I go back and forth between collecting and using. I buy a bunch of knives I like; some humble, some what I consider "nice". ($250 range)
Then, I look at my collection and realize there's a lot of duplication there, get disgusted with myself and have a big sell-off. After a couple years, the knife knut in me comes out of remission and I start again.
I bought myself a nice knife with the intent for it to be my main carry knife. It's a Benchmade Griptilian with the gray G10 scales, blue liners and barrel spacers and 20CV blade. I carried it for a week or two, then I felt like it was too heavy and bulky for my needs. Went back to a 2 layer SAK and went into remission again.
Each time I go through the cycle, I learn a bit about myself. I don't find myself carrying the Griptilian because it's big & heavy, not because it's "too nice". Part of its being nice is that it's robust enough to carry and use every day and will not wear out. Sure, it will SHOW some wear, but this isn't a stamp or coin. It's a KNIFE; a tool. What I learned about myself this time is that weight DOES matter and a knife with a blade that's big enough to cut fruit is likely going to feel too big at some point. So this time, I'm heavily into Spyderco Lightweights. They're robust enough and nice enough, but still very thin & light. The ones I'm favoring now are:
- Delica
- Leaf Jumper
- Native
- Manix 2 (next)
Back to the OP: Force yourself to carry and use that Norseman for a couple weeks. Develop a bond with it. Accept that it'll pick up signs of carry and use and remember that one of the reasons you bought it is that it can take this in stride. Yeah, it'll lose resale value, but again, this isn't a stamp collection.