ones favored.

I would defy you to easily open and close a Spyderco d'Holder Toad. The fact that I "can" manage to operate a Spyderco Lum Chinese Folder is not to say that I would want to do so on a regular basis. In fact, I like the design so much that I have a left handed custom version on order from Mr. Lum. Wonder how many right handed users would line up to buy it for personal use if I needed to sell it. Ditto with the left hand One-Eyed-Jack that I have on order from A.T. Barr. And those two, by my standards, are pretty "righty friendly" for LH liner locks. Imagine handing a custom LH version of the Spydero C25 Centofante to a righty.

Clips too are an issue. Again, if you want to prove you talents as a contortionist, that's you business. But I really think many would challenge the "universality" of a clip that cannot be moved from side to side.
 
Tennessee Flea said:
you are taking your personal experience and generalizing to all or the majority of left handed people handling knives. Am I reading you correctly? Or are you just saying that this is true for you personally?

Of course it's just my personal experience, there is nothing else it could be, even if I tried to say differently. It's just my opinion, based on my personal experience with right handed locks. I do not think they require any more dexterity, due to the fact that I am not in any way ambi-dextrous, I am not particuarly dextrous with my left hand, or anything else.

However, I am really beginning to wonder if perhaps I do have a bit more dexterity than I had realized, because quite a few seem to have quite a bit of trouble with right handed locks and the left hand.

I don't know. I don't know any other left handed people that I can think of, and my wife is right handed.

In my experience, buttonlocks with the button on left side of the handle (so it's depressed by the thumb of the right hand) are more difficult for me to depress with my finger.

I have had experience with the button lock, from Microtech, and I did not find it particulary hard to activate with the left hand, although it has been quite awhile since I owned it and I can't say for sure exactly how I was using it.
 
Did you intend that as a trick statement? Or did it just work out that way? Naturally a Left Hand liner, frame or compression lock will work as easily for me as the right hand version would work for someone right handed. But there's an aweful lot more to a knife than just the lock.

Okay, I see what you are talking about. No, it was not intended as some kind of trick statement.

Nail nick slip-joints and thumb stud folders both locking and non locking can, and often do favor the right handed. Even a design element as seemingly ambi as the thumb hole can be incorporated into designs that, for one or any number of reasons, favor one hand over the other. When this is the case, we left handed folks are rarely the ones favored.

I have used slip joints from Case, Queen, Schrade, and Buck, but I have never noticed any bias. They felt fine to me using them left handed, and even if I had tried to use them right handed, it would obviously not feel "right" at all, certainly not compared to using the left, no matter what kind of handed bias was incorporated into the design.

Maybe I'm just lucky, but I don't notice things like that, and I don't have trouble with right handed scissors, whatever those are. Yes, I have heard of left handed scissors, but I have no idea how they might be different.
Maybe if I used a pair the difference would be obvious, but I am happy to use right handed scissors.

I would defy you to easily open and close a Spyderco d'Holder Toad.

I have never handled one, but just looking at pictures it looks like I might have more trouble than usual, due to the size, using either hand. I don't know, I don't know anyone around me who owns one.

The fact that I "can" manage to operate a Spyderco Lum Chinese Folder is not to say that I would want to do so on a regular basis.

This one I have handled, and I found it to be no different than any other liner lock/frame lock, as far as releasing it with my left thumb.
As I said before, I personally think it's safer, and is quite comfortable for me, and has been since I got my first liner lock. Obviously some people do have trouble.


In fact, I like the design so much that I have a left handed custom version on order from Mr. Lum. Wonder how many right handed users would line up to buy it for personal use if I needed to sell it. Ditto with the left hand One-Eyed-Jack that I have on order from A.T. Barr. And those two, by my standards, are pretty "righty friendly" for LH liner locks. Imagine handing a custom LH version of the Spydero C25 Centofante to a righty.

While I agree that most right handers would not be beating down your door to buy one, my opinion is the same. I don't think a righty would have any more trouble using the left handed lock than a lefty would with a right handed lock.

If Michael Walker had designed the lock opposite of what he did, that's what people would use as they are now, although it would be completely opposite of what we have now.
I just personally think it's a simple designation, and I always have. For 100% sure, that is all it is to me.

Again though, perhaps I am just lucky to have more, whatever, and can easily use right handed locks. As you can see however, there is at least one left handed person who also prefers right handed locks

Clips too are an issue. Again, if you want to prove you talents as a contortionist, that's you business. But I really think many would challenge the "universality" of a clip that cannot be moved from side to side.

I am completely lost here. I really don't know how a clip can be called right or left handed, or more suitable for either handed use.

I do prefer tip up with a clip that keeps the blade snugged up against the outside seam of my pocket, but it's not much of a preference, and I really don't give it much thought. However it sits in my pocket makes no difference to how I use it, from what I can tell.
 
mike_mck2 said:
I am completely lost here. I really don't know how a clip can be called right or left handed, or more suitable for either handed use.

That is because you carry in your ass pocket. If you carry up front (like the rest of us, you're a wierdo :D ), and you have an off-hand mounted clip; after drawing the knife you'd have do give an extra motion to spin the knife in your hand a half a turn to get your hand in position to open the knife.

I carried my Scallion like that... it sucks.

Anyway how bout dem Meerkats?
 
I get myself a custom blade for the BM 520 with a single thump stud on the right side of the blade (only lefty style). :cool:

I saw how the righties were having problems to open this knife. They left the stud aside and opened it like a nail nicked blade.

We lefties are used to come around with right hander stuff. See, how a rightie would grumble about a true leftie knife and you know what you have swallowed to conform to your right handed world. :D
 
Back
Top