I am very curious as to how many folks have had a BIC lighter break. I have never had it happen and really can't recall ever hearing of one breaking from friends. I have found BICs at the side of the road that were clearly there for a few seasons. Completely rusted caps, gouged bodies that were half if not mostly buried. With a little cleaning they light right up. Zippos have failed me repeatedly... maybe my "zip-fu" is weak but I don't trust those things as far as I can throw them... and from experience, that is about 5 skips across the pond on a calm day.:thumbup:
In my opinion,
a lil'bit of everything can quickly add up to a whole bunch of nuthin'. The concept of a typical "Altoids PSK" eludes my idea of practicality. That is not so say that I haven't seen some good tin kits but for the most part those few did not follow conventional "altoids" philosophy. I can only comment from a wilderness survival perspective. The urban crew's needs might be different from mine.
My PSK (Practical, Sensible, Knowledge-based)
Water - I really don't think you should be traveling anywhere in the woods without a water container... preferably one that you can boil in. Stainless bottles are hardly a specialty item anymore. GET ONE. If you are just in love with your plastic Madagascar Collector Sippy Bottle, find a soup can that fits under it but be sure to burn the liner out ahead of time.
Fire - BICs... one in your pocket and one in your pack/bag. Firesteels are awesome. Prepared jute and steel wool in a plastic baggie... fine steel wool catches even the weakest sparks from traditional F&S and burns HOT. It is much easier to dry than plant fiber. You can use PCBs here too as long as they are sealed properly.
Cordage - A few hanks of paracord and jute go a long way. My secret cordage weapon is dental floss. Break open a few dispensers and pocket the rolls. It is just as strong as 50lb Spiderwire, cheap and you can carry a lot in a little space. I have a mirror in my shower that has hung by the same length of dental floss since 1998. Okay, maybe I don't shower much, but my wife does.
First aid - Zinc Oxide. It's an antiseptic, antibacterial, UV blocking, funky foot fighting, crotch rot, burn soothing wonder cream, IMO. Throw in a couple bandaids if you are the type of person that limps when they get a paper cut... I think they still make the Hanna Montana ones. On a serious note. I would consider making a few duct tape cards. Get an old credit card and wrap about 10ft of duct tape around it. Great for making bandaids and relieving hotspots on your feet/hands. A large bandana is also very useful.
Shelter - Of course, it starts with your clothing but a GI poncho is gravy on a rainy day.
Navigation/Signaling and Other Stuff - I also keep a few items that I would have a hard time making in the woods. Flashlight, dogtag signal mirror/reflector, whistle, a couple small ziploc bags, a folder or multitool.
All this stuff can easily be stowed in your pockets. If you want to use a bag/pouch, make sure it is secure and comfortable to wear all the time. This should be with you ALWAYS. The best(and necessary) compliments to this kit are
Knowledge and
Experience. I have made suggestions based on my personal dirt time in all the seasons and weather conditions of the places I frequent. Your own experience is the best teacher. Test your gear in the worst conditions so you can eat cake in the best.
Rick