My Utica Cutlery Barlow arrived - will take pics later. First impressions:
Pro:
-fit and finish is perfect. Scales, pins, bolster are all flush. "Barlow" stamp is straight. Back springs are flush, no daylight between them.
-walk and talk are good enough. Main blade has a half stop. Blade snaps into open position, but it's a little mushy. Blades open and close easily enough, but not too easy.
-no blade play whatsoever in any direction
-tried to etch both blades with 5 minute diet coke bath. Main blade discolored a little bit, barely any discoloration on secondary. Pretty sure main blade is carbon steel, not so sure about secondary.
-both blades are razor sharp.
-cost less than $30 shipped
-made in USA
Cons:
-it's not a full sized Barlow, more like a mini Barlow. Would have cost around $35 for the full sized one.
-not convinced both blades are 1095 carbon (other reviews say they sometimes use stainless secondaries)
-good deal for $30, but a Chinese made Rough Rider mini Barlow with equivalent or better fit/finish would have cost like $7.
Overall I'm very pleased to have a good carbon steel American made knife in my pocket that I'm not afraid to lose. I wish I had spent a little more and gotafull sized barlow or trapper or stockman.