I made a post there a few days ago which was similar to one I posted here listing my three favorite new knives from the SHOT show. Because I had provided links to our site so people could see images and descriptions of those products, I got an unfriendly email from the owner explaining that my post was too commercial because it promoted our site. He said it was inappropriate for me to enter the forum and not contribute something by responding to a question. I had responded elsewhere to a question on another thread with no links to our site because it wasn't appropriate for that response. This particular post was a response to a similar post the unfriendly owner had entered himself about new knives at the SHOT show. I didn't say I didn't like the ones he had mentioned. I just mentioned a few that I thought were important and interesting to me. I don't suggest my opinion is any better than anybody else's. I was just expressing mine for whatever anybody thinks it's worth. I thought people might like to see what they look like and my site already has images so I provided a link.
Naturally, I'm always interested in promoting our site but my post was meant to be informative even though it was nothing more than an expression of my opinion. Most posts on the forums are expressions of opinion anyway. I didn't ask anybody to order anything. I simply said that I liked a few new knives that I saw at the show and anyone interested could go to our site for images and descriptions of them. Going there was purely optional and, as the logs indicate, quite a few people did go there using the links. So I guess I didn promote the site.
I like to think our site is a useful resource for information about knives as well as being an on-line store. Yes, it's commercial. Knife Forums, as you know, is a commercial site also just like BladeForums.
I certainly felt discouraged about posting anything else there and it reversed a decision I had already made to buy a banner ad on the site. One forum is enough for me anyway since my time is definitely limited. Sorry for the rant. Take care.
------------------
Fred
Knife Outlet
http://www.knifeoutlet.com