• Happy Thanksgiving to all of you! I hope that you all have something to be grateful for this year and for many years to come

  • The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is available! Price is $250 ea (shipped within CONUS).
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/

  • America has reached 250 years, and I am grateful to be here, in the best country in the world. Thank every one of you who helps make this country a better place, those who have gone before and risked it all, and those who've paid the ultimate price to make the United States what we are today.

    Happy Birthday America! Let Freedom Ring for all time!

Tops Atax?

It's been brought up several times before, so some interesting debate.

It's expensive, gimmicky, completely unnecessary. I want one.
 
I wouldn't ever want one of those to replace a 'normal' knife if I was backpacking or camping. A knife that needs a DVD that tells you how to use it...(But why do I secretly want to play with one?!?!? :D)
 
Just when I thought it was not possible to make a worse knife than the Tom Brown Tracker, TOPS comes up with that thing. I sure hopes it works better than my TOPS Tracker, which neither slices nor chops and weighs a ton.
 
Vic,

If I'm not mistaken, TOPS has been offering the ATAX since before they were offering the Tracker.
________________________________

As for my opinion of it:

I don't own one, and that's no accident. That said, if it was the only bladed tool I had available in a survival situation, I expect I would find it quite useful.
 
As you can see from Esav's link, I like the ATAX. I rarely am without it, it travels with me all day in the car in my Maxpedition Jumbo and I wear it a lot around the property, very comfortable... If you have used ulus and like them, the ATAX might be to your liking...

mike061.jpg

Mike027-1.jpg

Mike032-1.jpg
 
To each his own. If I ever buy another TOPS it will be of a more conventional design. Glad the ATAX works out for some.
 
I don't own one but if you put the handle between the blade and the handle isn't that cuttin down on your chopping depth? Or does is not penetrate very far?

I would think putting the handle behind the handle would be the most efficient way for chopping.


Does anyone see what I'm saying?
 
I don't see what you're saying, but I hear you HD.:D I think you end up turning it into a thick edged machete, not really an axe. It seems like it would be good for something like stripping branches off a pole more than splitting something.

Whatever it is, I don't think it has a thin enough edge for me. I think my axes are thinner at the edge.
 
I don't own one, cannot really afford one...but I would like to. I like Ron's stuff, he puts a lot of thought into what he does, what he films and what he designs. I just traded my Brother a knife. The knife got traded not for another knife but for 6 more Ron/Karen Hood DVDs. I always learn at least one thing per DVD that makes the DVD worth it and oftentimes I learn much, much more. I like the way he teaches, I like his humor and to be blunt, I think he knows his s**t and that's a lot more than I can say for a lot of people designing very fashionable junkers. :)
 
hollowdweller said:
I don't own one but if you put the handle between the blade and the handle isn't that cuttin down on your chopping depth? Or does is not penetrate very far?

I would think putting the handle behind the handle would be the most efficient way for chopping.


Does anyone see what I'm saying?
Click to expand...
I hear ya. If your splitting wood it would not do too well. But for chopping down small trees or branches it looks like it would work.

I wonder how it is to sharpen??
 
Horndog,

I'm hardly the voice of reason, the only high-end gimmick that I haven't bought and tested is the Tracker:D.... I should clarify that for me, the ATAX doesn't replace a straight knife, it is in addition to... I carry a Brusletto Puukko in my Jumbo with it and I always carry my SAK Trekker.. I think Ron Hood sells it the right way, a back-up tool that can always be with you on your belt in a car, on a horse, or snow mobile. You really forget that you are wearing it, which is pretty cool for something that I use as a hammer, nail-puller, and generally beat the crap out of...

HollowD,

Yep, the shots you see in my pics minimize the depth of chopping... There are a whole bunch of approaches to making an axe out of it (they are are on the DVD), I like zip ties the best.. The pics were from a test I did with my son where we took an 18" paracord and a shoelace, and a piece of grape vine.. We put it together in about a minute and I hit on hardwood just about as hard as I can swing (didn't come apart and no blade damage)... I learned that even without effort I had a basic chopping tool.

Don,

I am working on the Saiga review!
 
Check out one of the upcoming issues of Tactical Knives. I have a review of it in there. (1st article)
 
I think the ATAX looks like a nifty little tool but I have stayed away from it since its a TOPS knife which I generally view as high priced and gimmicky. I have only held one TOPS knife before so my impression might be slanted but it was a thick and the grind on it was very blunt. I also think the connection between the handle and blade would see alot of stress and I would like to have another one. Just my 2 opinion.
 
Orrey,

I think that question of strength is pretty straightforward from a materials engineering perspective, force is a function of length and that span is very short.. Also if you calculate the section modulus of that point of the knife, I think will find it is tremendously strong.. Also,the force that is exerted on the area is not shear (not that I think it would matter..). My concern when I bought it was the heat treatment, if wasn't done right, that would be tough....

As for the knife's utility, that's a matter of opinion:D:D.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top