Why I sold most of my expensive knives (anyone else feel like this?)

Excellent thread!

I am going through much the same thing. Although my threshold was about the $600.00 mark. I am selling down. If I can't make myself use it, or I don't like it, it goes up on the block. I am getting there. Although I still have way more than I need.

About six or seven years ago, I set out to simplify my life. I approached it slowly and methodically. I have been very much enjoying the results. I even gave up television. It is amazing how much extra knife money you have when you stop that $72.00/month cable bill for over six years. I don't pretend to think this is, or should be, the path others should follow.
But I have achieved amazing results. I am just having a better time with my life.

I really work hard, not to judge others. Whether their knives are too cheap, or too expensive. If it brings them joy, good on them. I have just been gravitating toward owning less and doing more. Not just with knives, but in all phases of my life.

I think it will be the events I will cherrish in my old age. Not the objects. I have always leaned more to the skills side of things. Properly built tools are a necessity, some are even works of art. And folks should be proud to own and use them. Just don't let them consume you.

I learned the value of skills vs gear at a young age. It was driven home for me on a multi-day camping/canoing trip in northen Maine, way back in 1978.

I was eighteen and poor. But somewhat woods savy. I was invited to go on a group trip. With all the other folks being older and more well off than I. As I set up my tent, one of those old orange 5x7 jobbies from a box store. I was actually mocked, and told I would wake up wet, by this guy with a big dollar specialty tent.. To the point where his wife had to tell him to leave me alone.

I noticed his tent. It was the nicest tent I had ever seen, by a long shot. I also noticed he was setting it up in a low spot. Normally, I might have said something. But after the abuse, I remained silent. Sure enough, that night the rains came. My cheap tent rocked and rolled, but made it through still upright and dry.

Just around sunrise, I could hear the guy and his wife arguing. I emerged from my tent well rested and dry. Only to see their tent, surrounded by a small pond about 2-3" deep. With almost as much inside. It was divine justice. He couldn't believe I was dry. He had to actually look in my tent to verify it. His wife asked if she could move in with me if it rained again.

I learned many lessons on that trip.
1. Never apologize for who you are.
2. Just because you have good gear, doesn't mean you know what you're doing.
3. You can have a lot of fun, no matter what level of gear you own.
4. Sleeping in a wet tent can put quite a strain on a marriage.


Moral of the story.
Do what makes you happy.
Don't worry about what others think.
Don't look down on others because of what they have, or don't have.
Learn to use and enjoy what you have or can afford.
Skills first, gear second.
 
[video=youtube;BNQULw8E8H0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNQULw8E8H0[/video]
 
Great post, LostViking!

I've not yet "purged," but I've definitely modified my buying habits, over time. Used to be buy whatever caught my eye. Now I think through each and every purchase, and make myself list pros/cons. Sure there are lots of knives I'd LIKE to have, and no knives I really NEED to have, but it's helped to narrow down what I REALLY WANT to have, and stick with that. My price range is all over the place. Just spent $50 on something I had been wanting for literally years, and saw a great deal. I'll also spend between $300 - $400, on occasion.

Some years I spend more than others, but I've rarely gotten a knife that I felt wasn't worth it, and even more rarely gotten rid of a knife.
 
I sold a bunch of high end to support my 1911 habits. $3k knife, or $3k 1911?
 
I don't own any truly high dollar knives, and the few I do own in the $150-250 range are mostly safe queens, but I don't think I'll part with them any day soon. Some people buy art or jewelry or cars that appeal to them, for no other reason than that. I buy knives whose designs appeal to me, sometimes strictly to own and look at every now and then, and sometimes for routine use. As I'm sure some of you have experienced, I sometimes find myself looking for some other justification than collecting and practical EDC use, and for me, I feel that I started undertaking more "outdoorsy" pursuits as something of an excuse to buy some of the knives I otherwise wouldn't need. Going on a hike, I really didn't need an assortment of knives . . . but maybe if I went camping? OK, so I start camping, but I really didn't need much in the way of cutting tools in a state park campground where firewood is purchased at a visitor center . . . but what if I started backpacking and camping in remote areas? It has been a sort of catalyst.

Now, I've started to weed out the knives that have no practical utility value and don't really fit into my collection anymore, whether because I have something similar but nicer, or just don't hold the appreciation that I used to. So far, I've just given such knives as gifts, but I suppose I'll start selling some eventually.
 
