.

No one is complaining. I hope I get one without machine marks. If you hope you get one with machine marks all over it great, more power to you. To the original poster don't be afraid to say what you said. It would be different if you tried to return the knife, because you want it to have no flaws. I certainly didn't get that impression from what you posted.
OP yanked the original post, but it sure looked like the start of a complaint about Comp to me. I'm fine with the user finish as long as there are no chatter marks or grinder gremlins. If you're not okay with that, you shouldn't order Comp.

I was just trying to get some input as to what people thought might come on the V8... the DS8 CF or the SK CF. Since the V8 and the DS8 didn't have the disclaimer in the original description about the "light machining marks" that other descriptions had.
Not looking to get everybody's big boy panties wadded up.
No one knows what the finish on any Comp batch is going to look like until they start shipping. All we have to go on is Jerry's photos. You're new here, and probably didn't see what happened with the Comp finish complaints/rants in the past. None of us want Jerry to stop offering Comp again. If you don't like coatings (which I don't), its a fantastic option and a great value for $40 more than the coating, but its not s silky smooth satin finish.
 
Maybe I just wasn't paying attention at the time, but I don't recall seeing comp finish complaints/rants here. I was under the impression those came more in the form of complaints to the shop, probably combined with requests to have the finish prettied up.

The caveat to this is that the original competition finish, or competition grade, or whatever is was called at the time, didn't have the decarb removed and quickly acquired a coat of surface rust. I don't know that I'd call the discussions here about that complaints/rants, but there were certainly discussions and expressions of surprise that normally corrosion-resistant INFI rusted so easily. But after that was replaced with the new type of comp. finish, I don't recall seeing even "complaints" of that sort here.

But then again, there were a few years when I wasn't paying much attention, so my observations might not be worth much.

And a further disclaimer-- I ordered a couple of those original comp finish knives that rusted just sitting in a drawer, and I wasn't expecting that. However, since they were offered as straight out of the oven without any finishing other than a really sharp convex edge, I didn't think there was anything to complain about. I was curious though, and learned all about decarb on this forum. When I found out that TGLBs could be special ordered with comp finish, I was hesitant at first, but after learning the new competition finish had the decarb removed, I ordered the Daryl Dixon combo (Competition Finish with Tan and Black G10) and couldn't be happier with it. When I ordered my Butaniku, I asked for Competition Finish, but was told that they weren't doing it anymore and it couldn't even be special ordered. Even if I promised not to complain that it wasn't pretty enough.

When they finally get around to bring Baby Butaniku's back, I want mine in comp finish (if I can't have satin). I hope no one gives them cause to quit offering it before I get mine.
 
I would say Busse's advertising photo should represent what you can expect.

Are you suggesting that this....

Silent%20Knight%20Comp%20BT-X3.jpg


Doesn't look like....

img_2263-jpg.871906


img_4338-jpg.873877


:(
 
The stock photo almost looks bead blasted to me but lighting makes a world of difference when taking photos of a bare blade. I know that whenever I strip, blast and rub down one of mine and want to share it here it always amazes me how different the same knife can look from pic to pic.
 
If I didn't know the SK's were new, I would swear they had been pretty used already. I want to be the one to put the first scratches on my knives. :(
 
I would say Busse's advertising photo should represent what you can expect.

Yes! Thank you boring boring this IS the real problem imho. The stock photos Busse puts out in their threads and especially in their emails look like Satin Finish and are advertising as Competition Finish. This leads to unrealistic expectations in the minds of some of us customers. Yeh, MOST of us on the forum know what to expect when we order CF, if we have read anything at all about it or looked at photos, when they were still available (FU PB :mad::rolleyes:) but someone new to Busse or not on the forum regularly or at all, who only receives the emails, yeh, the pics look satin and the discription is CF. If I was Busse Combat I’d put the blade with the most machine marks I could possibly find in the email newsletters pics, then if they came out better people who aren’t on here much or at all could be pleasantly surprised! Under promise, over deliver! ;) That is a good rule for a happier public perception! :)

And before I get blasted :D, I LOVE the CF and have ordered it on every blade I was ordering on which it was available. I want it to be around a long long time. I think positive public perception will help with that, and I think realistic photos would help with that! :thumbsup::thumbsup: Just my 2cents fellas and it’s probably worth what ya paid for it! :D
 
A CF finish is basically a great deal and good luck on a strip job. For the money you get a killer stripper finish underneath. Props to Jerry for offering CF for peanuts more than coated.
 
Are you suggesting that this....

