Sounds like you had a bad fit. Did you mail-order them? And you still had them for years?
I had a pair and they were forgettable (which is a good thing for boots when you forget you're wearing them.)
I'm partial to New Balance myself.
i got them in 12's bc 11's were too small. i dont think they had 1/2 sizes (this was years ago).. i kep them bc they were pricey and i didnt want to throw them away. so bundled up on the socks and wore them on days at work that i will not be walking much.. i was very displeased with them... the more i wore them the worse they got