Which is your favourite Spyderco fixed blade?

I was looking at it more as my future camp/hiking knife, but other possible uses are always appreciated...I loved your ARK, and would like you to personally tell me more about what to expect from the Rock Salt, if you don't mind.

What kind of chopping will it be able to take? (I know it's not a dedicated chopper)
Completely forget about batoning with it? (The Aqua can take quite a beating...)
Any improvements/changes over the old model other than coloured scales?
Recommended carry methods? I've heard some complaints about the sheath in the past...

Thanks!!! I admire your work and your posts. Keep them coming!
And have a nice day.
 
My only one, the Bushcraft:
9432255546_150d770691_b.jpg
 
I was looking at it more as my future camp/hiking knife, but other possible uses are always appreciated...I loved your ARK, and would like you to personally tell me more about what to expect from the Rock Salt, if you don't mind.

What kind of chopping will it be able to take? (I know it's not a dedicated chopper)
Completely forget about batoning with it? (The Aqua can take quite a beating...)
Any improvements/changes over the old model other than coloured scales?
Recommended carry methods? I've heard some complaints about the sheath in the past...

Thanks!!! I admire your work and your posts. Keep them coming!
And have a nice day.

The Rock Salt is on the lighter side for a camp knife, IMO. Most of my outdoor knife time, I've been swinging a big HI kukuri, or in more recent times, a S-O Camp Defender (see Sept Blade Mag). I actually have the original Rock Salt, but it looks like the only difference is the color FRN on the handle.
5456289167_23da14d7fe_z.jpg


At barely over 9 oz, the RS is also surprisingly lighter than you expect it to be, when you pick it up. It looks like it's going to weigh much more. This has the advantage of making it easy to pack for a knife this size, but does mean that it doesn't hit as hard. At less than 1/8" thick blade, there is no excess steel in the knife. Don't expect to chop into thick hardwood logs unless you like working hard. I personally only baton knives to test strength, and I wasn't willing to baton this one. The grip is good for cutting light stuff, but would probably develop some hot spots, should you ever actually try to chop a bunch of hardwood without wearing gloves. The wide, relative thin blade of the Rock Salt does mean that it's a very good slicer, and the tip shape, false edge, and blade thickness combine to let the RS penetrate quite well on thrusts, though the handle angle isn't optimized for that.

How it's carried will partially depend on what you want it to be able to do. If you only see this as a camp tool, then you can lash the sheath onto your pack with 550 through the grommet holes. If you want to be able to quickly access it for defensive use as well, I carry my midsize camp knives on my off side, horizontally, edge down. I can reach across and draw if I have plenty of time, or in an emergency, I can do a same-side-hand inverted draw.

The RS felt quite different than I expected. I thought I was getting a compact, rustproof camp knife, and instead got a nimble fighter. (Ed says it's not a camp knife, btw.) There are, of course, different fighting styles: I prefer tip-heavy knives with a lot of impact, believing that chopping stuff off an attacker is generally the fastest way to use a blade to stop the attack.

Hope that helps. Thanks, I hope you have a very pleasant day, as well. :)

John
 
I have a schemmp rock and I agree it's too light for camp knife. I will probably use it this coming season but will start researching a replacement. It is nice to hike with though.
 
Beautiful, collection, Reject.

So, which Spyderco fixed blade should I try first, friends? Preferably something I can EDC without causing widespread panic.
 
Beautiful, collection, Reject.

So, which Spyderco fixed blade should I try first, friends? Preferably something I can EDC without causing widespread panic.

Least likely to cause panic would be my little ARK, but frankly, it's not the most convenient, unless you are in an outdoors setting where a small knife dangling outside your shirt won't be cause for alarm.

Good EDFB choices:
Enuff
Reverse
Ronin 2
Street Beat or Street Beat Lightweight

Maybe you could ask Reject to take a pic with just the small FB blades sides by side?

John
 
Last edited:
I've never owned a swick, but it's a slick little design.
The temperance series are very, very nice, but in my self imposed price bracket the street bowie wins.
 
