Which Knife Has Disappointed You The Most, Which Has Pleasantly Surprised You?

Biggest disappointment: Benchmade 943. I had been looking forward to it for months, then as soon as I got my hands on one my dreams shattered :(

Biggest surprise: Kershaw Junkyard Dog. Picked one up at a gunshow, the guy didn't know it was discontinued. I would have gladly paid the $50 he was asking, but he was trying to hide the fact that it had some rust spotting. Talked him down to $30 :D it flips like it has bearings...it's incredible.
 
Biggest disappointment: benchmade 940. Nothing really wrong with it, but it fit my hand so poorly that i what immediately disheartened with it.

Best : CRK umnumzaan, smoothest knife i have ever owned. And the Mora companion, Best 7.25 I have ever spent on a blade.
 
Biggest disappointment - Spyderco Southard - most overrated piece of Chinese junk I've ever bought.

That post likely deserves a bit more info. It comes off as not only short, but political & inflammatory. Can you elaborate a bit as to why you consider it junk? It's the only non-USA folder I own (not an easy purchase) but I was the exact opposite in thinking that it is worth every penny and then some.
 
"Elmax doesnt hold an edge"...excuse me while I roll in the floor! Haha.

The biggest disappointment for me is probably my Emerson CQC-15 because it is mediocre materials for a ridiculous price, and the chisel grind makes me sick. It has basically been good for prying heavy duty staples...thats it.
My most surprising folder would be my Spyderco ffg Endura because it takes a beating and begs for more.
 
Hmmm, The only dissapointing knife that I bought this year was a Schrade Old Timer. It needs more maintenance than most of my blades, so I tossed it into the cutlery drawer in the kitchen. It was an impulse buy as some of mine are, when I wander through big box stores while trailing the warden. I've impulsed bought other blades like a Buck Path Finder etc. which I still like. What comes more readily to mind is the great service from some manufacturers. I had an Endura that didn't feel right from day one. It was sent to Spyderco and they went above and beyond for me on a return. I had a poor attachment on a Condor sheath and they sent me a new one. I got into ESEE knives this year, and a couple of Izula twos taught me that small blades can be VERY practical. Man I love those Izulas ! Mora's Companion line has been another home run. Really, I have little to complain about with my knife buys.
 
I probably haven't owned nearly as many knives as some people here but with what i have had experience with, i would have to say that the Gerber Freeman Folding knife was the most disappointing knife i've ever owned. i've owned an older gerber folder many years ago (back when they were better quality) and i understood that the craftsmanship had gone down so i was expecting it to be a little bit of a disappointment but when i used this knife it was a true let down. I paid around 35 or so at the local academy and took it to work with me. the drop point shape and ergo of the grip made me think that it was going to be a decent knife for the price. when i went to cut some plastic straps off a pallet, i wasn't too impressed. the supposed steel of the knife is 5Cr15MoV. i've worked with this steel once before on an even cheaper knife but this was horrible. while i understand that this steel is a little soft, the blade had pretty decent dents in it after just a couple straps. that probably wasn't the best test but it was plastic. c'mon. The best part about it was the rubber grips along with the finger groves so it felt comfortable to hold but that was about it. the opening action felt crappy and i didn't feel secure enough with the lock-up. about a week went by and i decided to give it to my buddy that i work with in exchange for a decent lunch. at first he was excited but after a few weeks went by he said the knife was completely shot. I didn't even waste my time asking him what he did with it that made him think it was shot. anyways, here is a pic of the knife that i pulled from the web. i'm curious to know if anyone has had experience with this knife and how it went for them.

 
Disappointment: Emerson CQC-7...just seemed so--no other word for it--cheap. I could not believe how much it cost for the materials and workmanship. I felt like I'd won it at a carnival or something.

Surprise: Spyderco Endura with the Emerson Wave: super sharp, solid, tight, smooth, rugged, with a bigger and better Wave feature than the one on the Emerson, all about less than half the price. Win!
 
