Which knives/styles do you plain dislike? For no real reason, rubs ya wrong, design, steel, handle, blade-shapes, brands. Judgement-free opinions.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 29, 2021
Messages
4,138
I'll go first:

A lot of ZT, some designs I actually do jive with, but I don't like the near Spydiechef folding-kitchen-knife Sheepsfoot vibe that they give off on a lot of knives, and the 0350, 0308, 0370, all of that... while I have some cause for concern, even if you torture tested one for me, I'd just think the look was BORING. While I am on this point...

Actually, something about this "classic-modern/semi-tactical" pocket-knife look, of a plain, drop-point blade with thumb-studs... I think it is because I associate it with cheap gas-station knives subconsciously, the same way some may with Cold Steel, as I know they were big starters of this rejuvinator of the knife industry (OHO/"tactical"/half serrated - I know CS didn't do that first though), but before the rest, and in a unique way that is charming to me. If I was doing a lot of rough work, I'd buy a lot more 4-Max, Lawman, whatever they have in good S35 or AUS-10a.

Let me look up Benchmade while I am at it, prime example... Yeah, your Presidios, Barrage, Bailout, Bugout, Casbah, 917... they all look the same, to me! (Keep in mind this is free-opinion, no-good-reason complaint thread, please tell me if/why you think I'm wrong, but... it's just aesthetic talk) all of that is just awfully boring to me. Kind of the same way some see Spyderco (but I love Spyderco, technically favorite brand in numbers of knives by far). The Benchmade fixed blades (3V Puukko being my only one, I like it very much so far), Cruwear Adamas, and sometime, the 940 large appeal to me. I would take a Bugout in S90 or M4 for cheap if I had spare knife money, maybe. Just to try. A few personal issues with Benchmade, too.

To riff off of that, generic, bad-steel, released-by-dozen flippers, specifically, from Kershaw, and to an extent Gerber and CRKT, in that order, referring to Chinese flipper-type knives. I do like some other Kershaw knives, USA-mades, just not most of the flippers. Would also not buy a new Emerson, though I love his wave. Well, Spyderco, Demko and WMC's version of it. No recurves unless it is a reverse-S, too. No Chinese Buck - do not like the "modern" style, the most modern Buck I like is a lightweight version of the 110/

To continue off of THAT... Strider, Medford, I plain dislike. I don't like the price, knives, or the D2 that was on some for a long time, I understand. These are just gross people, as well, in their own unique ways. However, knives. I can hardly carry a copper PM2 (are those guys with all-copper everything on Instagram with pristine copper maybe not really carrying/using that?) but good thing I don't mind patina. I originally had a less extreme but similar mild dislike for CRK and Hinderer, but those are actually very nice, and I like the clean hollow grinds instead of the shovel-point. I believe the Shaman in M4 is the closest to a Strider I will own, I call it my Striderco.

Case. I really was primed to love Case, but they are just messed up with the wiggle and the wonky grinds of the new knives, I just can't compare to a Rough Ryder, and I'd rather carry the RR and a SAK if I'm going somewhere this is required, the RR has beautiful FnF time and again for a third of the cost or less. My tiny Case Toothpick was 60 and messed up, my Cotton Sampler was less than 20 and not a gap to be seen, nor a problem, even with the weird shape of the cotton sampler blade. I will gladly pay more, but I want the quality of what China can pump out for $20, or at least close to it.

What about you?

(Notice I mention disliking, say, specifically Chinese-made Kershaw flippers, and it's true, I don't like supporting China beyond a Rough Ryder, a lot of us don't, but to prevent thread closure, if you are going to mention things like Chinese, Pakistani knives or whatever, please no talk of their government!)
 
Last edited:
Not sure if this is applicable to the theme of the thread.

I greatly dislike the word “spidey” often associated with spyderco. “Spidey flick” makes me cringe whenever I read, or hear it. For some reason the word “blurple” infuriates me as well, often associated with spyderco. Hearing people mention “spidey flicking their blurple PM2 in whatever steel of the week is .. brings me great resentment.

I do like spyderco knives for the most part. I dislike terrible terminology associated with spyderco though.

I’m probably an ___ hole that should see a therapist 😂.

No intention of upsetting anyone with my “spydie” rant.

Any Folder with a choil makes me cringe as well ( besides the F3).
 
“spidey flicking their blurple PM2”
Funniest thing I’ve read all day, thanks for the laugh! I agree with your point. Also can’t stand all the vids of people “spidey flicking”, adjusting their hand just so, while balancing the knife between 2 fingers before the “flick.” Just seems pointless and flashy.

Also, I don’t like “flippers”
 
I don’t think I’ve seen one knife made by Olamic that I’ve liked. All those color, texture, finish and hole options that people put together just end up looking like a bunch of knives designed by flunked out art students who will forever gloat and rub in people’s noses that they were extras in the Fast n’ Furious Tokyo Drift movie, for one scene.
 
I've still never understood the Ti and CF handle craze. I find them slick tbh. Admittedly, my frugalness plays a part in this. I'm content with G10, micarta, and nothing wrong with Spydercos textured FRN.

Cleaver shape blade. Not for me. Plus, when the blade is close, it seems like the knife is 4"+ wide.

Never understood Medford knives. I'm convinced Medford is Latin for "pocket brick". Ok, they have a few slim models.

Tired of "lifestyle" brands. James Brand comes to mind. Whiskey, knives, gear, etc. If you don't drink 19 y.o. scotch and carry a $400 knife, you must be a schmuck. I had a can of Guinness while carrying a Rat 1 D2 last night. I guess I'm a schmuck.
 
Nope, you pretty-much covered it, Hashishiin Hashishiin .

