To Sharpen or not to Sharpen?

Joined
Nov 15, 1999
Messages
73
I need to get a few knives sharpened, but i have no experience with this. Do i take to a shop? Or do myself, but with a bit of practice on an old knife? I live in the orange county, So. Calif. area does anyone know of a good shop to have the knives sharpened?

Thanks,
Colt
 
Colt, Plaza Cutlery is a pretty good knife shop in the South Coast Plaza, Costa Mesa.

I'd think they'd have a pretty decent setup or can arrange one.

If your knives are collectors or special in some way, and you have 'em done once in a blue moon, I'd suggest taking it to them.

If you're interested in learning how to do it yourself, by all means practice on a few old knives first. It's not all that hard and just takes a bit of practice. Plaza Cutlery should be able to help you out there also, with a line of sharpeners and maybe a tip or two.

I'd suggest looking over the FAQ on this forum:
http://www.bladeforums.com/features/faqsharp.html

for starters... good luck.
 
To me the question is like: "do I learn to drive a car?" or "do I always take a taxi or bus to go to the store?" If you value self competence you do it yourself. This is basic skills type stuff.

If you have antique knives or if you bought custom knives costing hundreds of dollars with the intent of reselling them, don't sharpen them at all. Otherwise you should learn to do it. See the sharpening FAQ for techniques.

The best way to practise is on good, cheap, dull, knives. Go down to Goodwill and buy some used kitchen knives. Look for some good brands like Chicago Cutlery, MAC, Spyderco, Sabatier, Henckels, Victorinox, etc. The steel in these will be in the 55 to 58 rockwell range. This is easier to sharpen than a lot of hunting knives, but tougher than some cheap knives like Tramontina. The medium hardness steel mixed with the thinness of the blades will allow you to practise creating an edge in a reasonable length of time. If you somehow ding the blades or scratch the surfaces you will only be out about $1.00.

Note that these knives will be sufficiently dull that you will need something more abrasive than ceramic rods for your hone. If you go to a Home Depot you can find a Norton combination medium/fine grit bench stone for under $10.00. You can spend more, but it's nice to learn on something that costs less than $50.00. I do a lot of knives and like to use diamond plates. These tend to cost over $50.00 if they are large.

When you finally sharpen your "good" knives, if they are really show pieces you may want to protect the sides with some adhesive tape. Leave about 3/16ths of an inch of the edge region exposed and protect the rest of the blade from accidental scratches.

You may find it takes more time to sharpen your knives than you expected. The commonest problem is not working long enough.

 
Hi Colt,
I think Jeff Clark just gave you some very good advice. Since you are here in this forum , you obviously like knives, so why not learn how to sharpen them?

In the past, I have always used a stone, but in a fairly incompetant way. Unfortunately, I have scratched a few blades, (but not any expensive ones). I just bought a Sharpmaker 204, which has simple, direct instructions and is very easy to use. Best of all, you can sharpen your knives without scratching the blades without being a "pro". Again, the above advice is right on the target regarding the use of old knives to practise on, but it won't take long.
Good luck and happy sharpening to you!
Brian

------------------
Brian-The new knife in the Block, and definitely not the sharpest!
 
I would have to go with Jeff and Brian and say practice and learn only then can you learn to appreciate your blades even more.
I was once where you are now but after having a knife ruined by a knife shop lackey(thankfully a cheapo Buck I believe) attempting to sharpen it, I learned to do it myself.
Good luck.

------------------
The bible is not such a book a man would write if he could, or could write if he would.

*Lewis S. Chafer

2 Tim 3:16
 
What ever happened to Desert Rat? He used to never miss an opportunity to make a "reasonably flat rock" remark on a thread like this. Along with something about makeing people rich by selling sharpening gimmicks.
 
Thanks for all the great advice and info. I would really like to learn how to sharpen a knife. Can anyone on the forum recommend a good book or instructions on the net on how to do this.

Thanks,
Colt
 
Colt,
Do it yourself. The pride that you will feel when you can sharpen a knife to the point where it will shave hair off of your arm fantastic. Why should you pay someone to sharpen your knives when you can do it your self and make sure that its done right? Read the sharpening FAQ by Joe Talmadge. He has some really good advise. I have two sharpening systems, the sharpmaker by Spyderco and a kit from Razor Edge. The Spyderco costs less and it is also smaller, so I can take it with me. Plus the Spyerco Sharpmaker model 204 will sharpen just about anything that has an edge. It also comes with a really cool video to help you get started.

------------------
Shawn R Sullivan
~San Diego, Ca~
 
Colt,
Go to the quick navigation button at the top of this screen. Pull down the pull down menu click on the knowledge and features click on go, click on the Sharpening FAQ by Joe Talmadge this is a really great place to start learning about how to sharpen.
Hope this helps.

------------------
Shawn R Sullivan
~San Diego, Ca~

[This message has been edited by MrCas (edited 23 November 1999).]
 
If you are going to sharpen and use a jig or rig of some variety I strongly recommend you at least look at the Edgepro Apex system. It is more expensive but is simple to use and really puts a nice edge on almost anything. I have used this on everything from crappy kitchen knives to milspec knives of various vintages, garden knives, high end kitchen cutlery, and handmade/custom fixed blades. You'll save youself some real time and aggravation especially if you dont have the time to learn freehand with benchstones.
 
Back
Top