Biggest disappointment: Benchmade 943. I had been looking forward to it for months, then as soon as I got my hands on one my dreams shattered :(

Biggest surprise: Kershaw Junkyard Dog. Picked one up at a gunshow, the guy didn't know it was discontinued. I would have gladly paid the $50 he was asking, but he was trying to hide the fact that it had some rust spotting. Talked him down to $30 :D it flips like it has bearings...it's incredible.

Why didn't you like the 943?
 
Disappointed me the most was the Microtech Matrix. I loved the look and didn't care about the 0777 contaversy, but it just didn't flip or feel the way I had hoped. I had very high expectations.

I was VERY pleasantly surprised by the Spyderco Military with fluted Ti scales. Just an amazingly smooth knife.
 
Biggest disappointment - Spyderco Southard - most overrated piece of Chinese junk I've ever bought.

Biggest pleasant surprise - Emersons - resisted liking them for years. Now probably my favorite maker.

China isn't the same as Taiwan, you know.
 
Most dissapointing. Every strider I have ever held or owned. I have had one sng cc and handled a Lego sng. Also owned 3 smfs. I wanted to like strider because I like the look of the knife and the kinda "attitude" of the brand and the warranty but they were all stiff and slow to deploy unless you make them so loose that there is blade play. Fit and finish is also crap. Ergonomics were good on the cc sng but bad on all others.

Surprised by the large sebenza 21. Unlike strider which I wanted to like but could not bring myself to do so I did not want to like the sebenza. I wanted to think it was boring and overpriced but its not. It is simple which is why I like the micarta but the ergonomics and the fit and finish and the way it carries in the pocket are all great.
 
I might catch some flack for this but the biggest disappointment for me was the 3" XM-18 flipper. I really really tried to love the knife as it was my first Hinderer but it was just too small for my hand and the detent was too weak, making the flipper useless. I was sad to see it go but I sold it to get an XM-24 and I'm very happy with it.

Pleasantly surprised would have to be my old S&W folder that I got when the only thing I knew about knives was that I wanted one. Fast forward 10 years and it's still going strong as one of my primary beaters.

Disappointed - ZT0561 and ZT0560: Elmax doesn't hold an edge, minor blade play, poor clip retention, rough stud placed and also the rattle sound from blade stop pin....

Polar opposite of my experience. Love my 0560. You sure the one you got wasn't defective?
 
I might catch some flack for this but the biggest disappointment for me was the 3" XM-18 flipper. I really really tried to love the knife as it was my first Hinderer but it was just too small for my hand and the detent was too weak, making the flipper useless. I was sad to see it go but I sold it to get an XM-24 and I'm very happy with it.

Pleasantly surprised would have to be my old S&W folder that I got when the only thing I knew about knives was that I wanted one. Fast forward 10 years and it's still going strong as one of my primary beaters.



Polar opposite of my experience. Love my 0560. You sure the one you got wasn't defective?

I bought the 0561 because I want to try out the Elmax steel...I expected it to perform as nice as it name. But at the time I got the knife I was kind of disappoint, the rattle sound, this is the stop pin (the second pic wasn't mine but it has the same issue)

IMG_7672.jpg

cspHi.jpg

Mine 0561 serial number was 0041.

After I get ride of my 561 for several months, I want to give a chance for Elmax steel as many tester keep consider it a super steel. And I bought ZT0560 my friend also bought the same model at the time. Its was just a same story, Elmax doesn't super at anything as it should, in fact its just a mediocre steel which has pretty cool name. My friend also has the exactly same experienced, curious if it been call "Super Steel" due to its fancy name and good looking composition label:thumbdn:
 
Last edited:
Two big disappointments in the last five years. First, the Kershaw Shallot in S110V. It took me 2 full hours to sharpen it up, and it cut well. However, with light jobsite use, the blade chipped! No prying, stabbing, jamming or torquing the knife. Using it to slice white wood pine, it chipped! I learned a great lesson about "super steels" with that purchase. I don't need a $100 letter opener, but I have one. Second, a gorgeous Queen folder in D2. Wanted this one bad as I like the large stockman patterns, but couldn't find one with rounded bolsters I liked for literally years. But a weak spring on this knife turned into a non working spring and now it won't reliably snap shut, but freezes, even when the blade is 90% closed.