Silent%20Knight%20Comp%20BT-X3.jpg


Doesn't look like....

img_2263-jpg.871906


img_4338-jpg.873877


:(


I ordered mySK in CF knowing it was luck of the draw, some will have more marks, some less. The stock photos are obviously some of the cleaner ones and beautifully photographed.

CF is raw naked infi goodness, love it or leave it at the trow or throw it up on the xchange, but please dont be the pooper of the CF party :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
The competition finish has light machining marks.
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/poll-should-busse-discontinue-the-competition-finish.1103780/

My way of thinking is this is really just a miscommunication between Busse and some ill-educated customers.

It seems like it could be solved very easily by creating a 'check box' where the customer ordering the comp finish must acknowlege that they are aware that the comp finish is an incomplete finish which will have grind and manufacturing lines.

Seems like a very easy fix...


Prior to the comp finish being an option I had to strip the coating off of my users myself. I'd rather just order them that way from Busse...
 
Last edited:
The competition finish has light machining marks.


My way of thinking is this is really just a miscommunication between Busse and some ill-educated customers.

It seems like it could be solved very easily by creating a 'check box' where the customer ordering the comp finish must acknowlege that they are aware that the comp finish is an incomplete finish which will have grind and manufacturing lines.

Seems like a very easy fix...


Prior to the comp finish being an option I had to strip the coating off of my users myself. I'd rather just order them that way from Busse...

Wow ill-educated.. really?

I have bought several comp Busse since the day that it was still a standard option and it was "free" For example a couple of TGLB that has those free comp finish are much prettier than these SK...

And saying those machine mark are easily fix mean you dont know much about how knife making really work... those machine line need some serious surface grinding to fix out and in order to do that you need to remove handle too. DIY handsand high likely to make it looks worse... when the advertising picture looks so differently to a real one I think everyone has right to complain as customer...


 
The competition finish has light machining marks.


My way of thinking is this is really just a miscommunication between Busse and some ill-educated customers.

It seems like it could be solved very easily by creating a 'check box' where the customer ordering the comp finish must acknowlege that they are aware that the comp finish is an incomplete finish which will have grind and manufacturing lines.

Seems like a very easy fix...


Prior to the comp finish being an option I had to strip the coating off of my users myself. I'd rather just order them that way from Busse...
Incomplete is what I took from that whole paragraph. Don't show a picture of perfection and then sell incomplete. The market will only bear so much, then sales start dropping off. It isn't necessarily that the price goes up. Could be profits start going down. I love em, but everyone does have their limits. Normally my limit is $80 for g10 upgrade. I did go that route for the last tg offering. Others I have passed on because of it. Just saying. Eat bacon and lets drink. I am drinking beam and cola. What you got?...hehe
 
I've grown accustomed to the machine marks I've found beneath the coating of my strippers so $40 for a gremlin free guarantee is well worth it to me all by itself. The only thing I will miss about coated blades is not being able to put a nice deep etch on the logo.
 
There are actually about 3 or 4 generation of "Comp Finish" that we are aware of, the original (with decarb still on and known for the rusting decarb layer) the next and longest running that saw the decarb removed but all that raw goodness (and perhaps some gremlins and imperfections - the TGLB was the last of the blades to get this I think) then the interim with the comp finish we saw available on the SOBs (love this one) and the current that is a mix of (IMHO) our old comp and the BIG finish. Comp went away because people were returning Comp Finished blades (most probably the TGLBs as they were sold en-mass) being unhappy with the imperfections. I LOVE Comp Finish and hope it is here to stay. I would love it to go back to that we saw on the TGLB and SOBs but those days are passed sadly.



 
I like the dimples on the flats, at least like your SOB, better than the machining marks. I had a SHE2 that was stripped and polished by Josh @ REK and that thing was HEAVILY dimpled.
 
All I’m saying is, in case I was unclear the first time:rolleyes:, is we kind of had this discussion already when the MountainManDu photos came out. It is obvious that the same exact photo was used for both the Satin and CF photos. And the blade in the photo is satin finish. The logos are photoshopped and the zoom angle changed. Don’t take my word for it brothers, as always, do your own research! :)

And I hope you all will do so before further posting on this topic! Here are the threads:

https://www.bladeforums.com/threads...n-to-the-mountainmandu.1538892/#post-17675514

https://www.bladeforums.com/threads...ednesday-12-13-17-specs-pics-pricing.1538750/

Yeh, ultimately I hope the Busse customers have reasonable expectations about the CF and therefore it will be around a long time! :):thumbsup::thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top