Whenever I get this feeling, I just throw the majority of my collection into storage for a while. It makes it so that they're out of sight, but I don't have to buy them back if I want to have them again. Plus, when I finally DO take them out of storage, I get that new knife giddyness like I did the first time I bought them. It's like Christmas morning:)
 
I pared down my knife collection by 3/4 and my gun collection by 1/2 over the last two years. Now I have exactly what I want, set up exactly how I want them, and all of it I have a use for. Much more satisfying.

Plus, I bought a bike with the proceeds, set it up how I want it, and put money in the bank.
 
I can tell you that I more or less agree with the general sentiment. That's why my shopping list for Blade is short, and consists primarily of a number of production knives that I've never seen in person that I'm interested in. I am not going with the intent to buy a super expensive custom, because honestly, I don't see the value in it. I carry a $500 limited edition carbon fiber CRK Insingo every day that I DO feel was worth the money, however, and have several other higher end production knives (Spyderco, ZT, and CRK). CRKs are the only ones I'm interested in out of the "Big Three" however, because I refuse to pay a dime for a Strider (sorry, military family background and I think Mick is pure scum), and I love my ZT Hinderer designs far more than I'd love an actual Hinderer at $500+.

I will probably end up paring down my collection further at some point soon.
 
Sure, a custom can perform like a production knife, and the extra expense is not going into better cutting performance. However, there is something special about having a one-off or something rare and unique that is not readily available. There are about 5-10 knives I could never part with, and they are what I feel what represents my style and taste in knives best.

That right there.

I won't buy an expensive knife, production or custom, just because its the "best one out there" and "everybody wants one".

I have Kershaw's, Bucks, CRKT's, Bokers, even Taylor Cutlery's, all in various steels that all "cut just fine" and do the task asked of them... They are all production knives, I have zero customs at the moment, but they all suit me. They all fit my budget at the time and satisfied a desire. Stylistically in one way or another they all fit "me"... There are still a bunch of production knives I'm interested in, But as I mentioned there are a few customs and high end production pieces on my radar... And they are pricey, but as you said (and i also mentioned) i appreciate them as works of art, more then just knives... Not just because they are trends, or fads, but they truly do just tug at that "it" that's inside me. I actually and truly dont have much interest in many if the top end knives out there, but those few i do, they made me stare, say "whoa", (regardless if they did for anyone else), and i will own them.

I've actually been looking through my "collection" more as late since joining here, and while I'll probably still pick up a cheap to midrange production knife here or there, (maybe a couple more Blurs since I love them so), ive been seriously thinking about curbing my spending habits here starting over the summer. Rather then 1 or 2 every week damn near, cut back to 1 or 2 per month tops; and with the $ saved I'm going to start aiming at the few true top ends that I have noticed, the ones that I like "for me", and That would be statement pieces for me... Like my tattoos but rather something I can leave to my kids...

With the practical aspects of the ones I already own; work, camp, EDC's rugged and formal, etc. All avenues Covered, some fixed and lots of folders, all in styles that suit me for sure, i've decided It's about time I upgraded my collection not just to have expensive trendy knives, but to have " those" knives that I truly want. That nobody else (or very few folks) have. since $300-500-1000 knives are not in my " budget", i bought a bunch that were. Now that I have a bunch that suit most every need I have and then some, its high time I start saving and "settling down"...

I did most of my whoring and my herem is plentiful... And while I very well still plan to add a few more concubines here and there, even that standard has been changed now that I have a better knowledge of what I like and what I don't... It's high time that I add a few good "wives" to the mix...

I like all the knives I own, but I want to be where alongside my collection of blurs, maybe 3 or 4 more other production knives that I just like more then the rest, I'll have those 5-10 that I just can't imagine ever getting rid of... Real Heirloom pieces, Not just because of their price, but because of their very essence to me. (At which point expect some nice GAW's, as I'll surely be ready to down grade at that time, lol)
 
Last edited:
I am the rare exception in saying that I really only 1 knife (I have 2 other cheap ones that were given to me, but I don't even know where they are). Its a Hoback A15, expensive knife. Im not a collector, nor do I really care to be. I don't have the personality of being a collector, I don't like having an inventory of things that I don't use. I went through the knife hobby fairly quickly. In Janurary of this year (2015) I had a Benchmade Barrage, most expensive knife I ever owned. From there I went through a gauntlet of more and more expensive knives with a Sebenza 21 being the first and least expensive. When I got into the hobby, Jake Hoback's knives immediately grabbed my attention (that and Direware). After owning a Hoback Kwaiback Midtech, it made me want to own one of his customs.