Three huge, great surprises. First, Kershaw Tremor. I like big, hard working knives for my job and this one is all that, plus one. It is no longer in production, so I just bought it for a paltry $22 delivered. It is a slicing machine with G10 handles! It is rock solid and I would put it in the feel and performance of an $80 knife with no problems. After using it for a month, I bought two more to set aside for my work (construction) as needed in the future. The steel is just right for a good work knife; it doesn't roll, chip or dull too easily. And when it is dull, I swipe it a few times on my 800gr diamond chef's steel and it is job ready again.

Second surprise, my Ontario RAT 7 in D2. I read so much about the negatives of D2 after getting this knife I was wondering if I should even take it camping. I checked out some videos of guys using this as a knife really hard, not to cut cinder blocks or pierce car hoods, and decided to try it out on my own at the house. Better to have it break at the house than out on a camping or hunting trip. I chopped through a white oak 2X4 that was about 35 years old (think hard as steel), dropped it from six feet into a stump about 20 times to see if the point would break, and did some really hard, aggressive cutting/chopping on a 2X4. Not a whiff of damage to the edge. It was much duller than when I started, but the diamond rod got it right back up to snuff in a few strokes.

The third surprise is a Cold Steel Lawman. This knife was actually recommended by a knife maker here on BF, so that gave me the idea to check one out. Like many, I was put off by the shenanigans by the owner of CS so never really paid attention to the brand. I have never owned a lighter, stronger folder. It's incredible. The hollow grinds make it a good slicer, the all G10 (no liners) body makes it incredibly light. The AUS8 they use has some kind of proprietary treatment applied to it and it blows the other AUS8 knives I have out of the water. Excellent utility work knife.

Robert
 
Last edited:
Biggest disappointment: Original Ka-Bar. I was running and it moved to the front of my leg. Once my leg extended, the knife was pressured between my lower abdomen and the leg strap, snapping the blade in half inside the sheath. I also couldn't get it to hold an edge, and the cutting bevel rusted in a week - in Colorado.

Biggest surprise: Benchmade 3550. For such a small auto, the damn thing just won't die. It's almost comical.
 
How do you like the ergonomics on the strider?

Ergonomics were fine,just the overall size was a killer for me. The only complaint I would have if I needed to choose one was the lock was difficult to disengage
 
Biggest disappointment - The buck 184

I had been lusting over it since I was 16 and I can't hold it with the pins in the handle.

Biggest surprise - ZT350/550

I never knew about Zero tolerance knives and didn't raise the 350 was an assisted flipper. I brought the tigerstripe and its so much fun to use.
I love the way I can get the 550 to flick open so nicely. Its excellently designed IMO.
 
Biggest disappointment: Microtech Ultratech. The action was so stiff it was barely possible to open it.

Biggest surprise: Benchmade 51. I knew it would be good, but I really love the way it handles and the latch system is genius.
 
Biggest Disappointment: Chris Reeve S35vn. CRK is easily my favorite maker. But the 3 S35vn I have USED, were poor examples of edge retention. I think 3 knives, with the same pathetic edge holding is a large enough sample size to make this opinion.

Biggest surprise: Emerson Mini Cqc-15. One of my all time favorite EDC knives. Holds an edge real well and is super easy to sharpen. One of the most comfortable, smoothest knives I have ever owned. The Journeyman is an awesome knife also. But the Mini -15 is something special.
 
Back
Top