Would a lack of filework be a dealbreaker here?

I'd leave it, I like file work on the right knife like an HH Frank piece but this one looks right without it. It looks more organic this way, I feel file work would take away from the rest of the knife.

I just looked again and I think the scales and liners are too thin and the file work would have to be too fine to show off any detail. If you're set on doin' it and it sounds like you'd rather not do some tasteful work to the bolsters.

That's a refined piece with prehistoric bent.
 
Nice folder as is, however IMO a tastefully designed filework pattern, well executed would elevate this piece.
I believe knifemakers are wise to have concern over what collectors prefer, especially if they count on sales of their knives
for income.
 
I am a fan of well done file work. That being said, this knife has enough going on and is fantastic as is. I doubt you'll have trouble finding a buyer either way. I'd call it done.
 
Pretty nice the way it is, Lon. Maybe a little something with the back spacer but your choice of materials already has a lot going on. Sweet looking knife!

Walt
 
I like it a LOT as-is. Filework just seems like a way to attract corrosion on a carbon steel piece, unless on the spine of the handle and filled with epoxy. I find too many fancy folders to be far too visually busy, and I like what you've done with this one by limiting the visual elements.
 
I like how the color of the spacer matches the outer hue of the scales. I won't break that striped look.
A kerf down the lenght imho should be fading toward the blade and should be made with a round file.
 
This is one of my early folders. I think this fluting is a clean way to break up a large expanse of backspacer. Also, there is a difference in surface finishes; the flute is polished but the spacer is satin (I even jeweled a backspacer once).

Bob

20150817_182753 by Bob, on Flickr
 
stezann said:
i like how the color of the spacer matches the outer hue of the scales. I won't break that striped look.
a kerf down the lenght imho should be fading toward the blade and should be made with a round file.
Click to expand...

yes ^
 
I personally love file work, but not every knife should carry it. It really comes down to what your vision for this piece is. What did you picture going into it?

Zieg
 
Bob Ohlemann said:
This is one of my early folders. I think this fluting is a clean way to break up a large expanse of backspacer. Also, there is a difference in surface finishes; the flute is polished but the spacer is satin (I even jeweled a backspacer once).
Click to expand...

Bob,
Thank you for sharing that one. That's really nice work! Simple and clean lines which is what I was going for. I also considered jeweling the backspacer and I might try that out as well.
 
Odog27 said:
I am a fan of well done file work. That being said, this knife has enough going on and is fantastic as is. I doubt you'll have trouble finding a buyer either way. I'd call it done.
Click to expand...

I totally agree with you on that.
Rob
 
Personally, I'm not into all the file work either. William Henry Fine Knives does not finish off their knives with file work... I like the look, it's clean, simple, and the materials and finish speak for themselves. It's how I would produce a gentleman's folder.

Paul
 
'File work' is as variable quality as a 'handmade knife'. I can't assume your work (which we haven't seen) will do the job.

I have seen some of the most eyepopping patterns totally elevating a piece, :) and I have seen repetitive and simplistic patterns, done poorly, to degrade a piece. :(

It's already REALLY busy with patterns in the blade, bolster and handle. This plays a role. At this point less IS more! Good piece.

I'd love to see you create a knife with less busy materials, and then add in your best filework pattern. At that point you can show your clients their choices. :thumbup:

Good thread.

Coop
 
I think some abstract lines or a Diamond patern filework could work with the knife, but small and subtle, certainly not the whole backspace.

Verstuurd vanaf mijn ONEPLUS A3003 met Tapatalk
 
SharpByCoop said:
'File work' is as variable quality as a 'handmade knife'. I can't assume your work (which we haven't seen) will do the job.

I have seen some of the most eyepopping patterns totally elevating a piece, :) and I have seen repetitive and simplistic patterns, done poorly, to degrade a piece. :(

It's already REALLY busy with patterns in the blade, bolster and handle. This plays a role. At this point less IS more! Good piece.

I'd love to see you create a knife with less busy materials, and then add in your best filework pattern. At that point you can show your clients their choices. :thumbup:

Good thread.

Coop
Click to expand...


My sentiments, EXACTLY!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top