which one should I go with

[Akapennypincher]

Maybe try something with a bit softer (i.e. more forgiving) steel? How about a RAT-1 in AUS-8? I find them very easy to sharpen, and the knife performs very well, especially considering the price. You can get 'em new for about $30+/-, so you can try it out without spending a lot. Plus, they come in several colors and variations:

G-10 grip don't slip in any weather.