I decided to put this in a new thread, rather than to hijack
the other one. An issue has bugged me for quite a while, and my 31 year old son is an example of it.
I grew up in the country, on a small farm in a family of cotton mill hands. There were so many things that we just seemed to grow up knowing. About most of them I have no sense of a beginning or learning point, they were just part of our lives. Things like: how to use tools, how to sharpen knives, how to build fires and cook, how to trap, sleep out at night, run a trot-line, tree and plant identification, outdoor navigation, slaughtering and butchering animals from chickens and rabbits up through hogs. I cannot remember a time, even when very young, when I did not carry a good knife and have ready access to firearms.
Where do kids learn these things anymore? Some people might consider them anachronisms but they can still quickly become essential life skills in the right situations.
My son decided eary in life that he was an athelete. Physically gifted, he tried it all, from team sports to track and wrestling. That was his only interest. I could never interest him in hunting, fishing, the outdoors. Tried Boy Scouts one year but he was indifferent to it. I have skills that he might one day badly need, and he has absolutely no desire to learn them.
The best possible sources I can think of for such experiences are, to grow up surrounded by it as I was, an interested adult or friend (but you have to have the desire to absorb it), and Boy Scouts (which in some locales has been terribly watered down), and possibly the military.
My former employer, a large electric utility, had a procedure for testing possible new hires into labor classifications. It is amazing how many physically impressive specimens wash out because they do not know even the most simple tool use. I watched a large, athletic looking young guy as he was totally baffled trying to dig a hole with hole diggers, and healthy young people who could not cope with climbing a high platform on a long extention ladder and lowering a bucket full of rocks on a rope to ground level, things that I have no doubt I could easily do even now at age 62. It was unbelievable how many people that somewhat 'springy' ladder washed out.
It is great that some people are still interested and that such resources as "Wilderness and Survival Skills" exist, although they do tend to deal inordinately in minutiae.
More power to them, I just wish that more people (like my son) cared about this stuff.
the other one. An issue has bugged me for quite a while, and my 31 year old son is an example of it.
I grew up in the country, on a small farm in a family of cotton mill hands. There were so many things that we just seemed to grow up knowing. About most of them I have no sense of a beginning or learning point, they were just part of our lives. Things like: how to use tools, how to sharpen knives, how to build fires and cook, how to trap, sleep out at night, run a trot-line, tree and plant identification, outdoor navigation, slaughtering and butchering animals from chickens and rabbits up through hogs. I cannot remember a time, even when very young, when I did not carry a good knife and have ready access to firearms.
Where do kids learn these things anymore? Some people might consider them anachronisms but they can still quickly become essential life skills in the right situations.
My son decided eary in life that he was an athelete. Physically gifted, he tried it all, from team sports to track and wrestling. That was his only interest. I could never interest him in hunting, fishing, the outdoors. Tried Boy Scouts one year but he was indifferent to it. I have skills that he might one day badly need, and he has absolutely no desire to learn them.
The best possible sources I can think of for such experiences are, to grow up surrounded by it as I was, an interested adult or friend (but you have to have the desire to absorb it), and Boy Scouts (which in some locales has been terribly watered down), and possibly the military.
My former employer, a large electric utility, had a procedure for testing possible new hires into labor classifications. It is amazing how many physically impressive specimens wash out because they do not know even the most simple tool use. I watched a large, athletic looking young guy as he was totally baffled trying to dig a hole with hole diggers, and healthy young people who could not cope with climbing a high platform on a long extention ladder and lowering a bucket full of rocks on a rope to ground level, things that I have no doubt I could easily do even now at age 62. It was unbelievable how many people that somewhat 'springy' ladder washed out.
It is great that some people are still interested and that such resources as "Wilderness and Survival Skills" exist, although they do tend to deal inordinately in minutiae.
More power to them, I just wish that more people (like my son) cared about this stuff.