What are your favourite knife movies?

* for favorites

*seraphym falls
the edge
the hunted
rambo iv
*jerimiah johnson
*legends of the fall
*the dark knight
*gangs of new york
*last of the mohicans
*the patriot
 
If you want to see realistic knife action and learn something. Watch "The Hunted" with Tommy Lee Jones. He plays a character based on Tom Brown. This is a true knife movie.
 
What part of The Hunted do you think was realistic? The scene where del Toro kills the two hunters is highly unrealistic. The whole movie was full of weird situations. Many scenes revolved around Tom Brown's ideas of tracking.


That being said, I like this movie and I have it on DVD. :o
I think Tom Brown is good at what he does, but he's not exactly my kind of survival or knife expert and to be honest, I don't know what to think about his "Stalking Wolf"-stories. I also don't think his knife is the ultimate survival knife, but I guess it's a pleasure to own and use it. Until I have money left to buy one, I'll have to practice bushcraft like everybody else on this planet, including indians. ;)
 
No, not all of it was realistic. Especially when he forges a knife in a camp fire in about 1 hour. But in comparison to other movies out there they the tried to stick to the real tactics of tracking and knife fighting (although a knife fight would be over in a few second, not a few minutes as it shows in the film).

I don't like Tom Brown's knife design. I prefer a RTAKII paired up with a RAT-3 when I'm on an outing.
 
(although a knife fight would be over in a few second, not a few minutes as it shows in the film).

Well, to be fair, Tommy Lee Jones said exactly the same thing in an interview. After all, it's just a movie, and movies are supposed to be entertaining.
 
Any and all the Zatoichi movies. And all the Old Mifune Samurai movies!
Toshiro-Mifune-Throne_l.jpg
 
Anyone remember the movie Cyborg with Jeane Claude Van Dam?
Lots of knife action in that movie.
I am watching Blind Fury on TV right now. Fun sword happenings in that movie.
 
I put the Hunted on my list too but I still find some scenes kind of stupid/funny. For example, Benecio Del Toro's character talking about chickens being slaughtered to make a point about one species killing another species lower in the food chain, out of nowhere showing his daughter tracks in the lawn, and making a knife in 5 minutes. I love the editing though. He has a rough outline of his knife and the next frame he has a perfectly ground edge :rolleyes: This stuff is typical in some movies though and makes them kind of funny.
 
I love the editing though. He has a rough outline of his knife and the next frame he has a perfectly ground edge :rolleyes: This stuff is typical in some movies though and makes them kind of funny.

I hate it when people point out things like this in movies. Maybe WE would like a couple hours of film of him actually making that knife, but 99.9999% of the population is there to watch a movie, not a documentary on knife-making.

We can also assume that at some point his character took a dump, even though we didn't see it on-screen.
 
Troy.... those stainless steel swords used by Achilees(spell) were top of the line. I didn't even know they had stainless steel swords thousands of years ago.
 
I just got done watching V for Vendetta, lots of knife throwing and slashing. I think V used some kind of dagger. It's definitely worth watching if you're into throwing knives, government cover-ups, rebellion....
 
If you want to see realistic knife action and learn something. Watch "The Hunted" with Tommy Lee Jones. He plays a character based on Tom Brown. This is a true knife movie.

Could not disagree more.

1.) That thing Del Toro was using is not a fighting knife.

2.) Tom Brown is a tool who lives in New Jersey, an area known more for its toxic waste dumps than wilderness.

3.) After Tom Kier, the Sayoc Kali guru who was advising the set got more popular than Tom, Tom had him shown the door. The end result is pure crap, and not representative of SK.

After seeing the previews for this movie, I really thought it would be epic. It sucked. Sucked as badly as anything can suck. I was left thinking "Now why in the hell, with all the competent blade instruction now around, would they get some half-assed, Hollywood styled garbage like this??" I did some research afterwards, and discovered that the system in question was Sayoc Kali. I was thinking "Man. That Sayoc Kali stuff... what the hell is it?? It's weak." Then, I read an interview with Tom Kier in realfighting. As usual, Tom set himself up as something he was not, in this case a knife-fighting expert. Of course he is not, so he brought in outside help in the form of Mr. Kier. Long story short, Kier struck up a friendship with Del Toro, and started showing up Brown on the set, so was sent packing.

Dunno how many of you remember back in the mid-80s sometime, when the two self-styled mountain men in Montana killed a resort worker, and took another one as a "bride" for the son. A lengthy manhunt ensued, and at one point Tom Brown was brought in. I wish I still had the book, which was about the local sherrif on the case, the guy who eventually brought the fugitives in. The account of Mr. Brown's involvement would be pure comedy were it not so pathetic.
 
Last edited:
Ok, then, H2H907, what movie would you recommend? You seem to have very high expectations of Hollywood. I'm not exactly trained in knife fighting, but some of the moves I saw in the movie were taught to me by my kempo instructor.
 
Not a real knife movie, but if you ever again watch The French Connection with Gene Hackman, there is a scene early on where the French arch-ciminal is prying open and eating a raw oyster with an Opinel...he was in a suit and just pulled it out of his jacket pocket...looked like a #7 :D
 
Back
Top