Why is the Compact so expensive?

Joined
Mar 22, 2022
Messages
2,584
The Compact costs way too much for a 2 layer celidor model. I think we've been letting Victorinox get away with overpricing it for far too long.

I know that demand for the Compact is high. Sometimes it's hard to find in stock. The issue is that there's nothing so special about the Compact which should be preventing Victorinox from increasing its production to meet the demand for it.

I think Victorinox has been pulling an Apple move on us, which is to say that they are deliberately overpricing something while artificially keeping production of it low in order to create scarcity, which in turn increases the perception of its value.

Conspiracy fiction, or conspiracy fact? 👁️ 👁️

x-files opening theme song
 
I think it's pricier in the US than other regions. I know I pay about 14% less than you.

I think it is special in one way or another. I don't like the 91 mm models very much, & the compact is by far my favorite of those. It's a good SAK.

I have two, one is still brand new..
 
Yeah they’re overpriced by comparison with the other 91mm models.
Basic supply and demand I guess. Popular since they pack a punch in a small package. Retailers catch wind of the demand and work it.
I just saw it listed for $75 on the biggest retail site.

As far as factory conspiracy, I doubt it.
Hard to think they chose the this model to corner the market.

Personally, if I need a minimalist folder I go with the 58mm Classic SD. Does mostly anything the ‘compact’ does, while is truly compact.
If I want a 91mm model, I go straight to Champ/Champion. It covers all my expected and unexpected needs from a pocket tool.
With a good pouch on my belt, I forget is there till I need it.

Anything in between is a compromise and doesn’t really do it for me,
since I always seem to need a tool thats missing on those 2,3,4,5 layered models.
 
Maybe the opposite? Maybe they don't make as many as other smaller frame models? Maybe the scissors and pen?
I love mine, it's my going to town SAK. I'd like to see it in Black and Translucent Blue.
 
I think Victorinox ‘pushes’ some models for a better margin per sale while for some other models, they make money by volumes sold.

A 84mm Recruit doesn’t ‘cost’ Victorinox more to make than a 91mm Compact, yet the former costs about 17 euro while the latter costs at least double the price. Even a Classic costs more than a Recruit these days.

Whatever the model, Victorinox price levels are very fair in my opinion. You always get a great quality product that will last a lifetime.
 
Let's look at what makes the Compact unique.

1. Combo bottle/can opener tool. This is a short relatively thin tool that's just like any other tool on a SAK in terms of production. If anything, the combo tool is probably saving Victorinox a ton of money on production costs because it's easier to make one combo tool that eliminates four other tools (the small blade, the can opener, the bottle opener, and the awl are all excluded whenever the combo tool is included) than it is to make all 4 of those other tools, plus the extra backspring and the extra liner that go along with them. 3 of those tools also have to be sharpened as well, while the combo tool does not.

2. Parcel hook with nail file. This is nothing special either. Victorinox has been putting that same exact nail file texture on several different tools for decades. It's been said countless times, but I'll repeat it here anyway: there is no reason at all that Victorinox should not be putting that texture on every single parcel hook going forward. It's trivial. They've done it thousands of times a day on average to every Cadet, Classic SD, Minichamp, Money Clip / Ambassador, Sportsman, and whatever other obscure or discontinued models that I'm leaving out. It's nothing new or mind blowing or costly to do.

3. It comes with a straight pin. Wow, those are super expensive, right? No, they're not. They cost pennies to make and Victorinox charges around a dollar each for them if you want to buy them separately. YAWN. So lame. I can buy a whole box of straight pins that are more corrosion resistant for only a few dollars. That box will last me a lifetime. I'll be dead long before I can manage to run out of straight pins. Every 91mm SAK has the same exact straight pin slot too.

4. It has an extra slot in the back scale for a pen. Okay this is actually ridiculous. First of all, the extra space for the back slot means that the scale probably uses slightly less material. In terms of production, this scale is no different either. It's literally made from a mold just like every other celidor scale. When it comes to the pen itself, it's not even stainless steel. The main body isn't even ferrous! And what is it exactly? It's a small, cheap, pressurized pen insert. It's not fundamentally different than any other pen refill, except that it has an end cap that's shaped to match the outer contour of the back scale. That's it.

5. The mini screwdriver is included. Honestly, that's pretty great. I love the mini screwdriver. I wish Victorinox would make a version of the mini screwdriver with a ring on the back end so I could attach it directly to my key chain. But is the inclusion of the mini screwdriver worth the extra cost of the Compact? No. Not even close.


Any way I look at it, the extra cost of the Compact over many other 91mm models simply can't be justified. For those of you in Europe, the price difference probably isn't too bad. Here in the States, the difference can be pretty outrageous.
 
Have to agree with Guy McVer the Compact is way too expensive for what it is, no way should it cost more then the Climber for it's reduced capabilities.
 
The location where you live makes all the difference. I live in Europe and can buy any model easily for very fair prices. Even the so-called “discontinued” 74mm models I can buy easily. A Compact would cost me about 35 euro.
 
I’m not a fan: but I used to be. I think it’s only about a 10% premium for the pin and tiny screwdriver and the pen included.
Not too bad really. Pick another model change the scales, add the extras see how much it costs you. Here it's maybe £3 quid more than
Super Tinker. However if you shop around you can pay another £25 for it if it makes you happy.

The Pin thing is ridiculous £2.85 from The big V or add 14p for a tin of 500.
 
Last edited:
I really don’t get it. People religiously pay massive amounts of money for certain electronic devices with a piece of fruit on the backside and never complain. Items that last at most 10 years when you really, really push it.

Now look at the Victorinox Compact. It will cost you 50 euro/USD or so at most when you accept a bad deal (because it can be had for less if you shop around). You get an impeccable tool, made to the highest standards. With a little care, that Compact will last you a lifetime. And it can even be passed down to the next generation. Furthermore, the fine folks over in Ibach-Schwyz will repair that SAK for you for free, no questions asked, should a problem ever arise. In spite of all of this, people complain because it cost a little more than a basic Spartan or Camper. Unbelievable.
 
Now look at the Victorinox Compact. It will cost you 50 euro/USD or so at most when you accept a bad deal (because it can be had for less if you shop around).
No, it's worse than that. Way worse. It keeps going up. Victorinox alone is selling them for 58 usd now, and that's before taxes and shipping costs. I've seen them starting to approach 70 usd in some instances, and anecdotally I've heard upwards of 70. That's insane.

50 usd would already be too much. Hell, 45 usd is too much, but that's considered a good deal for the Compact now. What I don't understand is why anyone would try making excuses for this crap. They're a business, not your friend.

edit:
I've just looked on amazon and they're 79 usd. Amazon usually has decent deals on SAKs. A while back I bought a new Huntsman on there (4 layers) for 25 usd.
nope.jpg
 
Last edited:
No, it's worse than that. Way worse. It keeps going up. Victorinox alone is selling them for 58 usd now, and that's before taxes and shipping costs. I've seen them starting to approach 70 usd in some instances, and anecdotally I've heard upwards of 70. That's insane.

50 usd would already be too much. Hell, 45 usd is too much, but that's considered a good deal for the Compact now. What I don't understand is why anyone would try making excuses for this crap. They're a business, not your friend.
Now you know how we feel about knives like ESEE costing twice as much as yours. 😄
 
To be clear, I refer to prices in the European Union, where I live. I understand that prices in the US will be higher. I can’t buy a Case for US prices over here either.

My general point however is that Victorinox is not and never was a company that tries to rip off their costumers. Their pricing is very fair. You’re paying the middle man.
 
Back
Top