I'm more of a "Casio" guy, as opposed to "Rolex". So, the whole "overbuilt/overpriced/pocket jewelry" folder thing escapes me. Beyond that, quite a few of 'em are exercises in "ugly" and look like five pounds of $h!+ in a one-pound bag. I think I'll just stick with my $29 420HC Buck 110 Slim Selects. If I need pocket jewelry, I reckon I'll just buy some form of "custom" Abalone slip joint.



*...and "MagnaCut". Over the last few months, every time I hear "MagnaCut", I wanna' take my 1095 Cro-Van BK-9 and stab myself in the ears.
 
I've still never understood the Ti and CF handle craze. I find them slick tbh. Admittedly, my frugalness plays a part in this. I'm content with G10, micarta, and nothing wrong with Spydercos textured FRN.

Cleaver shape blade. Not for me. Plus, when the blade is close, it seems like the knife is 4"+ wide.

Never understood Medford knives. I'm convinced Medford is Latin for "pocket brick". Ok, they have a few slim models.

Tired of "lifestyle" brands. James Brand comes to mind. Whiskey, knives, gear, etc. If you don't drink 19 y.o. scotch and carry a $400 knife, you must be a schmuck. I had a can of Guinness while carrying a Rat 1 D2 last night. I guess I'm a schmuck.
I’m joining your team!
 
I've still never understood the Ti and CF handle craze. I find them slick tbh. Admittedly, my frugalness plays a part in this. I'm content with G10, micarta, and nothing wrong with Spydercos textured FRN.

Cleaver shape blade. Not for me. Plus, when the blade is close, it seems like the knife is 4"+ wide.

Never understood Medford knives. I'm convinced Medford is Latin for "pocket brick". Ok, they have a few slim models.

Tired of "lifestyle" brands. James Brand comes to mind. Whiskey, knives, gear, etc. If you don't drink 19 y.o. scotch and carry a $400 knife, you must be a schmuck. I had a can of Guinness while carrying a Rat 1 D2 last night. I guess I'm a schmuck.

I’ll never understand the “lifestyle” brands either. I believe it’s a millennial hipster thing.
 
Any design that looks like it's marketed to people who daydream about getting in knife fights.
Anything that scratches the back of my hand when I reach in my pocket.
I have not, do not, and will not ever want to buy a flipper, automatic, out-the-front, etc. (See gripe #1).
Blatantly bad ergos, flat slick scales, and finger choils that force your hand into non-cutting-friendly positions.
Giant Mouse knives that ARE NOT EVEN THE SIZE OF REGULAR MICE
 
...Tired of "lifestyle" brands. James Brand comes to mind. Whiskey, knives, gear, etc. If you don't drink 19 y.o. scotch and carry a $400 knife, you must be a schmuck. I had a can of Guinness while carrying a Rat 1 D2 last night. I guess I'm a schmuck.


Earlier this morning, I cut the plastic wrap on my $39 1.75L "handle" of Jack with my $21 Buck 110 LT.


Schmucks, the two of us.
 
Nope, you pretty-much covered it, Hashishiin Hashishiin .

I'm more of a "Casio" guy, as opposed to "Rolex". So, the whole "overbuilt/overpriced/pocket jewelry" folder thing escapes me. Beyond that, quite a few of 'em are exercises in "ugly" and look like five pounds of $h!+ in a one-pound bag. I think I'll just stick with my $29 420HC Buck 110 Slim Selects. If I need pocket jewelry, I reckon I'll just buy some form of "custom" Abalone slip joint.



*...and "MagnaCut". Over the last few months, every time I hear "MagnaCut", I wanna' take my 1095 Cro-Van BK-9 and stab myself in the ears.


I have to disagree with you on Magnacut. I have a David Mary/Good Knife Co. Super Brute in Magnacut and it is amazing! It holds an edge forever!!

I agree it is over hyped though.

99C96FFB-BA24-41E2-80C6-B7F5FAD98551.jpeg
 
I have to disagree with you on Magnacut. I have a David Mary/Good Knife Co. Super Brute in Magnacut and it is amazing! I agree it is over hyped.

View attachment 1892002


Oh, I have MagnaCut blades, but only because their respective Manufacturers only produced those respective models in that steel.

Are they any better than my 420HC Bucks? Seriously doubtful in my humble opinion. (*I have several of Dave's blades, and love 'em)
 
Oh, I have MagnaCut blades, but only because their respective Manufacturers only produced those respective models in that steel.

Are they any better than my 420HC Bucks? Seriously doubtful. (*I have several of Dave's blades, and love 'em)

My EcoSport gets me to work every day. However, I would love to pull up in a Raptor some day!!!
I have expensive knives, I do carry them. But my “work” knives are 10v, 154, and vg10
 
Dislike flippers, liner locks and most frame locks. Those wide blade extrema wharncliffe blades that look like a normal knife with a broken blade are just weird. Don't much care for huge so-called camp knives. Garishly colored covers are not my thing at all. I have a CRK but find most titanium frame locks boring. I'm definitely a traditionalist in my taste in knives and a lot of other things too. Not hard to explain why either, I'm 70.
 
Same way with Kershaw, SOG and Cold Steel for me at least.
Kershaw is ok with me. They make a few different levels based on where the knife is made, who designed it and what it's made of.

I never did care for SOG or Cold Steel though. Nothing I could ever pin down and say why, they just never appealed to me.
 
Two words - Chisel Grind

I've seen the "tactical" justifications, but in the real world where most people aren't "operators" I've never been able to figure out a purpose for them unless you're using your knife to scrape paint. Honestly they seem lazy, like one side of the blade is finished and the other isn't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top