Which One To Keep?

Which One to Keep

  • Lightfoot

    Votes: 1 100.0%

  • Hinderer

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    1
173rdRedDevil

173rdRedDevil

Gold Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
1,308


I'm currently in a pickle. I've got these two blades that I really like, but. Looking to thin the herd so one needs to go. Basically need everyone's help on a decision. Because I sure as heck can't decide for myself haha! Also, ether one will absolutely be a user. No safe queens!

1st up: Greg Lightfoot "Half-Dress" Custom Offspring.

2nd up: Hinderer LE Skinner w/ Black DLC and CF Monkey Edge scale.

Any input would be greatly appreciated! Also, if I've posted this in the wrong area. If any mods could be so kind as to move it to the propper AO.
 
Last edited:
Just by looks and the blade shape I'd keep the right one.
But things might change depending on weight, smooth opening, steel and other things which might be important to you.
 
I would personally keep the Hinderer.
Also, I have never personally been of fan of Greg's work (just me)


I know what they are all about (RHK) I've owned quite a few, and they make excellent EDC knives....

Two Issues:

That's me, I don't know what you like?

Is this for EDC or just as a collector?
 
I would keep the Hinderer if it's going to be a user, or keep the Lightfoot if it's a collection piece.

Hinderer's are proven hard-work knives. The lightfoot looks a little delicate around the edges.
 
If I can't make up my mind, and there is nothing forcing me to make a decision right at that minute, I wait until later when I might be better able to make a decision.

My observation is that the custom knife is a little nicer and probably harder to replace, so it gets points for that.
 
I would keep the Hinderer which seems to be the popular choice based on those commenting.
 
I don't care for the blade on the Lightfoot, so I would say keep the Hinderer.
 
Not a fan myself. Id let both go. If i had to keep one id keep the hinderer. Only due to the longer blade length or so it appears from the pics.
 
If it's going to be a user I vote on keeping the Hinderer; but I get your dilemma, it's going to be tough to let either one go. That Lightfoot is a beaut!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top