Which martial art should I try?

Mike Kilo Niner said:
ddean: .....What specific things should we be looking for in a potential instructor to identify someone intimately familiar with the martial aspects of the art.
I think you've hit on the most important--
talk to instructor about what you want.
Given your experiences,
you won't be snowed by a 'salesperson'.
Also;
Observe or participate in a class.
A proper instructor knows that someone watching a class
will not take away any 'secrets'.
The 'secrets' of taiji is in the practice,
which is why books & videos are of only limited value.
No mystic or magical powers,
just guided, correct repetition training body & mind.

Check attitude of instructor & students.
See that the instructor makes detail adjustments
to students form--
the more advanced the student the finer the detail.
Foot movement & placement should have the same emphasis as the hands or hips.

No put-down of any other martial art.
No secrecy (as in paranoia)-------
(at the same time, traditionally some teachings
are reserved for the most advanced students)
The eye focus direction follows a hand (foot sometimes)
for advanced students.

Any potential head instructor should
-at least- be able to describe:
Which family taiji they teach,
and the lineage within that family
from which the instructor's learning derives.

They should teach -at least- 1 taiji weapon form.
They should teach push-hands;
and teach it as training--not to win tournements.
Push-hands competitions are usually not true taiji push-hands.
Competitions are useful, but cannot be the -point- of training.
They best teach/incorporate a qigong practice from the same family as the taiji.
Ditto silk-reeling practice; through it's pretty rare.
If they teach separate practice of taiji circles,
all the better.
If the instructor emphasizes postures.....all the better.
Some taiji is done at a relaxed pace, some faster,
some have a mixture of speeds.

What other arts does the instructor offer or incorporate?
OK if instructor also teaches other Chinese arts,
but beware instructors who teach a buffet of disparate arts;
especially if they are all the 'popular' arts.

If the instructor says that a certain movement has only
one application, then they don't know the art.

That's all that comes to mind at the moment.
Read the 3 sites I provide above,
they know taijiquan.

The spelling doesn't matter.
My teacher's school teaches Tai Chi because that's the
spelling that's recognized by the public.

=========================
There's an instructor in Atlanta that you should check out.
He's listed down on this page:
http://www.chenzhonghua.com/Branches/branches.htm
at Kennesaw State University Extension
David Hilburn 678\462-1697
dhilburn@mindspring.com
www.taichiatlanta.com
 
Yeah!

Outta tha sunset, like dust with boots on, comes...

iDios mio! iLos Cantanistas!

:D:D:D

iCreo que no!

Keith
 
try this out

many here
Georgia
Bujinkan Atlanta Dojo
Bujinkan Fudo Shibu
Bujinkan Fusenshi Dojo
Bujinkan-Ki-ai
Bujinkan Macon Dojo
Bujinkan Mikazuki Dojo
Bujinkan Raiken Dojo
Bujinkan Shinobu Bushi Kyokai
Bujinkan Zenka Dojo
Canton Budo
Dalton Bujinkan Training Group
David's Bujinkan Page
Kobudo Atlanta
North Georgia Martial Arts
 
Mike,

I live in Atlanta too. What school are you going to? I have a MA class that meets at Emory.

I can help you locate someone if you need help. I've got a good friend that is a lineage successor of one of the Hung brothers that teaches Tai Chi in Atlanta.

Lots of those Ninja folk around here too.

David
 
ddean,

Thanks so much for the advice -- there's lot's of good tips that apply in evaluating any potential instructor. Kennesaw is a bit of a drive for us, but we'll definitely check out Mr. Hilburn's school.
 
DannyinJapan,

Jack Hoban's site is a great source of info. Thanks for the link! I'd been training in the Bujinkan for about 6mos when my (future) wife suggested we go to the 2003 Tai Kai. His evening training session on "basic" kihon blew my mind -- he's fabulous.

Thanks!
 
Lion's Roar,

Emory, too as a matter of fact. Which MA class do you teach? And is your friend Dr. Tingsen Xu? He teaches a couple of Tai Chi PE classes at Emory and is very good.

Unfortunately, grad student stipends make affording private lessons rather difficult. :(

In any event, I'm always glad to run into another "Emoroid." :eek:

Cheers,
MK9
 
I like Muay Thai.

Fast, effective, no boring (and useless IMO) forms to remember. Pretty simple stuff with no frills and fancy show off techniques. You just increase in speed, power and technique perfection over time. :)
 
I echo the Muay Thai.

I also study Jun Fan/Jeet Kun Do, Kali/Escrima and Silat and recommend them all highly.
 
i once had someone tell me (about a week ago) about living in thailand - "the apmosphere is nice, but the prisons are not. how nice do you think it is to be a white guy locked up with 15,000 muay thai kickboxing experts?"

a form is suppose to teach you how to move correctly, and to get the body to instantly react to a specific movement, it its a good teacher he/she shouldnt ever teach you a "useless form". but your right that muay thai will speed up your training with much less memorization time, memory coming from in the moment usage...

id still like to learn more about the hawaain martial arts..., an entire form based on "how to take down massive angry samoans". very brutal, very effective, short on excess forms (although it has some odd weapons that would get you sent to federal prison in a heart beat)
 
I think you should pick the martial art where you fly through the air kicking. I think that has advantages over the others. You don't have to take the stairs anymore.





munk
 
Sounds like you racked a slide and let off a round.
I never heard that before- that's very clever- is it one of those sayings- or did you make it up, Spectre? It's so good I wish i'd made it up.

Seriously though, if we can't master flying around the room while spinning and kicking, surely we can do those sets of sommersaults at 25 mph across a 100 yards of indoor stadium?



munk
 
Back
Top