Rod Neep said:
...It is one thing to make a flashy thing with stars and spangles (to impress folks), but it is a very different thing to make an obviously gorgeous piece of craft work that absolutely oozes quality such as that one...
Exactly, and thank you for bringing that up Rod.
I'm teaching Trisha the same way that I was taught. You learn the basics first -- design, flow, weight and balance, basic metallurgy and heat treating, fit and finish, edge geometry, cutting ability, etc. Only after you begin to master those basics do you move on to fancy materials, embellishment, and the various "bells and whistles". You present the knife in the raw so-to-speak, without window dressings, and let it stand on it's own.
When the knife was finished I had a hard time getting her to take it to the Hammer-in. She kept saying that it wasn't good enough. I'm trying to teach her another facet of the basics. Never being satisfied is an admirable as well as essential quality. When a maker is satisfied and thinks "he's arrived" he is finished. There is no way to improve when you can't see your own room for improvement.
Conversely, you can't droop your head in shame for your shortcomings. It's perfectly fine to silently feel a modicum of pride for the small things you've managed to achieve. It's a delicate balancing act.