I've got both large and small Case in CV, German Eye, and Rough Rider. I have to say, I was disappointed in the Case: Fit and finish were perfect, but the strength of the backspring left a lot to be desired (I've found this on others, as well). The RR has the split-liner lock (not really a Walker lock, as the tang engagement is different), and good F&F . If I were going trad, I would pick the German Eye: Extra strong backspring, forged carbon blade, and price in line with the philosophy of a Sodbuster. [I also like to pair it with it's large stockman kin.]