After going through about 13 expensive knives (over $400) I finally had a Direware Solo V5. Loved the knife, but for EDC, just wasn't working out well for me. Got then A15 in a trade and loved it.

When I told my Uncle (guy who got me into knives) how much this A15 was, his head spun. I understand why, 6 months ago you couldn't have made me believe that a $200 knife was worth it, let alone a $1300 one.

Through getting different high end knives and learning more about the custom knife world, for me having a Hoback is more about buying the maker, not the knife. Yeah, the knife cuts and everything is amazing about it, but I could say the same thing about the Paramilitary 2 I owned. I learned about Jake Hoback and saw what kind of person he is. I like that I own a knife from him, I respect him as a person and as a maker.

He has already helped me out with this A15 and has been excellent in communication.

If you buy a knife to use and that's it, then customs are not worth it at all. But for me, even if I never cut a single item ever again, I would still own this Hoback A15 because its not JUST about the function of the knife for me, its about being able to own something custom from someone who I respect.


Its funny, the same uncle who scoffed at my knife is the same person who owns 20+ spyderco's / benchmades / CRKT, etc... Im sure he has more money in knives than I do, and 95% of them never see the light of day, while mine goes with me everywhere. To each their own, and I do understand why he would rather own a lot of less expensive knives.

EDIT* Just reread it after I posted this, makes me look like a Hoback fanboy to the extreme. This applies to other custom makers and the people who enjoy their knives.
 
No. If anything I have shied away from the "high-end production" knives in the $150-500 range. All those Benchmades, ZTs, Cold Steels, CRKs, Spydercos, Hinderers, and Striders add up - even the ones considered "good value for the money"... I would rather save the money and use it towards a really special piece handmade by a knifemaker I respect, and that I would carry almost day versus having an assortment of assembly-line produced, machine-cut knives, each of which might go into the pocket once a week at best.
 
I'm a confirmed knife slut...I want them all. :D
Whether it's $50 or $700, if I can scrounge the cash somehow, it will be mine, if I like the looks and function of it.

Slowing down? Pffft, I'm just getting started! :thumbup:
 
I haven't gotten an "expensive" knife yet but I've been tempted many times and I could afford one if I wanted. By expensive I'm talking a pricepoint of 400-500 bucks or so.

But I like nice steel. I like nice steel because I like to actually use my knives. That leads to them being misplaced for a time, and sometimes even lost.

So if I'm not really going to use it, what's the sense in nice steel? I can appreciate them though. I have quite a few nice production knives that I like to use and fondle. My most expensive ones are my bark rivers. I use them strictly for hunting. Skinning and processing the meat. They are so sharp I can skin several pigs and deer without making a dent in the edge. When it comes time to cut the meat up they go through the large pieces like lasers.

I think a lot of appeal of this forum is to live the knife life vicariously through others. I love to look at the pics and read posts of people enjoying their knives.

I'm kind of surprized I don't have a sebenza yet. One thing that has really slowed down my knife purchases is I'm getting older now and don't have any heirs. I have a lot of cool stuff and other than my significant other, nobody to leave them to when I croak. I've gotten to the place in life where I can just enjoy the things I have (guns, knives, all american canner . . ) I'm getting closer to retirement and want to bolster my short term savings so I can do some work around the house when that time comes. My things will live longer than I will!
 
I'm selling this one because it is the knife I carry the least.



There was a time when I carried it every day... for 5 months. Things came up though... projects I have been waiting on for some time. Those projects need funds.

I'll carry it for ya. Send ya pics for the family album too. :D
 
I'm kind of surprized I don't have a sebenza yet. One thing that has really slowed down my knife purchases is I'm getting older now and don't have any heirs. I have a lot of cool stuff and other than my significant other, nobody to leave them to when I croak.

I would gladly and graciously inherit your "cool stuff" :)
 
I'm a confirmed knife slut...I want them all. :D
Whether it's $50 or $700, if I can scrounge the cash somehow, it will be mine, if I like the looks and function of it.

Slowing down? Pffft, I'm just getting started! :thumbup:

Me too. Although so far I haven't spent more than $500 on a knife.

I generally live around the $150 to $250 range, my favorites being my two CRK's (a large Sebenza 21 Unique, and a Zaan), Zt, and Emerson. Just got a ZT 0452cf, Emerson Combat Fighter, and an Al Mar SERE 2000 this week.

So to answer the question: no, I don't see myself slowing down any time soon. However, I don't feel the need to justify my knife purchases other than the fact that I enjoy collecting and using them.

