I don't have a pricey one but for 14 years or so been using a camco workhorse stockman
For like 14 or 17 dollars.....brass bolsters and black McCarty.....darn autocorrect MICARTA LOL
Looks alright and works well BUT WISH I HAD A NICE CASE, QUEEN OR GEC in better steel
Surprisingly the cheap camco holds an edge alright...nothing to write home about except for performance for price category
The CAMCO should be a pretty good work knife. According to another knife site that is all about pocket knives, they say that they were actually made by Camillus. Not great, but pretty good.
After a weekend of hard carpentry work for a friend, he borrowed my CASE stockman so much I told him to put it in his pocket and give it back at the end of the day. He didn't, I forgot, and later after he told me he was carrying it a lot to "keep it safe", I told him to keep it. I had owned many CASE stockman patterns, and thought of them as a good work knife, nothing too special.
So when I went to replace it about 10 - 12 years ago, it seemed to me that the CASE knives had taken a dive in quality. Growing up, I proudly carried
only CASE folders, only having my first non CASE, a Boker, that was received as a gift. I was spoiled. I was used to picking the scales I wanted from out local sporting good store, then putting my edge on it, then in the pocket it went, ready for work. Over the years I had several.
But looking for a new one that had the same quality, the heavier blade (the XL or XXL pattern) was tough. In some weird way, I remember the pricing being about what it is now, only about 12 or so years ago. So $60 - $75 for an unadorned model (not a commemorative, no fancy scales, not a limited edition - thanks, Zippo) was a fair lick at pricing when I was buying knives like my RAT 1 for $25. Back then, never found a CASE that didn't have a couple of half peened pins, maybe the shield sticking out on one side, a blade that wouldn't open like the others, a cracked scale, grit in assembly, poor grinds, etc. I vote with my feet, and didn't bite.
A contractor buddy of mine bought me a Remington set, based solely on the name. It had the perfect stockman pattern I like, and a peanut knife together. He bought them for about $20 for the set. It has black dymond wood scales dyed though, and 440a (a guess) blades. I could not have been more surprised at the quality. It is great! The hardness of the steel is a little harder than the CASE ran theirs, it doesn't rust, all blades still snap closed, and I liked it enough I went to the same store and bought two more sets. It is exactly what I wanted, just not from the maker or country I preferred. They have performed as well as any CASE I have ever owned, which makes me sad.
So no CASE. I bought a Queen, but the main blade was a little flimsy for me. Could never, ever get a GEC, even with one of the BF folding dealers keeping an eye out for me. Those GEC collectors seem to buy all the knives as released and preorder as much as possible. Doubtful at this stage of the game I will ever wear one out, and since I have two (one gets dull, I get the other one) I am pretty sure I am set.
Good news though, I have recently seen some really gorgeous knives, well made and the fit and finish excellent from the CASE guys that weren't prohibitively expensive. I think everyone that likes the pattern and appreciates it as a work knife should own a CASE, a BUCK or an old Schrade stockman.
Robert