Whats the coarsest benchstone you know of?

L

lerner

Joined
Sep 1, 2008
Messages
125
Im looking for a benchstone which would remove the most stock, even for the hardest metals. Basically the next best thing to a bench-grinding wheel.

I suppose I need diamond, but an "extra-course" arkansas stone could be faster than a "course" diamond stone, right? I wouldnt know which brand is coursest without feeling them.

Links to defenseknives.com or knifecenter.com would be helpful:)
 
Last edited:
H

hellgap

Joined
Dec 17, 2008
Messages
1,189
doing it by hand is ok but old fashioned use a belt sander or a file if you want to hand bomb it.ive got a grinder but most people use belt sanders to fast removal and then fine tume by hand
 
Jason B.

Jason B.

Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
11,089
The DMT XX-coarse is 120 mesh and should cut faster than any other stone. When it comes to removing stock Diamonds are a man's best friend.
 
S

Soilarch

Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
297
You need a way to vise or hold the blade but I like a 12" $18 Nicholson file. (Mill Bastard or "single cut").

There's definitely a learning curve. But once I learned that there a many traditional bowhunters who sharpen their broadheads with nothing but a file (and get them shaving sharp) I had to try it.

It's great. You can hog-off metal or get a fairly nice, albeit "toothy" edge by varying pressure and technique. My attempts to get shaving-sharp are about 50/50. Give me a piece of 2000grit sandpaper though and I'm in business...as far as broadheads go.

For 1/10 of what some stones cost its worth a try!
 
knarfeng

knarfeng

senex morosus moderator
Staff member
Super Mod
Moderator
Joined
Jul 30, 2006
Messages
34,047
I was going to say that Norton Crystolon coarse silicon carbide stones are about 100 grit. And they are pretty inexpensive.

But THOMBROGAN WINS.

I don't know of anything coarser than a 24.

Golly, Bill. You made me check my spelling 3 times to make sure I spelled it right.
 
D

db

Joined
Oct 3, 1998
Messages
3,762
I've taken a 34 grit 1x30 belt sander belt and glued it to the side of a 2x4 and truthfully it was just too darn aggressive. For sharpening I think the DMT XXC hone is my favorite coarse hone. A cheap black silicon hone is a very close second. I've also read that the RazorEdge coarse hone also works great and at its price it is worth a try.
 
S

Soilarch

Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Messages
297
hardheart said:
this is probably a good bet for fast removal
http://www.lanskysharpeners.com/images/hires/LHONE.jpg
like a file/rasp but in ceramic so it will cut knife steels.
Click to expand...


Heck Hardheart, I forgot most broadheads are only hardened to the mid 50s at most. (Some reach high 50s and a few stay in the 40s) Axes/machetes are also very soft compared to a nice piece of treated D2 or 1095.

Now I have to actually get over my fear of scratching my pretty knife blades and see if my Nicholasons will even "catch" on the harder steels. I'm thinking my [email protected] is a lost cause but will get back to the gang about my AUS8/6,420, S30V, 1095, and ATS34. (I think that cover most of my collection.) Pretty sure they'll catch on my Bucks and the AUS blades...as they seem much softer from experience in sharpening and use.
 
65535

65535

Joined
Mar 14, 2007
Messages
3,736
A DMT Coarse stone will do anything you need, the XCoarse and XXCoarse will do it faster, but require more time removing the deeper scratch pattern. IMHO for hand work DMT's are the best bet for the lower grits, as you move up to normal sharpening use then you can choose whatever you prefer.
 
Last edited:
K

ksskss

Joined
May 25, 2006
Messages
262
Here's the 24 grit in the large size that Thom is referring to:

b2.jpg


It's pretty agressive.

---
Ken
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top