Everyone needs something in life to enjoy and occupy themselves with, or what's the point. If knife collecting is causing you more worry than enjoyment, then maybe it's not the hobby for you.
 
Ok, here's my journey, with a little backstory:
I have always been drawn to knives. Always. Since I was a little bitty boy. The first one I ever bought was a stiletto shaped knife with a 1.5" blade that said "coca-cola" on the handle. I was 5 years old and my ol man let me buy it at a gun show we went to.
Up until I joined BF, I'd had a few nice knives. I always liked to have the best I could afford for what I needed. I found bladeforums while searching for info on knives. It kept coming up in the search engines. This was a LONG time ago. (Back when the site had first started) I kept telling myself I didn't want to join because I didn't want to get "addicted to knives like the rest of the yahoos on here" (seriously)...
I finally gave in and joined. I had lurked a long time and it just felt right to join somehow.
When I joined bladeforums, it was all over. I bought more knives in a few months than I had ever owned before. I bought a knife for every size, every use, had to have all the hottest newest folders, etc.
I finally just hit a wall, I guess you could say. I had knives coming out of my ears. I had so many knives (that were meant to last a lifetime) that I'd need several lifetimes to use them all. I just felt overburdened by it all. I felt ridiculous. I felt like I had turned something I loved, and something I had invested money and time in into a parody of itself.
I sold off everything I didn't use first. Next I sold off multiples of things I had in different sizes (even if I used em). In other words - I had a couple of 3" to 5" blade folders instead of tons of them, I had a couple small fixed blades, a couple large ones, etc.
After I coasted like that for a while I finally decided I didn't even need a couple of each size range. I sold off even further and kept what was MY personal cream of the crop. I was so content with this that I've been there ever since. I might buy a knife here and there to see if it can dethrone one of my keepers, but they hardly ever do.
I was so content with my collection (which really is just a "collection" of tools that I use, so I don't consider it much of a collection) that I didn't buy any knives at all for 5 years.
I guess I still get the itch now and then, and it's all thanks to you crazy fellers. Thanks. (And I really, sincerely mean that. Thank you.)
 
Last edited:
Using/collecting or acquiring knives is about having fun. The hunt, the purchase and finally the possession. Once it is no longer fun, for whatever reason, then it's time to re evaluate why one started this whole knife thing. If it's time for a change, then so be it. IMO everyone that has an addiction to knives performs a purge, whether it's out of guilt, not being able to justify several lifetimes of knives on hand or simply getting bored of having a bunch of knives.
Thank God I'm not there yet, but I know it's coming one day, but not today. I'm still having too much fun.

Absolutely Agree 100%......
 
I pared down my knife collection by 3/4 and my gun collection by 1/2 over the last two years. Now I have exactly what I want, set up exactly how I want them, and all of it I have a use for. Much more satisfying.

Plus, I bought a bike with the proceeds, set it up how I want it, and put money in the bank.

Ditto - sort of.

I got rid of all but what I consider my most essential guns, which by most standards isn't too shabby. I got rid of the sks because I didn't really shoot it and it's kind of heavy, now that I have a couple ar15's. I got rid of a couple revolvers, I kept my favorites. I trimmed my glocks down two my two favorites. I have my 30;30 and 308 for hunting. And a shotgun selection plus .22's. Overall I think I have a nice versatile collection for target shooting and hunting. I can even use my little savage .22's with CB shorts in my backyard for pest elimination and it's no louder than my pellet guns.

But here is the important thing. Years ago when I saw the writing on the wall - I started stocking up on ammo. Guns can be reused, but they need ammo. I actually considered reloading at one point but I don't shoot enough to warrant all that and have family that reloads.

I purchased quality items years ago while the economy was good, I'm getting closer to retirement so this will pay off now. I never have to purchase ammo, I have nice knives, good prep stuff, spare parts for things . . . Tools. And knowledge.

I still have interests and hobbies but can enjoy them with a tighter budget. My main concern is home upkeep in the next few years so I'm trying to put some aside for that. I'm going to restore a little jonboat soon that I got for free, that should be fun. It only needs a new transom and a motor.

The old me would have just gotten a new one but the new me is a little more choosy about where my money goes. I'm glad I was old enough to enjoy myself before prosperity turned into austerity. I feel sorry for young folks these days, they don't know what they missed. This is "normal" for them. When people don't know things are supposed to be better they quit trying and just accept the status quo.

But I'm getting off track. I'm kind of depressed because I don't have much faith in the future. I think things will get worse before they get better.
 
Back
Top