I carry a Ronin 2. It's not huge but it's pretty aggressive looking. Plus it's not a utility knife. It's there, "just in case"
 
1. ARK, 2. Swick, 3. Reverse.

The ARK is my running knife - very easy to carry, which is key for that activity.
I also like the Swicks because they are really handy (I mean, just look at them ;) ) and easy to pocket and I think the Reverse is a brilliant design!

The SE Aqua salt and maybe rock salt are on my want list.

The bushcraft is the usual high quality, but the handle is a bit too fat for my stubby fingers. I still have the original spalted handle one, but sold the synth handle version. I had the same problem with the Temp2. The Perrin designs are awesome, but the handles do not fit my hands. The Phil Wilson collabs - how can you not like the design + materials + build quality!!
 
I took a pic of the ARK, Ronin 2, and Street Bowie next to each other. The Endura-sized Cara Cara is for scale
23825003972_419a425af2.jpg


Rock Salt next to a Shirley-Owens Camp Defender 2.75. Haven't gotten all the wax off the blade yet...persistent stuff
23933376195_3051726a31.jpg
 
Last edited:
These are all my favorites. I've had my eye on the Aqua salt. May end up getting one this year. Only question though, serrated or plain edge? I don't have anything serrated so that may sway my decision.
 
Serrated all the way.

20151209_155847_zpsl42n5ljo.jpg


No discussion when talking Salt series, SE beats PE in absolutely everything. And I've tried 90% of the serration styles in the knife industry today, I'd say...

20151209_155555_zpszqafdm2t.jpg


20151209_155504_zpspvucderv.jpg


And the Aqua Salt has a nice portion near the tip that is plain edged, and I find it long and big enough to do most detailed tasks that require a Plain Edge and can't be done with SE. And really easy to sharpen or strop back if it dents/rolls.

20150909_111506_zpsqq4aezte.jpg


PS: Keep pics coming, Spectre! And Info as well, so useful! Thanks. Have a nice day you all
 
I didn't take a picture of the rear of the Rock Salt, but I did take a picture of the back of the Ronin 2 in the sheath. (The RS also uses a G Clip.)

The S-O CD 2.75 is wearing a small BladeTech Tek-Lok. Now the Tek-Lok is a very sturdy, capable lock, with the advantage of being able to take the lock and attached sheath off a belt without removing the belt.

On more compact knives, I greatly prefer the Spyderco G Clip. The G Clip, like the Tek-Lok, can be rotated for a vertical or horizontal carry. The G Clip is smaller, so of course has less space to spread load, but is big enough for even the Rock Salt. Unlike the Tek-Lok, the G Clip can either have a belt threaded through it for OWB carry, or can be slipped over the actual waistband without a belt. It also can be used for IWB carry.

23919619676_f68755fd3c.jpg


Now, the G Clip is much flatter than the Tek-Lok. That's probably not obvious in this picture, but you can definitely see the G Clip is not as tall or wide.

John
 
Last edited:
I didn't take a picture of the rear of the Rock Salt, but I did take a picture of the back of the Ronin 2 in the sheath. (The RS also uses a G Clip.)

The S-O CD 2.75 is wearing a small BladeTech Tek-Lok. Now the Tek-Lok is a very sturdy, capable lock, with the advantage of being able to take the lock and attached sheath off a belt without removing the belt.

On more compact knives, I greatly prefer the Spyderco G Clip. The G Clip, like the Tek-Lok, can be rotated for a vertical or horizontal carry. The G Clip is smaller, so of course has less space to spread load, but is big enough for even the Rock Salt. Unlike the Tek-Lok, the G Clip can either have a belt threaded through it for OWB carry, or can be slipped over the actual waistband without a belt. It also can be used for IWB carry.

23919619676_f68755fd3c.jpg


Now, the G Clip is much flatter than the Tek-Lok. That's probably not obvious in this picture, but you can definitely see the G Clip is not as tall or wide.

John
I think that's the big tek-lok. The small ones I use are almost the same dimensions as a g-clip.
 
I think you're right about which one that is, J W. I still find the G Clip much more compact.
 
Back
Top