Your Opinion on the BEST overall knife Company?!

Joined
Jan 5, 2006
Messages
329
Comparing knife companies is like comparing apples and oranges, but let's see what people think out there.

Here's what we'll judge by.

1) Quality of products (including design, materials and production).

2) Variety of products (including accessories and knife styles).

3) Business execution (meaning shipping dates, promotions, consumer options ect.).

4) Customer service.

Now I am a pretty big Kershaw fan and love the Ken Onions designs. I think they make a great quality products and know they have GREAT customer service. They have many different styles, including a wicked E.T.design. They could brush up on their accessories . .but other than that . .

Of all the companies out there, I feel that for me Kershaw has the edge.:thumbup:

Sure there is Spyderco and others with great products and I am sure good customer support. I don't know If I haven't look in the right spots, but I see and awful lot of attention from Kershaw (Thomas) here on this forum. That gets good marks in my book. Which makes me wonder why Kershaw isn't on the Manufactures Forum here?

Got a couple of favorite companies? Post them and tell us why!:)
 
Busse, Swamp Rat and Scrapyard Knife Co. in the customer service department are A-1! They have lifetime warranties, which is on top of a pretty indestructible knife in the first place.
 
AFAIK, no one company does everything, or even many things, in a world class manner.

Those that make slip joints tend not to make decent modern locking folders, or fixed blade knives.

I just wind up liking what I like and I do not care if a company has a "full" product line. I have the only Spydie that interested me. My one type of Buck is the 110. My only Benchmades are 806D2s and one of the red class locking filet knives. I have puukkos from makers who make nothing else. I have Ka-Bar fixed blades but the only folder they make that I bought is the Hobo.

I will now second Bark River Knife and Tool. They make many varieties of fixed bladed knives. If you time your purchase, you can customize yours in the context of the production run. Mine have been uniformally sharp, and have all exhibited great attention to detail. None of the five that I have now have ever given me the slightest twinge of buyer's remorse.

My customer service anecdote is this: I bought a curly maple handled Gameskeeper from DLT Trading. I took some pics of my new baby and posted them on the "other" forum. Mike Stewart himself said that the maple could be more curly looking than the scales on my knife. He told me to mail it in and he'd completely upgrade the scales to some fancier blanks of maple and mail it back. There was nothing defective about the knife whatsoever and he didn't have to redo it at all. I got the kife back inside of 10 days and it is the one knife that I am assured of that is now worth more than I paid for it because it got prettier wood for about $4.00
 
Spyderco, and, while I have no personal experience with them, I have a couple of friends that speak very highly of entrek. They aparently have the same warranty policy as the Busse, swamprat, scrapyard folks do.
 
Benchmade.

Then Spyderco.

Then a number of outfits that have strengths, but not the collection of strengths those two do.
 
Ill jsut say i trust sog, spyderco and benchmade a lot.


Buck has that classic american feel but ive no personal experience.
I loved my gerber knife but when a company starts moving too much production to china... i lose faith.
Of course there are others i trust but because of price or no experience or designs i dont like i just dont list them.
 
loving my kershaws at the moment...getting a buck soon and hear they are great. I hear kershaw's customer support is phenomenal.
 
SPYDERCO!
Stephan said:
Here's what we'll judge by.

1) Quality of products (including design, materials and production).

2) Variety of products (including accessories and knife styles).

3) Business execution (meaning shipping dates, promotions, consumer options ect.).

4) Customer service.

I'd first like to say, within the past few years, Kershaw has really amazed me, and is definitely a company worthy of 2nd place on my personal list of Knife Manufacturers.:thumbup:

As for my #1 choice in Knife Companies, Spyderco all the way!

1) Quality of products (including design(a), materials(b) and production(c)): You'd be really hard pressed to find a company with more emphasis on quality than Spyderco. Spyderco breaks (that's right, they have a knife-breaking machine) knives from each run to assure their high lock strength and security standards are consistantly met. Spyderco has one of the few CATRA machines around, and use it to further test their product. They utilize a Q-fog tester, to allow them to guage the corrosion-resistance of their products. Their warranty is exactly what they advertise it, "Fair, Honest, and Proper", and they back it up.

(a) Spyderco, alone, revitalized the custom collaboration trend that so many Knife Companies are following these days. Back in 1989, Spyderco was only the 2nd company to do a custom collaboration (Gerber had done some rather short-lived ones in the 70's & 80's), except Spyderco made it work long-term.
Spyderco and Bob Terzuola started a trend that hasn't cooled off to this day. Spyderco has some of the best designers in the industry working collaboratively with them, but as far as I'm concerned, they have the top two designers in the world working for them. Sal Glesser, Spyderco's Founder and President, and his son Eric, are in my opinion the best folding knife designers on the planet! With knife designs like the Military, the Para-Military, the Manix, the Dodo, the Stretch, and a host of others, lock designs like the compression lock and the ball-bearing lock, and a sharpening system design like the Tri-Angle Sharpmaker, I think most would agree that their designs are at the very least "top notch".
Just to add a final note to Spyderco's "designs", let's examine some of the design features of folding knives we often take for granted. 1) The pocket clip- A Spyderco design! 2) The blade-hole opener- A Spyderco design!

(b) Spyderco was the first production company to offer G-10 and ATS-34 on a folding knife! Spyderco is in constant search of the best materials for every facet of their knives. How many other production companies currently offer an affordable ZDP-189 bladed knife? How many other companies offer a rust-proof folding knife? How many other companies offer at least 5 different locking mechanisms/systems on their folding knives? I rest my case.

(c) Spyderco has an excellent facility stateside, in Golden, Colorado, where they employ some of the latest, greatest technology available to test and build knives. Spyderco also contracts with some of the most respected and skilled production knifemakers in Japan to produce their knives. Having split production like this is indeed a benefit to the consumer, since the Japanese will not allow blade-steel like VG10 and ZDP-189 to be made outside their facilities. Not only do we get the best bladesteel and other refinements the Japanese have, we get S30V, and top shelf American products as well.

2) Variety of products (including accessories and knife styles):
Spyderco started their business in the late 70's, manufacturing what many consider to be the best sharpening system around. They then branched off into producing knives. As far as variety of knives go, I don't think you'll find a company with as diverse a variety of folding knives anywhere. Fixed blade designs have only recently started to emerge, but boy are they emerging! Hossom is in collaboration them for an awesome design, and just wait until the Schempp fixed blades come out.

3) Business execution (meaning shipping dates, promotions, consumer options ect.).
Spyderco's business execution is absolutely awesome. I won't waste your time by listing the reasons, but if you are curious, check out Spyderco's forum here, or on their site (Spyderco.com), and you'll see why. Sal Glesser is still one of the only company Presidents who very frequently hangs out on the forums and solicits input from his customers. If you don't believe me, check his BladeForums member profile.

4) Customer service:
Fantastic on my end, but again, I would highly recommend you take a look at their forum to see for yourselves.

Best wishes,
3G
 
Wow 3G!!

What a great and informative post.

I was recently considering in investing in a Spyderco. In fact, the reason I first got into collecting knives was because of a Spyderco knife. I was working for pepsi and got tired of using the company box cutters. A firend heard my complaint and threw a spyderco at me and let me keep it. I believe it was a older model that kinda look like the police design only it had (I think) some sort of plastic handle.

A great knife that I loved so much that when I lost it (sucked) I had to replace it. Which is how I ended up buying my first knife from Kershaw. The Whirlwind, another great knife. Now I have 5 Kershaws and looking for more.

I've always wanted to get another spyderco . . soon!

Thanks for the info.
 
Back
Top