What's a good handgun caliber/brand for outdoor use

Joined
Mar 22, 2007
Messages
158
My lady says I can get another handgun. I am wondering what you guys prefer for personal protection, hiking, camping, and general woods bumming. I am looking at getting a larger caliber; I already have a 9mm. I want a semi-auto I know that. I am looking at what brand and caliber you guys have and enjoy using. Thanks for the help.
 
Whats the nastiest 4 legged predator in your area?

Around my area, with small and infrequent "dangerous" critters (rabid fox, coyote, snakes, etc) I carry a .22 Ruger semi-auto or a XD Tactical .45ACP for an extended hike (mainly for two leggers).
 
I'm a 9mm nut myself- protection against what? If 4 legged you may wanna consider a wheelgun as not many autos are chambered in calibers very good for 4 legged critters. Maybe a .45 acp with a 400 corbon barrel for the woods or a 10mm- other than that the woods are revolver territory imo. My woods pistol is a ruger alaskan :)
 
If you're set on a semi-auto, I hear lots of good things about the 10mm round. The classic .45 is always a good choice, and it would give you an excuse to get a cool 1911.

Personally, I'm a huge fan or Ruger .357s. Great guns, great round. Pretty versatile since you can use .39 spls in the gun as well. I'd suggest something like a GP100 with a 4" barrel. You could go with one of the smaller SP101s, but holding onto one of those with full power .357 mags is a bit of a challenge.
 
A 1911 is a good choice but I don't carry or use mine nearly as often as my Glock 30. It's a great pistol. Easy to carry concealed, shoots well, and very accurate (surprisingly accurate for the barrel length).
 
i'm going to get bashed by the liberal members of this arena, but, oh' well.
first of all, any man that has to get the O.K. from his wife for anything is not a man!
if you are an adult man or women, you need no approval from anything or anyone!! last time i checked we are free to make our own choices. that being said-
454 casull alasken super redhawk! would stop any creature, whether two or four legged on earth!
 
Glock in .357 sig. Very close to the .357 mag with regard to ballistics, recoil is about the same as a .40 cal. It is a winner.
 
The largest predator in my area is a mountain lion. But I am mostly worrying about the two legged ones. Skimmerhorn I agree freedom of choice is a must but so is consideration and eating. Something like she gets something nice I get something nice. I like the idea of glock .40 but still am looking for more opinions so keep them coming.
 
If auto is a must I think the best there is would be a Glock 20, 10mm.

Not a Glock fan, but that pistol in 10mm if very hard to beat for a woods gun in most of America.

If revolvers come into play I would be happy with a .357 (loaded heavy) on the east coast (smalled critters). Nod goes to Ruger since they will take hotter loads than others.
Then step up to .44 or .454 as you move west or want more power.
 
i'm going to get bashed by the liberal members of this arena, but, oh' well.
first of all, any man that has to get the O.K. from his wife for anything is not a man!
if you are an adult man or women, you need no approval from anything or anyone!! last time i checked we are free to make our own choices. that being said-
454 casull alasken super redhawk! would stop any creature, whether two or four legged on earth!


I think your working from a skewed perspective of how marriage works!


I'm leaning toward a ruger sp101 right now for myself.
 
Ok with so many people talking revolver I am wondering why you prefer it? I have read many an article of pros and cons but am wondering your reasons?
 
1911 in 10mm is the way to go. I have 3 Colts in 10mm. Great guns. I own 41 1911s; that's 3.4% of my entire collection and I love em.
 
I think a Glock 20, 10MM would be ideal, Glock 40 S&W would work fine too for Auto's.. Revolvers are great because there is very little chance of a malfunction compared to an automatic. They also come in more powerfull calibers.

This is my set for heading out into the backwoods of N. Idaho.. Marlin 45-70 Guide gun, and Ruger Alaskan 454.. Should be able to handle anything that jumps out and wants to invade my personal space..lol..;)
 

Attachments

  • aabigguns.jpg
    aabigguns.jpg
    100.5 KB · Views: 60
Well, your only somewhat reasonably priced and practical choices larger than a 9mm are basically 357 Sig, 40, 10mm, and 45 ACP. I don't personally like the 357 Sig because the brass is tricky to reload and a 125 grain bullet in 357 Sig and 40 are just about identical ballistics wise. The 10mm is a great round but ammo is scarce for it and high priced. So I guess I would recommend something like a Glock Mdl 22 in 40 caliber. This is a rugged, reliable pistol with a 15 round mag. So, with one in the chamber that's 16 rounds and enough firepower to bring down about anything you might encounter on this continent short of a bison, moose, or grizzly and the 40 with a 180 grain bullet is a pretty potent stopper. Next choice would be a quality 1911 clone in 45. I'm a part time deputy and carry both on duty, also a Kahr PM40 as the mood strikes, and a 41 mag revolver when a really bad situation is expected. For bumming around in the desert my absolute must carry is my S&W six inch barrel revolver in 41 mag. Regardless, the main thing is learning to shoot whatever you get to the best of your ability. As for brands of autos, take a good look at Taurus which, IMO, has the best quality for the price. I do love my Taurus PT 1911! BTW, my forebears settled St.Onge, SD way back when and I grew up in that neck of the woods starting in 1934.
 
Ruger .357 Mag., 6"

You can shoot wimpy .38s or really powerful .357 Mags. approaching the .44 Magnum realm. (900 ft. lbs. for some of the beasts out there).

You can also shoot 125 grains up to 200 grains... and all sorts of bullet types.

It's a great, powerful, and accurate gun. I love mine. If I could only have one handgun this
would be it. And in my neck of the woods it's all I'll ever need in terms of power.

Oh then you can buy a lever gun in .357!!! Even more fun!
 
I know you said you want a semi-auto but a good revolver is hard to beat for "woods bumming". I have several and two large caliber guns that I carry the most are the Ruger SP101 in .357 and S&W 329PD in 44. I shoot "light" handloads in each but you have the option of 38 or 44 special factory loads if recoil is a concern. If it must be a semi-auto I love my Kimber 45.
 
I've got a Springfield XD-9 Subcompact that shoots like a dream... If you're looking for something larger, I would suggest the XD-40...
 
Back
Top