What is the right knife for camping/bear attacks/wild mountain folk kind of knife?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anybody heard the story of Hugh Glass. Killed a big griz with his bowie, got mauled and left for dead by his buddies. Made it a few hundred miles through wilderness with healing wounds with nothing but his knife, guts, and what I can only think were 75lb balls of steel. That was one tough sob.
 
Protactical said:
The only problem with bears and guns is that there are lots of situations where handguns aren't allowed, like bow hunting season, or all over Canada.

If you’re deliberately going after big brown bears with a knife, you probably shouldn’t be allowed to near sharp objects anyway.

Protactical makes a good point that I can relate to. I’m an archery hunter and in my state of Arizona we’re not allowed to carry a firearm of any kind (including a pistol even if we have a CCW) during a bow hunting season while we have an archery tag in our possession.

Several years ago I had a close encounter with a bear sow with two cubs. I did all the right things, I backed away making myself look as big and menacing as I could while shouting all the obscenities I could think of. She sent both cubs up a tree and began to follow me to the tree line. Once I knew I didn’t have to worry about falling over a deadfall, I picked up the pace (backwards) a little. All I had was my bow with all my arrows in a quiver and a folding knife in my pack. Fortunately, she held her ground at the tree line but it left me knowing I shouldn’t be so foolish as not to have something besides my good communication skills to rely on if I ever end up under one.

When I got home, I started to look at knives that would fit the bill. I’ve always been a survivalist and to be honest a SAK will take care of almost anything needed along those lines but I wanted something I could also use as a small hatchet for shelter construction and making tools and traps.

I didn’t think much of any of the K Bars because they’re all so thin. I haunted knife shops for a while and finally I ordered the Ontario Marine Raider. This thing is an awesome tool but it weighs more than my favorite bush pistol (4” S&W M-19) so I didn’t always bring it. A few months later I ordered the Ontario Taskforce. It’s significantly smaller and just as sturdy but it has those dumb @$$ serrations on it. For the last several years, that’s the one I’ve taken with me. I had a friend sew a sheath on the bottom of my favorite pack so I can grab it easily when I have the pack on. I think if they made that knife without the serrations, it would be perfect.

From my experience, the Ontario knives are a super bargain. I’m thinking of ordering the Quartermaster next. They make 3 different models of this, the SP17, the FF17 and the P3. I like the idea of a steel pommel so it’ll be either the FF17 of the P3.
 
I broke the tip off an Ontario Marine Raider Bowie with what seemed to me like fairly light prying. May have been a fluke but I am always suspicious of a tip that thin on a blade that long.
 
Ruben Calo,Argentinian custom knifemaker,has a thread going on now with his Pig Killer.As much as any other knife,this one looks like it could fill the bill.:thumbup: :cool: :D

Doug
 
What about the Buck Hoodlum? I know its a little spendy but it looks like it would do just about everything youd need to in the woods...
 
Got a thread here from 2005/2006, not really a knife review, just typical unserious talk which really didn't need to be brought back with two more meaningless posts.

Closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top