>>which stone did you get?
Cheapo coarse/fine combo stone from Ace hardware & honing oil.
>>did you raise a burr?
Yes
>>does knife wobble as you make passes?
Actually the blade kept grabbing into the stone going in one direction.
Other direction was fine.
Too much angle?
I did a really good job of turning a semi sharp blade dull.
>>how did you find angle? permanent marker trick? guess?
Used a sharpie & folded paper to estimate 20 degree angle.
>>how long did you rub one side of the knife on the stone?
@ 30 passes each side
>>one minute? two minutes? ... how many minutes to do 300 passes?
did not get this far; seemed like any sharpening effort was proceeding in the wrong direction
Yeah maybe I need to give this another try.
I am having a really hard time working around the curve of the blade as it extends into the tip.
Appreciate the advice. Will give it another shot this weekend.
Hi,
you're doing pretty good
and that stone is reportedly pretty flat (good thing)
Yes, when the blade starts digging into the stone, back down the angle a little bit
Its very common in freehand for everybody,
one side angle a little higher ,
other side a little lower,
as long as you remember to adjust, you'll get there
30 passes to raise a burr sounds like angle is sufficiently high/elevated
that you're basically microbeveling from the start,
and if that angle is ~20 degrees, thats great
so when you switch to other side,
back down the angle a bit, and do matching number of passes (like 20), and check if the burr has flipped
when it does flip, double the angle,
do 40 degrees per side,
and do 1-2 real light alternating edge leading passes to cut the burr off,
as long as you made contact with the stone
it should now slice real well , maybe a bit noisy
it should also shave
following that back down to 20 degrees
and do alternating edge leading single passes
do five of them per side, then check slicing paper,
when it stops being so noisy stop, you're done,
dont go too much past 10 passes per side,
you might need to deburr again
For sharpening the tip, rotate/pivot the blade, like you do when cutting with knife,
follow the curve, make sure edge is contacting stone (look)
here is animation of how to orient the blade to the stone
whether you're doing scrubbing passes or one direction only passes,
just follow the curve, 90 to the stone, and when you do,
look to see that the edge is contacting the stone,
going away from yourself, look for daylight to diappear, shadow means contact
yes this means tilting the handle a little or pressing the edge with your other hand
but looking with your eyes is what you should focus on
Here is an example of a very recent video
[video=youtube;oRmcQ-MqbBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRmcQ-MqbBE[/video]
If that doesn't feel right, you can always go vertical to deburr/microbevel,
by leaning your sharpening stone against a wall or book to make a
bench stone sharmaker and just slice down the stone and pivot for tip