Funny this should come up. I just got one as a gift and I was wondering about it myself. It is forged steel and hickory. No nonsense and pretty sharp. You can see hammer marks on the head. It is real pretty in a functional, hand made kind of way. Not a machined piece at all. I have yet to give it a workout, but it looks real solid. I got a woodsman's model, 20" handle and about 2 lbs. I think it will be great for camping and such. Swings comfortable one or two handed. Great for a big hatchet or a small felling axe. I don't know about edge holding ability or anything yet, but my initial impression is very positive.