who makes the best folder under $200

Get a Spyderco like the Military or Manix or a Benchmade like the 710HS or 806D2. You'll be happy either way.

I personally wouldn't put that much weight on what opens fastest (but I don't carry for self defense). They can all be opened pretty quickly. Even if you're carrying primarily for self defense, I think training is going to be more important that 1/10 of a second difference in speed of opening.
 
Buck Mayo TNT. And Buck has absolutely awesome customer service as well.
 
Personally, I would say out of the kershaws, the spydercos, the benchmades, the Camillus Dominator I have has won, almsot no contest. At the 150.00 I paid for it, a real bargain!
 
my vote goes to the Camillus Dominator. for a bargain, i would go with the Camillus HEAT too... same design principles as the Dominator with more cost effective materials. the Dominator is great for the price!
 
Buck 110 from their custom house, your choice of steel andhle material, bolsters. Grteat knife
 
I carried an SOG PEII for the past three or four years, (from when they came out), and found it to be easy to maintain, quick opening with a resonably durable blade. I think they're available for around $100.00, (I've seen em for as low as $60.00 online somewhere a couple of years ago). If a 5" blade is a bit big check out the PE (1?) with 3 1/2 or 4 inck blade. same AUS-8 steel.

I know this will sound somewhat contradictory but I about two hours ago I picked up a Benchmade 550 to replace the SOG, (Office types get a bit twitchy around such large weapons :D ). This is also a quick opener with a 440C blade that the production edge, (a fairly sharp edge at that :D :D ), that has gone through six currigated card board boxes with no real damage to the blade, the edge is still reasonably sharp, (this was not a test...Just work). This was $95.00.

If AUS-8 or 440C are too soft for you Benckmade puts out the 555D2. It's a slightly smaller version of the 550 with a D2 steel blade. I have sharpened a couple and D2 is some pretty tough stuff. Very hard so it'll keep an edge longer. I think this one is around $100.00 as well. They also has the Resistor that comes with a 154CM steel blade that is some pretty good stuff as well for about $180.00. It felt pretty good in my hand so...


I have read quite a few discouraging posts regarding the Axis lock, (benchmade), and the, (I disremember the name), lock SOG uses. Like I said I carried that SOG for quite a while through all kinds of odd and ugly stuff and it never failed, the blade got no looser or tighter than I had set it. Even after it flew out of my hand a couple of times only to bounce and ping off almost everything in my kitchen. I have a friend with a benchmade 555D2 that he has had for a year or two and this guy just plain abuses his knife, (pains my hart to no end :grumpy: ), and he has had no problems whatsoever with his.

Ok enough sbout the high teck new stuff. Let us not forget about the old school stuff we all grew up with like the Buck 110 and others of that same style. Sinpe durable, dependable and resonably priced.

Cleaverly disguised as a responsable adult,
Charlie
 
Absolutely and positively the best folder for under two hundred bucks is the Protec Godfather or godson. Super materials, wicked design and I dare say it will open faster then your benchmade or your dominator;-)>
 
Long time lurker, first time poster...wish me luck. :)

I use my knives at work very hard. The knives I tended to buy were the ones available at the local Navy Exchange. (Typically low end Gerbers, occasionally Spydercos and SOGs.) I tended to break one every 2-3 months. Bear in mind that I'm a typical sailor; if I'm not actively abusing my knife doing work, I'm actively abusing it at play -- carving, whittling, cutting, and occasionally throwing. Things came to a head when I dropped a nice chunk of change on a Gerber Covert Folder. It was a good knife. It lasted me almost six months (an unheard of amount of time for me) before I'd managed to lose most of the grip screws, accumulated a nice amount of rust inside the lock, and snapped the tip off. I reground the tip and replaced the screws after my last deployment but the blade had an excessive amount of wobble to it. Tightening the pivot screws to the point where the play was removed made it nearly impossible to open or close. I figured it was time for another knife. (To the Covert's credit, I never managed to ding or chip the blade; I don't know the whole story behind that whiz-bang steel it's made of but it seems to be great stuff.)

I picked up a CS Voyager (5" serrated tanto) on impulse and threw it into the fray over a year and a half ago. Since then, I've broken down ammo crates, pried open stubborn ammo cans, pried apart (or smashed, if required) wooden dunnage, cut through wire seals (the braided kind), cut old rags into cleaning patches, pried up nails, hammered nails back down, pried stuck/split casings out of firearms, and generally done all the things CS says not to do in the warranty...on a daily basis, no less. I'm also the only person in my shop that uses his knife as a wirecutter -- I close the knife halfway, place the wire across the groove in the handle, and use a squeezing motion to sever it. I've done some one-time stunts that were pretty spectacular, but the one I'll always remember best was sawing through most of a tire, including the belt, over the course of a few minutes. (The story behind that is beyond the scope of this post. Suffice it to say that it was necessary.) The blade got VERY hot in this case and had noticably dulled, but it survived. And -- joy of joys -- the screws never came loose and got lost, as there are no screws to lose. I like things simple.

This year and a half has been rough on my Voyager. It has two nasty dings in the edge, just forward of where the serrations start, that are too deep to grind out easily. These were caused by several months of snapping wire seals with a levering motion. At first, I used the edge of the blade to pry seals apart, as I was afraid of lock failure or blade breakage. I've since learned that a reinforced tanto point is plenty strong to be used sideways instead and that's the way I do it now. The finish is very scratched up and the serrations have lost some of their distinctness from numerous resharpenings. The finish is worn off the clip in most places. It still locks as tightly as it did the day I bought it.

Is it the best knife under $200? I'm almost sure that it isn't. However, it's done everything that I've ever asked of it. It's taken an enormous amount of abuse. And, if and when it ever breaks, I'm out $60...a real shame, but I won't cry myself to sleep over it. My only regret is that it was the tenth folder I've owned, and not the first. I've read that CS quality can be hit or miss, so YMMV.
 
warthog90805 said:
If AUS-8 or 440C are too soft for you Benckmade puts out the 555D2. It's a slightly smaller version of the 550 with a D2 steel blade. I have sharpened a couple and D2 is some pretty tough stuff. Very hard so it'll keep an edge longer.
Okay, so I've been wondering about this so maybe someone can help me out. Not trying to hijack this thread, but since we're on the subject of different steels...

BM hardens their 440C to 58-60HRC
BM hardens their D2 to 58-60HRC
In other words, both steels are the same hardness, but the D2 holds it's edge better. Why is that? Different steel microstructure?
 
If it has to be new go Benchmade. Or keep a close eye on the exchange forums, add a few bucks and maybe pick up a used Sebenza.
 
Back
Top