marcangel said:
I'm going out on a limb here, because I'm going to state my honest opinion. It really doesn't matter that this has been a 3 martini night, other than the fact
I'm willing to say openly, what I would normally keep my mouth shut about. I like the man, but relative to W. Osborne or Kenny Steigerwalt, the knives SUCK! Fit and finish is is nowhere near what the price commands. This is THE ONLY maker where my wife (who ...GOD, I love this woman) routinely buys me a knife for X-mas in the $2-4K range who asked me to look at it before, because to her it "wasn't right".

O.K. preacher fans...go ahead I'm all yours....shoot till I drop!
I respect that you are actually having an opinion that runs counter to the herd.
I have owned/purveyed(is that an actual word?) over 2 dozen Steigerwalt knives in my life. I have a gorgeous black mother of pearl piece right now. I like Kenny quite a bit myself, but his is not in Pease's league.
Osborne is the king of what he does in my book, no one else that I can think of is that good. Not Kious, not McConnell, not Horn. The blade finish on the Osborne I got last year is insanely well done, he says he hand rubs to 2000 grit. Do you know how frustrating that can be?
Let's break it down. The two Pease pieces, I got this year. The Rev. knows that they are for my "permanent" collection, and that people are going to be looking hard at the work, so maybe he tries a little harder than he did on yours, I don't know.
There is no side to side play, or front to back. Everything, and I mean everything, lines up. The blade is centered, all angles requiring 90 deg. fit have it. The blade finish is exactly similar to the way Kenny delivers his. It is smooth and walks and talks. no "proud" fits. The gold plated allen heads don't have deformation. The filework is inspired and well executed.
The only thing, and I mean only thing not perfect is on the pearl knife, and the blade-to-handle ratio is off by 1/4". This is allowable, but not perfect.
Gary Levine has two of W.D.'s knives on his site right now.
I am not a "fan" of the W.D.'s work, I simply think that it is a must-have if you consider yourself an evolved knife collector. The Sidelock is not made by anyone else, and is very much worth owning.
That is not a flame, that is a difference of opinion, and a correction of fact.