So that's OK?
I could come up with one that is insulting to Jews, to see if it gets the same reaction. But I really don't want to argue or offend anyone.
You miss my point. I wouldn't use that line about Abraham because it would be insulting to Muslims, although I love the line. I would make that point in PA but not as a sig because Muslims' sensitivities are just as important as anyone else's and why the Hell would we want to alienate any segment of the Knife Community?
This is, believe it or not, a business. Spark, wisely or unwisely ( unwisely) has entrusted its smooth running to Mods and superMods and conscientious members. He's not in business to offend people, at least not gratuitously. Free speech has to take a back seat to decency and being businesslike, and that's why we have PA: to keep the inflammatory stuff confined to a well regulated zoo.
This thread itself is starting to get people at each other's throats, which is really not productive, is it?
I think everyone has had a fair say, and far be it from me to tell people what to say or how much ( outside PA). Again, not my intent.
But can't we let the Supers etc discuss this more privately without all the heat and bad feelings?
Again, for the record I guess ( hello NSA!), Phil is no racist. If you want to discuss his views with him over on PA he will make sensible arguments for his opinions and although some are just wrong ( in my opinion) they are far from kneejerk hate, although in a sig line alone you easily could get the wrong impression.
I'm against the second one about all Muslims being quiescent and against the Abraham/Zionist one too, much as I love that one, simply out of courtesy for the feelings of our Muslim or potential Muslim members and friends, and as a matter of good business.
And with that, I've said my piece.