- Joined
- Jun 16, 2003
- Messages
- 20,206
No they don't. Newer methods have been promoted because they have been deemed to be safer and more effective than the older methods.
"No they don't" meaning what?
They specifically advice against using heat on the tick - or applying any substance to the tick -- on the grounds of health and safety.
U.S.C.D.CAvoid folklore remedies such as "painting" the tick with nail polish or petroleum jelly, or using heat to make the tick detach from the skin. Your goal is to remove the tick as quickly as possible--not waiting for it to detach.
Do not apply any substances to the tick before removing it - no alcohol or nail polish, no petroleum jelly or other ointments, and do not try to burn it out or otherwise convince to let go of you. It won't let go. It will just happily keep on sucking your blood and pumping pathogens into you.
Anapsid.org Chronic Neuroimmune Diseases Information Resource
There are many myths about what is a good method of tick removal (such as turning it clock-wise or anti-clockwise, or burning, suffocating, or twiddling the tick until it is dizzy) but most of these methods are likely to do more harm than good, even if the tick does detach.
Applying solutions such as alcohol, aftershave, oils / butter, paraffin or petroleum jelly, or twiddling the tick, may cause it irritation and result in it regurgitating saliva or stomach contents, which can contain disease-causing organisms. Applying a freezing agent or burning the tick with a cigarette, lighter, or match head may also result in fluids being forced out from the tick into you or your pet's blood stream.
These methods of tick removal might be successful in getting a tick to release its grip, but they may also significantly increase the risk of disease transmission.
Tick Bite Prevention Week
DO NOT
Do NOT try to burn the tick with a match or other hot object.
Do NOT twist the tick when pulling it out.
Do NOT try to kill, smother, or lubricate the tick with oil, alcohol, vaseline, or similar material.
National Institutes of health
Causing injury or stress to the tick can result in it regurgitating the blood meal that it has ingested. This may contain infective organisms and result in the host contracting a serious infection/s.
Stress to the tick can result from applying solutions such as alcohol, aftershave, oils / butter, paraffin or petroleum jelly. It can also result from applying a freezing agent or burning the tick with a cigarette, lighter, or match head.
These methods might be successful in getting a tick to release its grip, but they can also significantly increase the chances of disease transmission.
BADA - UK
DO NOT apply substances such as petroleum jelly, finger nail polish, finger nail polish remover, repellents, pesticides, or a lighted match to the tick while it is attached. These materials are either ineffective, or worse, might agitate the tick and cause it to force more infective fluid into the wound site.
LimeDisease.org